That guy totally goes back. Hey, you know that feeling when you just broke a girl's heart and she's repeatedly insulting you and you don't want to leave because you want to console her? Yeah, you actually have feelings for her. Go back and win the Bachelorette. Idiot.
When you don't really dig a woman and she's crying and insulting you, you leave. You can't wait to get out of there.
That's what I said to my wife last night too...Brooks comes back, she picks him, they DON'T get engaged. I give them 2 months after the finale before they're broken up.
His little feelings rant did irreparable harm to their "relationship." There's no going back to the way things were. It's hard enough to do that on these shows anyway, much less when this kind of thing happens.