Fantasy Football - Footballguys Forums
Welcome to Our Forums. Once you've registered and logged in, you're primed to talk football, among other topics, with the sharpest and most experienced fantasy players on the internet.
****OFFICIAL DYNASTY TRADES**** (24 Viewers)
- Thread starter Gottabesweet
- Start date
16 team PPR- Team 1 is total rebuild, team 2 is competing this year.
Team 1- gave up Dalvin Cook, Mccaffrey, Rudolph and 2 mid tier 2018 2nds.
Team 2- gave 5-2018 1sts (1 top 5, 2 middle tier, 2 later but could easily change), prosise, Johnathon williams, Deangelo Henderson
Team 1- gave up Dalvin Cook, Mccaffrey, Rudolph and 2 mid tier 2018 2nds.
Team 2- gave 5-2018 1sts (1 top 5, 2 middle tier, 2 later but could easily change), prosise, Johnathon williams, Deangelo Henderson
JPeso
Footballguy
JPeso
Footballguy
JPeso
Footballguy
JPeso
Footballguy
JPeso
Footballguy
NeverEnough
Footballguy
I just moved my 2.02 developmental draft pick this year & 2018 4th round rookie pick for Ingram in PPR. I was hurting at RB with Fournette as my only real starter + I'm in rebuild mode.
Concept Coop
Footballguy
4x mid-to-late first rounders certainly isn't trash. Cook and the top pick are close enough. I'd take 4 mid-to-late firsts for McCaffrey if I'm rebuilding. And I'm sure the guy helped his Barkley chances as well, by moving those points off of his roster.
I don't like including the 2nd round picks, but I don't the trade is really that bad.
msudaisy26
Footballguy
Couple moves I just made. Ppr scoring v
I sent Doug Martin
I got Zay Jones
I gave Zay Jones
I got Marshawn Lynch and a 2018 3rd (Should be early owner is in complete rebuild)
I was in talk to get Lynch, was offering my 2nd next year, it should be late. He wanted Galloday, who I am very high on. During this another owner asked me about Martin and I looked over his roster and seen Jones. So I went for the flip and it worked, but I wouldn't have been mad if I was stuck with Jones and feel I could have still made a move for Lynch.
I sent Doug Martin
I got Zay Jones
I gave Zay Jones
I got Marshawn Lynch and a 2018 3rd (Should be early owner is in complete rebuild)
I was in talk to get Lynch, was offering my 2nd next year, it should be late. He wanted Galloday, who I am very high on. During this another owner asked me about Martin and I looked over his roster and seen Jones. So I went for the flip and it worked, but I wouldn't have been mad if I was stuck with Jones and feel I could have still made a move for Lynch.
Concept Coop
Footballguy
12 Tm PPR - QRRWWWTF - 25 man rosters
Gave: Melvin Gordon, 2nd (18')
Got: Freeman
I'm sure many value them equally, or even prefer Gordon straight up, which is reasonable. It was worth the cost paid to secure the safer guy to me. Both teams in the hunt.
Gave: Melvin Gordon, 2nd (18')
Got: Freeman
I'm sure many value them equally, or even prefer Gordon straight up, which is reasonable. It was worth the cost paid to secure the safer guy to me. Both teams in the hunt.
Last edited by a moderator:
Zyphros
Footballguy
Totally agree freeman is safer but Gordon's ceiling is higher to me and it's not like he's bad so I want the Gordon side. If it were a bad player and a pick for the safe option I'd go that route though. Figured it was worth mentioning.
It would take something amazing for that team not to have the #1 pick. So yes it helped in that arena too.
Hankmoody
Footballguy
Cook for a "top pick" that might not be a top pick? That you have to wait a year for? That might not be anywhere near the talent level in a different draft? No. If someone shows me a roster and it's a lead-pipe lock for 1.01 then maybe but even then we don't know Guice or Barkley will even come out healthy - both Chubb and the Oregon kid decided to return unexpectedly.
Rudolph and 2 2nd's should net a 1st and the RB's easy, and a real Rudolph fan would probably give two 1sts in PPR for him and the 2nd's - he was TE5 in PPR last year.
So now you're at 1 or 2 random 1sts for CmC. A year later. With no guarantee where they land.
I just can't see the logic of being a rebuilding team and trading two top-5 RB's in a historic class for dart throws later. Any number, any kind, any projected landing spot. Horrible.
BearsFan4Life
Footballguy
14 Team.. no PPR... 1qb/1rb/1wr/1te/2 Flex ... all TD's 6 pts
Gave: LMiller
Got: AAbdullah, DHenry
Cam, Bell, Green, Dez, DThomas, Kelce with Reed an Miller was all that was on my bench worth anything, so went for a little depth
Gave: LMiller
Got: AAbdullah, DHenry
Cam, Bell, Green, Dez, DThomas, Kelce with Reed an Miller was all that was on my bench worth anything, so went for a little depth
joey
Footballguy
a little depth? you mean getting a top 12 dynasty RB in Henry? Yeah, that's ok for depth I guess
msudaisy26
Footballguy
I like Abdullah and Henry better than Miller. I own Miller in a couple dynasties and would probably trade him straight up for either player.
jeaton6
Footballguy
One More Rep
Footballguy
Concept Coop
Footballguy
Are you really arguing that Kyle Rudolph is worth more than a first round pick? He's not worth anything close to that. He's a throw in. Diggs is back, they added Cook, and Bradford won't be around after this season. He'll go right back to being the TE depth that he has always been.
