I would take the 1.01 there 100% of the time, but it seems like a fairly even transaction.FFPC not involved
Team A gave James Robinson, 2022 1st (looks late to me)
Team B gave 1.01
I would take the 1.01 there 100% of the time, but it seems like a fairly even transaction.FFPC not involved
Team A gave James Robinson, 2022 1st (looks late to me)
Team B gave 1.01
Robinson isn’t close to being worth the 1.01.I see. So Robinson would be 1.01? Perhaps I really undervalued Robinson. I'm beginning to regret moving him for what I did. Smart money says he's the starter. I still think Meyer is going to want his guy for some reason. Then he's an asset that just lost a whole lot of value. Enough about me. Calcs have this all even, as do I. My personal thought: I think getting Chase or whoever you believe in (I'm not thinking that the guy is picking Harris or Etienne for two reasons. Age, and they haven't proven they're three down backs yet. Why would you move a younger, three-down Robinson for one of those guys?) is good value for the pick and Robinson.
What pick would he be worth to you?Robinson isn’t close to being worth the 1.01.
I see. So Robinson would be 1.01? Perhaps I really undervalued Robinson. I'm beginning to regret moving him for what I did. Smart money says he's the starter. I still think Meyer is going to want his guy for some reason. Then he's an asset that just lost a whole lot of value. Enough about me. Calcs have this all even, as do I. My personal thought: I think getting Chase or whoever you believe in (I'm not thinking that the guy is picking Harris or Etienne for two reasons. Age, and they haven't proven they're three down backs yet. Why would you move a younger, three-down Robinson for one of those guys?) is good value for the pick and Robinson.
I think it totally depends on who your 1.01 is. Like rock said, if you have Chase at 1.01 I think that's reasonable to consider him over Robinson. If you view a RB (whichever one, Harris, Etienne, Williams, Hubbard, whoever) as the 1.01 I think it's a no-brainer to prefer James Robinson. I prefer Williams at 1.01 right now, and I would prefer to have Robinson over him. Maybe rookie hype hasn't peaked yet and since we don't know landing spot the conversation for the 1.01 is still relatively open. When it's a little more defined there seems to be an argument either way.Robinson isn’t close to being worth the 1.01.
We'll just pretend you already made the trade. I like it for you.Which side do you like? 1 point PPR, FFPC dynasty league.
Stefon Diggs
for
2021 01.07 & 2021 01.10 picks
I am rebuilding would get Diggs. I have 4 first round picks, those two plus 01.02 and 01.04.
For your first question above, you're really looking for the Assistant Coach Forum. For this one you're looking for the Dynasty Value thread here in the Pool.FFPC 1 QB Dynasty league is A Rodgers worth a 2021 02.10 and 2022 2nd?
If not more or less?
Thanks for your feedback
Thanks I posted over there a few days ago and go no feedback. The subject of this thread said Dynasty trades so thought it was for that. Thanks for the feedback.For your first question above, you're really looking for the Assistant Coach Forum. For this one you're looking for the Dynasty Value thread here in the Pool.
Since you already have Watson and Murray, I'd take the two dart throws for Rodgers (I'm just not a proponent of hoarding QBs). Unless you could trade one of the others for a first.
You value this roster as rebuilding?! It looks more like a team coming off from a championship.Which side do you like? 1 point PPR, FFPC dynasty league.
Stefon Diggs
for
2021 01.07 & 2021 01.10 picks
I am rebuilding would get Diggs. I have 4 first round picks, those two plus 01.02 and 01.04.
my current WR are:
C. Sutton
C. Claypool
C. Samuel
M. Pittman
B. Edwards
Q. Cephus
others I am keeping:
QB A. Rogers
QB K. Murray
QB D. Watson
RB M. Sanders
RB Z. Moss
RB T. Pollard
RB L. Bowden
TE D. Goedert
K and D
We keep 16 before rookie draft.
Seen to many RB's value get trashed during the draft or earlier in FA process so as a general rule I think it's bad business to buy a veteran RB before those things happen especially when giving up an asset that is flexible and fairly bulletproof from dropping.FFPC not involved
Team A gave James Robinson, 2022 1st (looks late to me)
Team B gave 1.01
It finished in 11th place in 12 team league. Besides QB, not much consistency and lots of injuries. But I do hope to turn it around quickly and think Diggs would help.You value this roster as rebuilding?! It looks more like a team coming off from a championship.
I’m not necessarily a believer. I wouldn’t be shocked if the Jags either sign a free agent or draft a back early that cuts heavily into Robinson’s workload - and to me volume had much to do with his success.What pick would he be worth to you?
