'Leeroy Jenkins said:
What police departments are we talking about here? Seems like a lot of people dropped the ball.
The Raleigh police department originally had little to go on. Coincidentally there were two peepers at the time, but they thought there was just one, and the one they caught wasn't a DNA match. They had a composite sketch that looked nothing like Planten. They had all types of accounts with various descriptions of various people. They really should have canvased neighboring apartments at the time, but didn't. What broke the case open was the lead detective retired, and another took over. A guy they called the "garbage man". He went through everything. This was three years after the murder, and he read all reports, and reinterviewed people, and discovered there was a tall thin guy who walked a large dark dog, and wore a hoodie and sunglasses, and was seen around the complex several times prior to the murder, and then disappeared afterwards. The detective made this public, and calls came in, which led to the neighbor who saw a man with a dog peek into Stephanie's window and run through the woods towards another apartment complex just two or three weeks before the murder. Why this person never came forward with this information when the murder happened was never said. The detective went to this other apartment complex, and got the name Drew Planten based on the description of him and his dog. Planten became his person of interest, and it turned out he was the guy. The arrest of Planten led police to another murder in Michigan, and possible others. Murders aren't always easy to solve, but they did solve Stephanie's and the young lady in Michigan. Who knows if there were more.