What I do know is Shady looked much more dynamic and the offense seemed to flow even better while he was in there. IF we see that, pretty sure Reid sees that.
Maybe.
or maybe it was this one game.
funny thing about Reid RBBCs. Ya just never can tell week to week. So it’s hard to read into any one game & predict what will happen the next.
I own shares of neither. What I see is roughly equal FF production, and the distinct possibility that it’s an even split all year.
You also have to factor in that McCoy is 31 with a ton of mileage on those treads. Everyone looks fresh in game 1. I’m interested in seeing how Shady looks in game 5 or 6 when the pounding adds up.
And even if he still looks good, as i’ve mentioned before on one of these KC RB topics, the double edged sword is that he may be most productive if his usage is limited to keep him fresh. Because just as Reid saw what you saw on the field, he also knows McCoy’s birthday. So it’s not like Reid is going to wake up today and think, “wow, McCoy really outplayed DWill. Imma give him 30+ touches next week!”
i just don’t see that being realistic. Shady’s upside is likely going to be limited by his touches. As others have said, that’s hard to predict week to week. But I can’t see any scenario that sends DWill to the bench & McCoy becoming a feature back. This isn’t RoJo & Peyton Barber. DWill wasn’t as productive, but he still hauled in 6 receptions, and he did score the TD.
Finally, the Chiefs put up 50+ using the game plan they used. And Reid probably saw that too. Maybe if they lost by 30 they’d have reason to make changes.
don't mean to throw cold water on any McCoy owners & not trying to hype up DWill. Just making observations from the standpoint of someone who has neither RB.
They’re both likely to be RB2s with the occasional “boom!” game, unless one of them gets hurt. And even then I’d expect DThompson to come in & take over half the touches.
Andy Reid gonna Andy Reid.