There's all sorts of wrong in this post, but there may not be another player who has appeared on the injury report more than Stewart has throughout his NFL career. It's truly amazing how blind you are when it comes to certain players, and Stewart is at the top of that list.
I think we just have a different way of looking at this player.
In the 4 years between 2008-2011, Stewart played in 62 out of 64 games (96.9% of all possible games). He carried the ball 725 times for 3500 yards (4.83 YPC).
Yet you are saying that he's not capable of staying healthy and that constant injuries have prevented him from making an impact in FF.
I don't see it that way. There's definitely a pattern of nagging minor foot/ankle problems, but this past season was the first time when it prevented Stewart from getting on the field and playing well. Maybe that's a sign of things to come. Maybe it's a temporary setback that will be resolved with surgery and a period of recovery.
My line of reasoning here is very straightforward.
- Stewart has been a very effective NFL player throughout his career.
- The main thing that has held him back in FF terms is a lack of opportunity.
- With DeAngelo Williams on the wrong end of 30, he will eventually be phased out and Stewart might have an opportunity to be the unquestioned lead back.
- Stewart is currently injured, but there's a realistic chance that he will make a full recovery and play at a high level for several more years.
I understand if people aren't as optimistic about Stewart as I am, but I don't think it's a giant stretch to hold out hope for this player. The reasoning makes sense. Where I think I mainly disagree with the conventional take on him is that I don't equate the lack of opportunity with a lack of performance. Stewart has been a very good NFL player, but a massive bust in FF. That's a matter of opportunity, not performance. Secondly, I'm more optimistic about his chances of recovering/staying healthy in the future. If I thought he had no chance to come back and play well, I would be a lot more pessimistic, but I'm open to the possibility of him making a full recovery and playing well for a few more years.