****OFFICIAL 2020 IN-SEASON DYNASTY TRADES****

[JFS171 838]

On 10/24/2019 at 7:00 PM, Dr. Dan said:

not involved, super flex ppr

 

Team A gets: 2020 1st (late) 2020 3rd (late), robby anderson, Gerald Everett

Team B gets: diggs

Some additional context here ... I’m the team that acquired Diggs. I’ll also point out that we just started the league this year using the Invisible Hand method for allocating KDS. As such, the picks are “worth more” in a vacuum,  except many teams are in very similar boats, having to cut significant portions of the roster prior to the first Rookie/FA Draft. As such, I think it basically makes the picks equivalent to a normal rookie draft. 
 

I personally have to cut nine guys from my 22 man roster. Everett, IMO, was my third TE, and this is not a TE premium league, though it does have two WRT flex spots in addition to the superflex. I’m honestly not sure I could’ve kept Everett, and doing so would’ve forced me to cut someone equivalent to a 2019 first round rookie, so I didn’t really care about including him. I acquired the 2020 3rd from a team for the remainder of my FAAB, which ... I’m not really competing due to way too many injuries this year, so the FAAB was kinda meaningless to me. 
 

I viewed it as Robby and a late 1 for Diggs, which ... thank you very much. 

[Buckna 1,391]

18 hours ago, 5Rings said:

12 team non-ppr. 

Team A (last place)  gets Derrick Henry (RB8)

Team B (most points, 3 games back) gets Juju and a 5th.

Second straight year of (likely) being top in points and missing playoffs, so tried selling some of my Rb depth (Jacobs, Henry, Gurley, Fournette, Coleman) to get picks for next year or a WR upgrade (Evans, Julio, Fitz/McL).  Henry got the most attention.  Tried getting OBJ or even Kupp, no dice, this offer came out of left field today and accepted.  Helps both teams on paper.  Interesting how far Gurley has fallen....

Feel like people missed the non-ppr aspect. WR’s aren’t worth anything close to equivalent RB value in those types of leagues, even potentially elite young ones.

[kittenmittens 1,263]

25 minutes ago, hispeedthinmint said:

Exactly. In non-ppr, I take Henry right now

No way.  Even in non ppr, Juju is likely to be a valuable asset for the next 10ish years. Derrick Henry's value is year to year at best.  Probably more like month to month or week to week. 

[doowain 823]

12 Team PPR

Team A gave:

Michael Gallup
Diontae Johnson

Team B gave:

Brandin Cooks
Will Fuller

[Interseptopus 5,722]

28 minutes ago, doowain said:

12 Team PPR

Team A gave:

Michael Gallup
Diontae Johnson

Team B gave:

Brandin Cooks
Will Fuller

Team B by a lot IMO

[mzkp54 32]

12 team superflex 0.5 PPR.
 

Gave McLaurin, Montgomery, and ‘20 1st for Davante Adams and ‘20 3rd

[doowain 823]

1 hour ago, Dr. Dan said:

1 hour ago, doowain said:

12 Team PPR

Team A gave:

Michael Gallup
Diontae Johnson

Team B gave:

Brandin Cooks
Will Fuller

Team B by a lot IMO

So you like Gallup/Diontae by a lot?

[Interseptopus 5,722]

12 minutes ago, doowain said:

So you like Gallup/Diontae by a lot?

absolutely Cooks isnt even 2nd fiddle any more and fuller cant stay healthy

[doowain 823]

22 minutes ago, Dr. Dan said:

absolutely Cooks isnt even 2nd fiddle any more and fuller cant stay healthy

Interesting. 

[Interseptopus 5,722]

44 minutes ago, doowain said:

Interesting. 

 

Both combos are averaging 24 fp/g in 2019 alone, so theres that. 

Gallup is the best player in that deal IMO. Prior to last week Gallup was top 10 in fp/g for the season. I think he stands to be the wr1 next year as I'm not sure Dallas can afford Cooper and Dak. Gallup had a college dominator score that shows he can be a wr1. 

Cooks has dropped significantly this year in his production. I've never been a huge fan, but with Kupp healthy he isnt getting nearly the targets he has it seems. 

Fuller is great... when hes healthy. Prior to this season he was averaging 10 games a season. No thanks. Especially when Houston continues to draft, trade, and be rumored in more trades for wrs. 

Johnson needs to beat out Washington, who looks like a bust so far. I think PIT hit it out of the park with that pick. Hes a fantastic possession wr. 

So I look at this trade as giving up 2 budding wrs (one in the middle of a breakout season) whose arrows are pointing up for 2 wrs whose arrows are pointing down. 

