I watched it again, and caught another thing that could support this theory. When Pauly shows up to the Bing, and talks with Sil about Phil being killed. He mentioned something about his mom dieing all alone, and nobody going to her funeral. I think he is still bitter about that, and it could be a way he is justifying being a rat.If this is true, Tony should have gone with his gut and whacked him on the boat.ICWT10 said:Paulie is in cahoots with Phil.First of all, Paulie has tried this in the past playing both sides of the fence with Johnny Sac and Carmine but just from last night's episode:Otis said:I noticed and questioned this too. Was just a weird scene and weird reaction. Could be a setup for something bigger.Wingnut said:Why did Paulie drive up near the car the Italians were in, have a quick look, then speed off like he was going somewhere?? (when the kid took Patsi outside to the car and said 'I just picked them up from the airport). At first I thought he was just making sure the Italians were really there since he pawned the responsibility off on Patsi...making sure it was all in place...but Im not so sure
1. They (the writers) went out of their way to twice bring up Paulie's name amongst the NY crew and wondering why Paulie's name wasn't listed. See, Phil knows Paulie is in cahoots, but Phil's guys don't. So first when Phil says "the top 3," they assume Paulie, Sil, and Tony. Phil has to jump in and say, "No Bobby Baccala." Then later, the NY guys are hanging out again this time without Phil and one says, "I wonder why we're not going after Goiteire. I mean come on, Bobby Baccala? Wasn't he Junior Soprano's driver just last year?" So like I said, they went out of their way twice to bring up the fact that Paulie isn't part of it even though everyone in the NY thinks he should be. Phil and Paulie have a deal that not even the NY guys know about at this point.
2. When Paulie was told that the hit was called out on Phil he got very defensive saying, "Does the Boss know about this?" Then when they told him to calm down he said something to the effect of how he survived through the all the cross-family bloodshed of the 70's and he's not looking to try his luck again. This shows how Paulie would be much happier cutting a deal and living then looking over his shoulder, engaging in war and dying.
3. He was supposed to be in charge of the Phil hit and Phil just happens to not show up at his goumare's on Friday night? Hmmmmm. I wonder if he was tipped off.
4. This one here is the kicker. Bobby and Sil were both shot dead less then 3 hours before Tony and Paulie go to Tony's house to collect food and supplies. Tony is a nervous wreck packing some canned food in garbage bags and scurrying around. What is Paulie doing? Paulie is looking out the window as calm as could be laughing and checking out AJ's girlfriend saying, "Look at the stems on blondie."
Paulie is a nervous wreck about everything! He is far too calm and collected when at that point, he would have every reason to believe that his life was in serious danger. He wouldn't know that Phil only put a hit out on Bobby, Sil and Tony. Just like all the NY guys, Paulie would of had to assume he would have a hit on him also. We've seen Paulie and how he acts when he's stressed. He wasn't stressed at all. He knows he is safe. How does he know? Because he is in cahoots with Phil.
That's how this plot will play out. Where they go with that and what not I have no idea; but Paulie looked out for himself and himself only and Bobby, Sil, and maybe Tony are going to pay for it.
Also, I noticed from the scenes from the next episode that they kind of show Pauly for a second. Something about his expression, and the way they showed him kind of stuck out.
In slow motion it also looked like AJ was witnessing something blowing up. And, someone giving Meadow bad news. Maybe the house gets blown up with Carm in it...