I think I like James Robinson basically equal to the 1.01 or close, but I know I am probably in the minority (as usual). I can't see paying that price to get 1.01, but I might a few months from now. So maybe it does make sense given how much more it will be worth as we move on. Could easily flip for another deal better than Robinson plus a late 1st. So...?
No, not 1.01 but in that neighborhood. I am probably being too liberal with the use of the phrase "basically equal" when really "or close" is more like it. But even within that world what I consider to be close and what other people consider to be close are often two different things. Even if we were to agree on Robinson. I like Robinson better than any of the RBs in this crop today, but that is subject to change. But I do think it is likely there are two or three WRs that will be preferable. This is one where I don't think I would give up the 1.01 if this offer came into my box but I wouldn't spend James Robinson and a 1st to get there either.I see. So Robinson would be 1.01? Perhaps I really undervalued Robinson. I'm beginning to regret moving him for what I did. Smart money says he's the starter. I still think Meyer is going to want his guy for some reason. Then he's an asset that just lost a whole lot of value. Enough about me. Calcs have this all even, as do I. My personal thought: I think getting Chase or whoever you believe in (I'm not thinking that the guy is picking Harris or Etienne for two reasons. Age, and they haven't proven they're three down backs yet. Why would you move a younger, three-down Robinson for one of those guys?) is good value for the pick and Robinson.
Mid 1st?Where do you value Dak in a start 1 QB league. What players would you trade him for? What future draft picks is he worth?
I was just approached asking what it would take to sell him and I didn't really think about it, but he is expendable so just wanting to get some opinions.
I've always been told that most start 1 QBs aren't worth a 1st.Where do you value Dak in a start 1 QB league. What players would you trade him for? What future draft picks is he worth?
I was just approached asking what it would take to sell him and I didn't really think about it, but he is expendable so just wanting to get some opinions.
Who does he have ahead of Dak?I've always been told that most start 1 QBs aren't worth a 1st.
I offered a 2022 1st and Tonyan to a guy who won't start Prescott but for a bye week...rejected with no counter.
EH, I can see the Robinson side. rookies are always a crapshoot. At least Robinson has proven somethingI would take the 1.01 there 100% of the time, but it seems like a fairly even transaction.
True, but you’re literally getting the best of the bunch. They can certainly bust too, but I would say it’s not very likely. I like James Robinson. Had him on a team last year that lost Saquon Barkley and he was a huge reason I even made the playoffs. But I do still have some doubts. Perhaps I put too much emphasis on draft capital, but I’m always apprehensive about late round or undrafted guys. I would be surprised if Jrob isn’t still the lead back in Jacksonville. I would not be surprised if they draft or bring in a somewhat high profile FA and they pilfer more carries from Jrob than his owners would like.EH, I can see the Robinson side. rookies are always a crapshoot. At least Robinson has proven something
I can see why then w/that uncertainty, but in a start 1 QB I will move my QB2 for a real offer. Hell, I want to move Lamar who is my QB1, but no offersWatson
Thing is there's very few UDFA RB's with nice rookie years that end up having continued success. I read an article a few months back about this topic and other than Arien Foster I can't think of anyone else. Sure Lindsey and a few others have had moderate success but not rookie 1.01 type value.EH, I can see the Robinson side. rookies are always a crapshoot. At least Robinson has proven something
What would Robinson be worth in your opinion as far as rookie picks in dynasty leagues go?Thing is there's very few UDFA RB's with nice rookie years that end up having continued success. I read an article a few months back about this topic and other than Arien Foster I can't think of anyone else. Sure Lindsey and a few others have had moderate success but not rookie 1.01 type value.
Full disclosure: I am lower on Robinson than the consensus. Being a UFDA and playing a position that generally doesn't have a long shelf life I'd probably have him around 1.08ish as I like Harris, Etienne, Chase, Pitts, Moore, Smith, Waddle and possibly Bateman and Javonte Williams over himWhat would Robinson be worth in your opinion as far as rookie picks in dynasty leagues go?
It's pretty close between Lamb and Jacobs for me, so the 1st side pretty easily.12 team, .5 PPR, 1 QB
Gave
Josh Jacobs, Davantae Booker, and 6.1
for
CeeDee Lamb, 2022 1st, and 4.4
Lamb > Jacobs so...free 2022 first.12 team, .5 PPR, 1 QB
Gave
Josh Jacobs, Davantae Booker, and 6.1
for
CeeDee Lamb, 2022 1st, and 4.4
Thanks and I still have Barkley, Kamara, Montgomery, Mixon, Snell, and Gus Edwards at RB but was a little light at WR behind my top 2.It's pretty close between Lamb and Jacobs for me, so the 1st side pretty easily.