If we're treating the top 5 pick as a maybe, we should treat the mid-to-late round picks as maybes as well, no? Maybe those mids end up being early? Or the lates, even?
The meat of the deal is 5 first round picks in what appears to be a very strong class for Cook/McCaffrey. That's not horrible.
The team actually came in with several others this offseason to fill the league. There was a dispersal draft with very few good assets. That team now has 9 1sts in 2018 and is a lock to have the #1 pick. I know nothing is certain, but that is as close as you can get.
Hankmoody
Footballguy
Depends on the league and owners. He was TE4 in PPR last year, he's only 27, and he has the same QB and system as last year. He was just drafted at TE4 in a limited keeper league of mine. It's not at all "banter" for a believer that's in win-now mode.
Hankmoody
Footballguy
Or he could have Cook, CMc, and four 1st round picks, one of which is a lead-pipe lock to be #1 overall. Absurd trade.
Hankmoody
Footballguy
I've seen Rudolph traded for 1sts+ twice so far so no, I'm not arguing, I'm reporting. He's not even close to a throw-in, even in a deal this monstrous. He's 27 years old in a PPR league he just finished TE4 in. Even if you expect regression (I do) he's got value to contenders. It doesn't matter what you or I value him at, it matters what just one guy in the league might.
You can call the picks whatever you want, but you make my point about lack of clarity. Sure, they "could" be earlier, they "could" be later, they "could" be the last 5 picks of the round. Cook and CMc have a whole lot less "could" and are solidly in the "are" category, being 3rd-ish round picks in startup drafts. You think anyone's spending 3rd rounders in a devy startup on 2018 picks, even if they were pre-defined at 1.01 and 1.02?
You can disagree all you want, but my take is that this trade is a joke and this owner made a bad move, period.
Concept Coop
Footballguy
Fair enough. "Throw in" was hyperbole on my part, but I don't think it's reasonable to assume any owner in the league is willing to value Rudolph that highly. He's not a difference maker as a dynasty asset. I'm sure a lot of folks would roll the dice on Prosise over him straight up.
FTR, I wouldn't make the deal. I don't see the appeal in liquidizing 21 and 22 YO RBs. As you said, add Barkley to that group and you're in business. But I see potential for it working out either way, depending on where the picks land. Because of that, the deal doesn't stand out in this thread as being horrible or a joke. JMO.
Lastly, I know this wasn't really your point, but I'd absolutely trade a 3rd round startup pick for the 2018 1.01 right now. Barkley projects to be a first round startup pick. Even if he gets Chubbed, the average 1.01 should repay the investment.
Last edited by a moderator:
Concept Coop
Footballguy
mcintyre1
Footballguy
The trick is to post it as a completed trade and see the reactionary fallout
I'd probably trade my first and second for Davis if I thought my team was pretty good. If I'm in rebuilding mode and expect to have a top 5 pick, probably not.
Last edited by a moderator:
JohnnyU
Footballguy
Doesn't matter how many picks you have if you're constantly turning young players into more picks. You will always be in rebuilding mode.
Gottabesweet
Footballguy
Sent: Duke Johnson and Tyler Lockett for a 2018 1st (Projected 1.10-1.12) late.
I don't use Duke or Lockett.
I now have 5 firsts next year and am a contending team (actually traded for my 1st back)
Will use some of these to ensure I have 1.1 or 1.2 or move some to 2019 draft.
I don't use Duke or Lockett.
I now have 5 firsts next year and am a contending team (actually traded for my 1st back)
Will use some of these to ensure I have 1.1 or 1.2 or move some to 2019 draft.
Streetduck
Footballguy
Traded Chris Carson for Joey Bosa and a 2018 3rd rd. pick which should be an early 3rd.
wakelawyer
Footballguy
Crowell for me. He's the only guy that I am confident will have any meaningful value this time next year.
Hankmoody
Footballguy
Streetduck
Footballguy
Last edited by a moderator:
Hankmoody
Footballguy
msudaisy26
Footballguy
I gave Kareem Hunt
I got 1 million dollars.
I got 1 million dollars.
jeaton6
Footballguy
No it doesn't depend. Unless the owner is Rudolphs mom. 2 firsts for Rudolph and 2 2's? Ludicrous. TE5 last year. Great. How about the numerous prior years when he hasn't been able to stay healthy? He was drafted TE4. Ok, in a Tier with 7 other guys in it. Proves nothing.Hankmoody said:
Hankmoody
Footballguy
New concept for you - different people have different opinions. I don't care what yours is. I do care that there are others out there that would pay it - I've seen it. You think it's ludicrous - fine, go with that. You think TE4 is part of a big 'ol tier - fine, go with that too. I'm not offering Rudolph to you so I don't know why you care so much.
Streetduck
Footballguy
Hankmoody
Footballguy
Roster deadline so I should have included "plus the roster spot" since I had to cut a guy (and he saved a guy) in addition. Still happy to pay it.
kittenmittens
Footballguy