[5Rings 255]

5 hours ago, hispeedthinmint said:

Exactly. In non-ppr, I take Henry right now

That was my thinking exactly.  Can start up to 3 rb and/or up to 5 wr.  Wanted to get out high on Henry and buy low on Juju.  This year, I lost the trade, no question. I’m playing for domination next year and forward.  Tired of this bad luck, top point scorer last place garbage.  Gonna build a team so strong it simply doesn’t matter if every opponent had their top week against me💪

[cloppbeast 1,415]

Get Kerryon Johnson, give Julian Edelman, Dede Westbrook, and a 2nd.

[irish eyes 1,234]

Draft picks in dynasty trades are useless. I have 1 pick from last year on my team & he is close to be being cut. 

[Hankmoody 3,740]

21 minutes ago, irish eyes said:

Draft picks in dynasty trades are useless. I have 1 pick from last year on my team & he is close to be being cut. 

So because one guy on the internet can't draft that makes all picks useless.   Got it.

[irish eyes 1,234]

5 minutes ago, Hankmoody said:

So because one guy on the internet can't draft that makes all picks useless.   Got it.

So, what rookies this  year have done anything.  Jacobs, kyler, mclaurin. That's about it. But I have to say, my 1st year in this dynasty league and anyone at the top didn't get much.

Edited October 26, 2019 by irish eyes

[Hankmoody 3,740]

1 minute ago, irish eyes said:

So, what rookies this  year have done anything.  Jacobs, kyler, mclaurin. That's about it.

Yep and all those picks from 2017 and 2016, Barkley, Chubb, Kamara, McCaffrey - man I sure hope you didn't get stuck drafting any of those guys either.  I'll make sure to avoid getting any picks that could possible draft those roster anchors going forward just based on your experiences.

[wgoldsph 945]

11 minutes ago, irish eyes said:

So, what rookies this  year have done anything.  Jacobs, kyler, mclaurin. That's about it.

I can't tell if this is a joke or not.

[wgoldsph 945]

4 hours ago, mzkp54 said:

12 team superflex 0.5 PPR.
 

Gave McLaurin, Montgomery, and ‘20 1st for Davante Adams and ‘20 3rd

You got fleeced.  Absolutely taken out back and beaten like a redheaded step child.

Two of mclaurin, Montgomery, or the 1st would be worth Adams.  The third is a dart throw, not really worth anything.  He's getting the best fantasy wr of the draft so far (who's on a team thats so bad that it shouldn't even be able to produce a fantasy wr), a top 5 overall pick in rookie drafts this past season, and a no1 in a loaded class - for a player who's been injured all year and isn't top 5 at his position when healthy.

[Interseptopus 5,722]

40 minutes ago, wgoldsph said:

You got fleeced.  Absolutely taken out back and beaten like a redheaded step child.

Two of mclaurin, Montgomery, or the 1st would be worth Adams.  The third is a dart throw, not really worth anything.  He's getting the best fantasy wr of the draft so far (who's on a team thats so bad that it shouldn't even be able to produce a fantasy wr), a top 5 overall pick in rookie drafts this past season, and a no1 in a loaded class - for a player who's been injured all year and isn't top 5 at his position when healthy.

I disagree wholeheartedly 

McLaurin is a great sell high. he doesnt meet the metrics for being a fantasy wr1

Montgomery looks like just a guy at this point. He can break tackles and has better hands than Howard but he is just another version of Jordan Howard. I'm surprised anyone thinks highly of him still. 

2020 1st depends where it will be. If its low it's a fantastic deal for a guy who was the overall wr1 a year ago and the only decent wr in that offense. 

I love this deal for Adams. He is being over looked and under valued because of his injury but he stands to be a league winner second half of the season, especially since GB is "in it" this year. 

 

ETA: Dynasty trade calculator has this deal dead even if it's a late 2020 1st

Edited October 27, 2019 by Dr. Dan

[irish eyes 1,234]

2 hours ago, Hankmoody said:

Yep and all those picks from 2017 and 2016, Barkley, Chubb, Kamara, McCaffrey - man I sure hope you didn't get stuck drafting any of those guys either.  I'll make sure to avoid getting any picks that could possible draft those roster anchors going forward just based on your experiences.

Barkley & McCaffrey were early picks, which no one gives up is my point. Yes you'll hit on chubb & Kamara by luck but you dont know what you're getting unless the team trading is truly pathetic 

Edited October 27, 2019 by irish eyes

[mzkp54 32]

1 hour ago, Dr. Dan said:

I disagree wholeheartedly 

McLaurin is a great sell high. he doesnt meet the metrics for being a fantasy wr1

Montgomery looks like just a guy at this point. He can break tackles and has better hands than Howard but he is just another version of Jordan Howard. I'm surprised anyone thinks highly of him still. 

