3) Todd Gurley, Los Angeles Rams
Originally drafted: Round 1, No. 10 overall.
The need to explain away Gurley's disastrous second season is mystifying. The short version goes like this:
The Rams' offense was run by paste-eating middle schoolers, and Gurley had no chance. No further analysis necessary.
Gurley's 278 carries tell a different story. At least four to five times each game, Gurley had daylight to work with. He often ran up the backs of his offensive linemen or was arm-tackled. If Gurley's game
isn'tabout making defenders miss, then he'll need to run through defenders more often. He simply didn't show the same burst, second effort or power that he did in his Offensive Rookie of the Year campaign. The
Rams coaching staff noticed, often taking him out of the game in key situations or failing to give him the ball late with the lead.
For a window into Gurley's season, let's travel
to Seattle last December. On fourth-and-1 inside the
Seahawks' 10-yard line early in the game, Gurley got the ball on a pitch to the left. He had his choice of multiple lanes and elected to take on
Seahawks linebacker
Bobby Wagner, only needing to gain a few inches with a full head of steam. Wagner stood him up cold and eventually pushed Gurley backward with some help. It was an
example of Wagner's greatness, but Gurley also should have made the play.
Of course the season wasn't all Gurley's fault. The criticism of the
Rams' passing game and offensive line was accurate. Still, that's not the point. Gurley was supposed to be a transcendent talent, the kind of player who should make his teammates look better. Try to imagine
Adrian Peterson or Barry Sanders or even Corey Dillon carrying the ball 278 times with a 3.2 yards-per-carry average and only
two runs over 20 yards, even
with lousy offenses around them. Something was wrong.
Trying to explain Gurley's down season: This is the part where it's
reallytempting to play amateur psychologist and guess what was in Gurley's mind or heart last season, to interpret those shakes of the head or the lackluster runs in garbage time. I went into this exercise hoping to see something positive from Gurley, but aside from his occasional light feet and graceful glide, it just wasn't there. At his best out of the I-formation, Gurley was
The Franchise, until quarterback
Jared Goff -- who is more comfortable out of the shotgun -- came along as the first overall pick in the 2016
NFL Draft. How to split the difference is up to new coach Sean McVay.
McVay should help considerably by modernizing the offense. Gurley could bounce back on the strength of big plays as a top running back, and no one would be surprised. He showed
that much talent as a rookie. This ranking is reflective of Gurley righting himself as a solid starter. But Gurley has to show himself to be a different player this year, to recognize that his sophomore slump was about more than his teammates. Otherwise, it will be time to trust what Gurley shows on Sundays over those scouting reports from the 2015 draft season.