some thoughts on mccoy...
it is true that being the heir apparent doesn't guarantee westbrook-like production, but he could produce less and still be valuable.
due to splitting time with duce staley earlier in his career, and correl buckhalter (when he wasn't on IR with a knee injury), and questions about whether he could withstand the punishment of a more prominent role (subsequently shown to be unfounded), westbrook only had more than 617 rushing yards once in his first four seasons.
when he broke out in his fifth season, he was 27. mccoy is only 21, and looks like he could be well ahead of schedule to become the "feature RB" relative to westbrook.
westbrook had more than 3 rushing TDs just once in that same first four season time frame (pre-27), and has had more than 7 rushing TDs (which he has done three times) just once (9 last season).
where it will be hard to keep up is as a receiver. westbrook is one of the best receiving RBs i've seen in the past few decades, along with marshall faulk and reggie bush. all of them could be split out and deployed like WRs, run WR routes, have WR hands (imagine any of them in the old ATL red gun that had eric metcalf, bert emanual, terrance mathis, etc).
after his second year, he had 600-700+ receiving yards the next four seasons (falling off to 400+ last year)... after his rookie year, he had 4-6 receiving TDs every season through 2008.
mccoy, who has started a few games when westbrook was out and shared carries otherwise, is pacing for about 700 rushing yards, 4 rushing TDs and 300+ receiving yards. he isn't as big or physical as westbrook, who had deceptive strength and especially lower body power, as well as superb contact balance and tackle breaking ability (at his best, you never saw westbrook get arm tackled).
like knowshon moreno and donald brown, mccoy has above average hands (probably a big reason reid thought he would be a perfect fit in their offense, and made a lot of sense as heir apparent to westbrook), the drops against the Cowboys notwithstanding. and it should be added, reid has proven he likes to throw to RBs. mccoy could be a bigger beneficiary in the future. they are among the best in the business in the screen game.
some seem unimpressed, but i liked the big plays in recent weeeks (60+ yarder for a TD two weeks ago, and a 40+ yarder against DAL).
it will sound like sacrilege, but when i saw his prep and collegiate highlights, in his movement skills, lateral quickness and agilty, vision and instincts, ability to set up blockers, elusiveness and overall open field running ability, he reminded me a : LITTLE : of gale sayers. i'm not saying he is anywhere close to that good, just certain ways he eluded tacklers were at times reminiscent for me. he has a very smooth, under control, gliding running style. for more recent vintage comp players, i think he is bigger than warrick dunn and a bit smaller but similar in size to tiki barber (again, not making exact comparisons on a one-to-one correspondence level, but there could be similarities in physical traits/skill set).
also, if desean jackson and maclin are as good as they look, the eagles could be around the goal line a lot in the future. though smaller than moreno and brown (and a lot smaller than beanie wells from the RB class of '09), he was a highly effective scorer at Pitt.
* is there a consensus on how long is it thought westbrook will remain the starter in PHI? does mccoy inherit the mantle as soon as next season? 2011?
** like virtually all young RBs, he needs to mature physically, and to be coached up and put in a lot of hard work to become more technically sound in blitz pickup and pass protection. i have no doubt reid has already impressed on him the need to get that critically important component done before he can begin to play an even bigger role in the offense, and i think he will help him get there.
*** another factor to look at here in this context could be durability... westbrook has missed at least one game in every season (four times), two, three and four games once each prior to 2009, and already three games this season. he has missed 16 games (the equivalent to a season, when put like that) spread over 7 1/2 seasons, more than 2 per season. IF mccoy can avoid injury better, that could also help close the scoring gap... partly neutralizing the talent gap through sheer numbers, by potentially suiting up more consistently.