2020 1st depends where it will be. If its low it's a fantastic deal for a guy who was the overall wr1 a year ago and the only decent wr in that offense. 

I love this deal for Adams. He is being over looked and under valued because of his injury but he stands to be a league winner second half of the season, especially since GB is "in it" this year. 

 

ETA: Dynasty trade calculator has this deal dead even if it's a late 2020 1st

Yeah I thought it was a fair deal, maybe a slight overpay but I think it sets me up nicely. My only real hole right now IMO is my QB2 (Baker), but even there is hopefully some potential for a rebound. I have Watson/Baker/Cook/Carson/Adams/Godwin/Allen/Edelman/Hooper as my starting lineup so I’d think it had a good a chance as anyone of being a late pick. 

[barackdhouse 2,038]

12 team FFPC style:

Team A gives Montgomery, 2020 2nd (late)

Team B gives Hunt, Coutee

Different 12 team FFPC style league:

Team A gives Barkley, Gallman, Slayton, Burkhead

Team B gives Edmonds, Gurley, Hooper, Robby Anderson 2020 2nd and 4th

Yet another different league same style:

Team A Guice, Gurley, Herndon

Team B Chubb, Delanie Walker (couple weeks old)

Edited October 27, 2019 by barackdhouse

[doowain 823]

4 hours ago, Dr. Dan said:

 

Both combos are averaging 24 fp/g in 2019 alone, so theres that. 

Gallup is the best player in that deal IMO. Prior to last week Gallup was top 10 in fp/g for the season. I think he stands to be the wr1 next year as I'm not sure Dallas can afford Cooper and Dak. Gallup had a college dominator score that shows he can be a wr1. 

Cooks has dropped significantly this year in his production. I've never been a huge fan, but with Kupp healthy he isnt getting nearly the targets he has it seems. 

Fuller is great... when hes healthy. Prior to this season he was averaging 10 games a season. No thanks. Especially when Houston continues to draft, trade, and be rumored in more trades for wrs. 

Johnson needs to beat out Washington, who looks like a bust so far. I think PIT hit it out of the park with that pick. Hes a fantastic possession wr. 

So I look at this trade as giving up 2 budding wrs (one in the middle of a breakout season) whose arrows are pointing up for 2 wrs whose arrows are pointing down. 

Playing devil's advocate, you could say "buying low".

Does that trade happen the week after Fuller's 50 pt outburst? No chance. 

[Dez 1,084]

38 minutes ago, irish eyes said:

Barkley & McCaffrey were early picks, which no one gives up is my point. Yes you'll hit on chubb & Kamara by luck but you dont know what you're getting unless the team trading is truly pathetic 

[Interseptopus 5,722]

28 minutes ago, doowain said:

Playing devil's advocate, you could say "buying low".

Does that trade happen the week after Fuller's 50 pt outburst? No chance. 

 

Fuller isnt scoring 50 points weekly. he is around 7 aside from that.one game. give me healthy upside all day long, not an oft injured modern day Sammy Watkins. best of luck to you 

Edited October 27, 2019 by Dr. Dan

[JoeJoe88 447]

4 hours ago, irish eyes said:

Draft picks in dynasty trades are useless. I have 1 pick from last year on my team & he is close to be being cut. 

Chris Godwin, Kenny Golladay, and Aaron Jones were all 4th round rookie picks in my dynasty league. Terry McLaurin was a the final pick of this past years rookie draft. 

[barackdhouse 2,038]

26 minutes ago, JoeJoe88 said:

Chris Godwin, Kenny Golladay, and Aaron Jones were all 4th round rookie picks in my dynasty league. Terry McLaurin was a the final pick of this past years rookie draft. 

Lindsay, Kittle. We could go on and on.

ETA got Waller in the 4th or later in nearly every rookie/FA draft this year. TE premium too.

Edited October 27, 2019 by barackdhouse

[ConnSKINS26 5,718]

14 team PPR devy dynasty, re-tooling for next year after an unlucky start.

Gave: 

Deshaun Watson, Marquise Brown, Andy Isabella, AP

Got:

Kyler Murray, DJ Chark

Edited October 27, 2019 by ConnSKINS26

[Interseptopus 5,722]

5 minutes ago, ConnSKINS26 said:

14 team PPR devy dynasty, re-tooling for next year after an unlucky start.