I find them a bit even but I am a big RB believer in fantasy. The guy wanting Jacobs is a Raider fan and his top 2 RBs are Akers and Lat Murray so don't think it was a terrible move for him either.Lamb > Jacobs so...free 2022 first.
Every single one of these trades is lopsided.Same league with 12 teams, .5 PPR, and 1 QB....yesterday was the 1st day trades could be made official...IMO there were terrible trades below:
Team A gets - 1.5
Team B gets - 1.11 & 2.11
Team A gets - 2023 1st
Team C gets - 3.4 & 4.4
Team A gets - 2022 2nd & 2023 2nd
Team D gets - 2022 3rd & Leonard Fournette
I'm not a fan of any of these deals.
Give me the good picks in all and very easily.Same league with 12 teams, .5 PPR, and 1 QB....yesterday was the 1st day trades could be made official...IMO there were terrible trades below:
Team A gets - 1.5
Team B gets - 1.11 & 2.11
Team A gets - 2023 1st
Team C gets - 3.4 & 4.4
Team A gets - 2022 2nd & 2023 2nd
Team D gets - 2022 3rd & Leonard Fournette
I'm not a fan of any of these deals.
In all, Team A gives: 1.11, 2.11, 3.4, 4.4, 2022 3rd, Leonard FournetteSame league with 12 teams, .5 PPR, and 1 QB....yesterday was the 1st day trades could be made official...IMO there were terrible trades below:
Team A gets - 1.5
Team B gets - 1.11 & 2.11
Team A gets - 2023 1st
Team C gets - 3.4 & 4.4
Team A gets - 2022 2nd & 2023 2nd
Team D gets - 2022 3rd & Leonard Fournette
I'm not a fan of any of these deals.
I get what you mean.I've always been told that most start 1 QBs aren't worth a 1st.
I offered a 2022 1st and Tonyan to a guy who won't start Prescott but for a bye week...rejected with no counter.
You got the right idea12 team, superflex
Sent
2.7, 3.7
Received
2.11, 8.11, Alexander Mattison
He's only 22, and the Vikes are gonna have to make a decision at rb .....pony up on cook, or let Mattison walk.
Gives me a few guys to hope pan out at rb.....edmonds, eno, Gus Edwards, penny
Only decent backs are Hunt, and Gibson
Vikings already paid Cook.12 team, superflex
Sent
2.7, 3.7
Received
2.11, 8.11, Alexander Mattison
He's only 22, and the Vikes are gonna have to make a decision at rb .....pony up on cook, or let Mattison walk.
Gives me a few guys to hope pan out at rb.....edmonds, eno, Gus Edwards, penny
Only decent backs are Hunt, and Gibson
Thanks AD.......and I missed that I guess, I knew a decision was going to have to be made, and cook is the answerVikings already paid Cook.
5 year contract extension on September 12, 2020 worth $63 million in new money with a little over $16.3 million fully guaranteed at signing including a $15,506,361 signing bonus and fully guaranteed 2020 base salary..
& a roster spot for 2-3 yrs.Thanks AD.......and I missed that I guess, I knew a decision was going to have to be made, and cook is the answer
So Mattison is a ufa in 2023, age of 25. I can live with that, and he will have fresh legs, and essentially cost me a 3rd rounder
I don’t think I’d give any 1st for Jeudy right now.12 team ppr QB/2RB/3WR/TE/FL
Team A gave up
Jeudy, Jerry DEN WR;
Miller, Scott TBB WR
Team B gave up
Ertz, Zach PHI TE;
1.06
Good one. I've been wondering what it would take to go from the 8 to one of the 3/4/5. I think this is about right for you.12 team non-ppr, QB/2RB/3WR/TE/FL
Gave 1.08, 2.06
Got 1.06
I also have 2.01 and 2.08, and wanted to get into top six of the draft. Probably paid to much to move up two spot mid round, but .
Why is the three/four/five crucial, might I ask, and who do you see there?Good one. I've been wondering what it would take to go from the 8 to one of the 3/4/5. I think this is about right for you.
Because I think the top five are pretty clear in a set of Harris/Chase/Etienne/Waddle/Smith. I could maybe have my arm twisted to go to six with Williams.Why is the three/four/five crucial, might I ask, and who do you see there?