**** a couple reports (pre/post-draft) from one of my favorite RB (& IDP) scouting profilers, "IDP" tony nowak of FFT...
LeSean McCoy (Pittsburgh – 2SO) 5’11” 204
Combine Invite: Yes
"After a record-breaking freshman year, expectations were high for McCoy and Pitt, who went in to the season with a Top-25 ranking. Both got out of the gate slow when Bowling Green came to town for the season opener and upset the Panthers by containing McCoy. He finished with 71 yards at a 3.1 ypc clip with no run over 12 yards, but did score an 11-yard TD on the opening drive and had five receptions for 45 yards. The following week, he scored all three TDs for the Panthers on short runs in a close victory over a surprising Buffalo squad. He was seven yards short of his first 100 yard rushing game, but went over 100 all-purpose yards again with a 24-yard reception. After a bye, McCoy scored the eventual game-winning TD in a one-point win over Iowa when he burst through the middle, then cut across the field and outran the rest of the defense 27 yards untouched. He was held in check most of the day, but on that pivotal drive he rushed for 41 yards and caught a 28-yard reception. At Syracuse, to open the Big East season, he notched his first 100-yard game. He rushed for 149 yards and started a five-game string where he would average 152.4 yards rushing and score 10 TDs, including the game-winner in an upset at #10 USF and a season-long 58-yarder at Navy. Against Louisville, the Cardinals put all their focus on McCoy and held him at negative yardage during the second half. He did run for an 11-yard TD on a direct snap and completed his second career pass for 14 yards. McCoy finished with a career-low 39 yards rushing, but Pitt blew out Louisville. He missed rushing for 100 yards again at Cincinnati, but ran for two TDs and had 127 combined yards in the loss. McCoy owned WVU in the Backyard Brawl for the second straight year, rushing for a career-high 183 yards, including a game-winning one-yard TD run, his second of the game, after carrying the ball nine of ten times on the decisive drive. In a regular season finale showdown with fellow standout underclassmen Donald Brown, McCoy was slightly less productive, but his 47-yard TD run in the third quarter began a 24-point outburst that led the team to victory at UConn. McCoy was limited to 85 yards on 24 carries in a disappointing offensive performance in a 3-0 loss to Oregon State in the Sun Bowl. After leading the Panthers to their first bowl since 2004, McCoy reversed early comments that he would return and, following an apparently agonizing decision process, declared he would enter the draft. McCoy finished his second season with 1,488 rushing yards on 308 carries and 21 TDs, tied for second in FBS.
In my preseason preview, I expected Shady to go the route of Panther alum Larry Fitzgerald and declare after just two seasons if he had similar success, but he improved on his numbers as a sophomore despite a target on his back every game. I expect him to find similar success to Fitzgerald at the next level, as well. McCoy is rare in his ability to thrive inside and outside. A natural runner with outstanding instincts and balance, he has breakaway speed once he gets to the second level. His balance really stands out to me watching him on film, just amazing how it contributes to his ability to change direction and break tackles. A compact runner with great elusiveness through the line and ankle-breaking moves in the open field, it’s hard to get a clean shot on him. Also a very good receiver with soft hands and awareness, he had 33 receptions in 2007 and 32 in 2008.
Ball security is one of the few holes in his game. He has also been accused of trying to bounce too much outside, but I don’t see it. He thrives between the tackles and heads to the edges when the situation dictates it. A bit thin through the hips, there’s some concern if he can carry more bulk, but he appears to have enough talent to succeed regardless. He’ll be 20 years old at the start of his first NFL season and with unlimited potential, he should be one of the first three backs selected."
________________________________________________________________________________
"Shady’s stock began to drop after he had to bow out of performing Combine drills due to a rough battle with the flu. He had a solid, but unspectacular Pro Day a month later, but it was apparent he had lost ground to some of the other consensus top runners in the class. Once viewed as a potential first-round pick, McCoy fell late into the second round. However, he rocketed back up fantasy rankings because of where he fell – Philly. In the Eagles high-powered offense with Brian Westbrook turning 30 before the season starts while coming off a left knee scope in February and a cleaning of his right ankle in June, McCoy falls in to one of the best back-up situations available. It’s too soon to write-off Westbrook, but HC Andy Reid’s offense spreads the ball around, so McCoy should have some opportunities out of the gate and is a must-have handcuff to the starter. Going forward, McCoy has a bright dynasty future with the skill set to eventually replace Westbrook directly."
***** LINKS
mccoy's soph highlights (like moreno, he only played two years in college)...
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6IvvhjERrV0
his page at eagles.com, that keeps a running total of his accomplishments (his production is stacking up pretty well against the other rookies in the early going... moreno is #1 in rushing yards and #2 in combined yards, mccoy is #2 & #1 in those stat columns, respectively)... includes a nice testimonial by fellow star Panther RB alum tony dorsett... forgot his two year TD production was among the highest in collegiate history (bettering fellow two and done star Panther alum larry fitzgerald)...
http://www.philadelphiaeagles.com/eagles_f...ml/mccoy_1.html