Gave: 

Deshaun Watson, Marquise Brown, Andy Isabella, AP

Got:

Kyler Murray, DJ Chark

I'll be in the minority and say I prefer the got

[JoeJoe88 447]

10 minutes ago, ConnSKINS26 said:

14 team PPR devy dynasty, re-tooling for next year after an unlucky start.

Gave: 

Deshaun Watson, Marquise Brown, Andy Isabella, AP

Got:

Kyler Murray, DJ Chark

I'll take the Kyler side.

[ConnSKINS26 5,718]

16 minutes ago, Dr. Dan said:

I'll be in the minority and say I prefer the got

I also expect to be in the minority in preferring what I received. I like Brown but he seems like much more of a potential Desean (and even that would be a historic success for him) than a potential Tyreek. 

Chark I think has already snuck into the "real WR1" conversation without many noticing. 

The QB swap was the price of admission but I think Murray will be a fine replacement in the coming years. I could easily make an argument for him as a top-5/6 dynasty QB:

Mahomes

Watson

L. Jackson

Wilson

Murray

Really just depends how much you like Wentz and Dak.

Edited October 27, 2019 by ConnSKINS26

[Run It Up 916]

12 team te premium ppr, QB, RB, WR, WR, TE, FLX, FLX, FLX, FLX

Sent G. Everett, S. Watkins

Received K. Golladay, J. Sternberger 

[doowain 823]

3 hours ago, Dr. Dan said:

 

Fuller isnt scoring 50 points weekly. he is around 7 aside from that.one game. give me healthy upside all day long, not an oft injured modern day Sammy Watkins. best of luck to you 

If you think that I was suggesting 50ppg, that says all I need to know. Thanks!

[Dr. Octopus 15,706]

15 hours ago, doowain said:

Interesting. 

I’d take the other side easily. Cooks may not be “even second fiddle anymore” but he’s outscoring both guys on the other side still, is much younger than people think and will likely be somewhere else next year anyway. Fuller can be flipped for value if you’re worried about his health. Honestly Gallup seems a bit overrated to me. He’s solid but I just don’t see him ever being a WR1 and Cooks has multiple season of doing so already and is only 26.

Edited October 27, 2019 by Dr. Octopus

[Interseptopus 5,722]

1 hour ago, Dr. Octopus said:

I’d take the other side easily. Cooks may not be “even second fiddle anymore” but he’s outscoring both guys on the other side still, is much younger than people think and will likely be somewhere else next year anyway. Fuller can be flipped for value if you’re worried about his health. Honestly Gallup seems a bit overrated to me. He’s solid but I just don’t see him ever being a WR1 and Cooks has multiple season of doing so already and is only 26.

cooks: 11 p/g

Gallup: 15 p/g

[Dr. Octopus 15,706]

2 hours ago, Dr. Dan said:

cooks: 11 p/g

Gallup: 15 p/g

Fair enough. I was mistaken on that but I do think Cooks is the better player and his situation will improve if Goff gets back on track. I also do not agree that Cooper will be gone in Dallas next year. If they have to franchise his they will. They traded away a first round pick to get him. There’s little chance they let him walk.

[Interseptopus 5,722]

7 minutes ago, Dr. Octopus said:

Fair enough. I was mistaken on that but I do think Cooks is the better player and his situation will improve if Goff gets back on track. I also do not agree that Cooper will be gone in Dallas next year. If they have to franchise his they will. They traded away a first round pick to get him. There’s little chance they let him walk.

yes they may franchise him. not sure if they can afford that either but that's probably a good option 

[doowain 823]

Team A got
Evans, Mike TBB WR

Team B got
Edmonds, Chase ARI RB
Kittle, George SFO TE

[FreeBaGeL 8,820]

6 hours ago, Dr. Octopus said:

I’d take the other side easily. Cooks may not be “even second fiddle anymore” but he’s outscoring both guys on the other side still, is much younger than people think and will likely be somewhere else next year anyway. Fuller can be flipped for value if you’re worried about his health. Honestly Gallup seems a bit overrated to me. He’s solid but I just don’t see him ever being a WR1 and Cooks has multiple season of doing so already and is only 26.

I would take Cooks but his contract looks like it will keep him there for some time.  $22m dead cap hit this offseason.  I would not count on him landing elsewhere next year.

[wgoldsph 945]

20 hours ago, Dr. Dan said:

Montgomery looks like just a guy at this point. He can break tackles and has better hands than Howard but he is just another version of Jordan Howard. I'm surprised anyone thinks highly of him still.

A lack of hands is what basically stopped Howard from being a rb1 early in his career.  Montgomery's problem isn't his ability - it's Tybursky and Nagy.

[Zyphros 1,890]

FFPC, been trying to trade Melvin Gordon for weeks, finally found a team.  I basically had to settle for min price though.

Got 2020 1st, could literally land anywhere.  FFPC you can win your way to 1.01, you can also get into playoffs and be bottom 4.  Team is 5th in total VP, and 10th in total points for, so I liked my odds as a top6 pick.  

I sent a ton of offers out last week of a 1st and a player I liked from them that wouldn't start.  No bites at all.  

[Ray Barboni 499]

3 hours ago, Zyphros said:

FFPC, been trying to trade Melvin Gordon for weeks, finally found a team.  I basically had to settle for min price though.

Got 2020 1st, could literally land anywhere.  FFPC you can win your way to 1.01, you can also get into playoffs and be bottom 4.  Team is 5th in total VP, and 10th in total points for, so I liked my odds as a top6 pick.  

I sent a ton of offers out last week of a 1st and a player I liked from them that wouldn't start.  No bites at all.  

Not sure how FFPC works ... or even whet the hell it is - but as a Gordon owner, I’d take ANY 2020 1st. 
 

Congrats 

[bostonfred 30,050]

QRWWTFKD non ppr

Contending team gets Julio

Rebuilding team gets hunter Henry

[kittenmittens 1,263]

12 team PPR non SF

Team A gets James White and Josh Reynolds 

Team B gets Andy Isabella, Mike Geisicki, 2020 2nd (mid/late) 

[Slider 617]

On 10/26/2019 at 2:02 PM, doowain said:

12 Team PPR

Team A gave:

Michael Gallup
Diontae Johnson

Team B gave:

Brandin Cooks
Will Fuller

Cooks and Fuller are two guys I would run from as they're simply not reliable. Gallup by a lot for me.

[Interseptopus 5,722]

9 hours ago, kittenmittens said:

12 team PPR non SF

Team A gets James White and Josh Reynolds 

Team B gets Andy Isabella, Mike Geisicki, 2020 2nd (mid/late) 

I'm probably in the minority here but I'll take Isabella side. 

IMO White is worth a 2nd to a contender. So then its Isabella and Geisicki for Reynolds, which to me that's getting Isabella for free 

[Dr. Octopus 15,706]

12 team ppr QB/2RB/3WR/TE/FL

 

Team trades:

Isabella, Andy WR | ARI

Kamara, Alvin RB | NO

Round 1 (Year 2020)  - late

Round 2 (Year 2020) - late

Team B trades:

Jones, Aaron RB | GB

Ertz, Zach TE | PHI

Ingram, Mark RB | BAL

Jones, Julio WR | ATL

[Dr. Octopus 15,706]

12 team ppr QB/2RB/3WR/TE/FL

 

Team A trades

 Edwards, Gus BAL RB;

Ingram, Mark BAL RB;

Green, A.J. CIN WR;

Watkins, Sammy KCC WR

Team B trades

 Singletary, Devin BUF RB;

Meyers, Jakobi NEP WR;

Knox, Dawson BUF TE

[bostonfred 30,050]

16 minutes ago, Dr. Octopus said:

12 team ppr QB/2RB/3WR/TE/FL

 

Team trades:

Isabella, Andy WR | ARI

Kamara, Alvin RB | NO

Round 1 (Year 2020)  - late

Round 2 (Year 2020) - late

Team B trades:

Jones, Aaron RB | GB

Ertz, Zach TE | PHI

Ingram, Mark RB | BAL

Jones, Julio WR | ATL

I guess Kamara and the picks but it's not unreasonable either way.  

I imagine the team getting Jones ertz Ingram and Julio has had a couple unexpected studs on an otherwise sparse roster and has been lucky with their record so far and needs to replace 3 or 4 spots in their lineup.  Probably has something like ekeler and the Patriots defense?

[bostonfred 30,050]

17 minutes ago, Dr. Octopus said:

12 team ppr QB/2RB/3WR/TE/FL

 

Team A trades

 Edwards, Gus BAL RB;

Ingram, Mark BAL RB;

Green, A.J. CIN WR;

Watkins, Sammy KCC WR

Team B trades

 Singletary, Devin BUF RB;

Meyers, Jakobi NEP WR;

Knox, Dawson BUF TE

This feels expensive for Singletary/Knox. Meyers is a throw in. But i guess Ingram and green are close enough to the end of the line and Watkins is still such a frustrating player that I get it for a rebuilding team who also happens to live in buffalo.