Leroy Hoard
Footballguy
Last couple really not bad songs.
After a while us older kids ditched our ours for paper bags containing a minimum lunch. We would wolf that down and leave for the playground which was directly across the street from a party store. Where we would spend all our money on junk food like chips and candy bars.Never had a lunch box
I always had the brown paper bag, with a PBJ, a bag of chips, sometimes an apple and some change to hit the vending machine for a milk and an ice cream sandwich. All of which was consumed in about 90 seconds and then off to play hoops.After a while us older kids ditched our ours for paper bags containing a minimum lunch. We would wolf that down and leave for the playground which was directly across the street from a party store. Where we would spend all our money on junk food like chips and candy bars.
That's an intriguing idea.I always thought the medley was perfect and Majesty really only would work on The White Album.
I don't think Honey Pie is a bad song, either. We're getting into the realm of not bad but just stuff I personally don't like so much, or stuff that gets docked for being a snippet or a cover not as good as the original. And the Beatles had so many good songs that something ranked, say, 150th is still going to be pretty damn good.Last couple really not bad songs.
Mine was better.My 1st-grade lunchbox ...#####es. When it mattered what metal lunchbox you had, and Thermoses were still cool.
So yeah, you could say I'm a little partial to the Beatles.
Guess what my answer is...I'll admit it; I'm struggling to come up with much to say about these songs. Could I skip to #10 or at least #50 or something I'm excited about?
YOUR HILLBILLY ### NEEDS TO ROOT FOR BAMA!!!!cap'n grunge said:
GB Robert Palmer. This album (Clues) is such a trip - he collaborates with Gary Numan on couple of tunes, has this Beatles cover, but the hits were none of that stuff.Suggested cover: Robert Palmer Fun, and even adds his own verse.
Aww, shucks. I always liked this song. But I had black and white Beatles posters on my wall in college, so you know where I stand with respect to early vs. late Beatles.194. Not a Second Time (With the Beatles, 1963)
Wow you're needy. Just let her do her thing.timschochet said:One more suggestion- can you list the album and year of the song? For songs like “Dig It” that I don’t inmediately remember it would help to reference it.
I knew I'd "lose" you as soon as I got into lower rankings for some early stuff, instead of just picking on the White Album all the time. Never fear, more White Album coming soon!Aww, shucks. I always liked this song. But I had black and white Beatles posters on my wall in college, so you know where I stand with respect to early vs. late Beatles.
Eh, it's all subjective. God Bless picking on the White Album, though.I knew I'd "lose" you as soon as I got into lower rankings for some early stuff, instead of just picking on the White Album all the time. Never fear, more White Album coming soon!
Well, this the Beatles we're talking about.Leroy Hoard said:Last couple really not bad songs.
This list is fluid, too. It was a last-minute decision to drop Not a Second Time and Little Child down in the rankings - they were ~8 slots up earlier today (not that that's a huge difference). I have these in not-sure-how-many tiers at this point, generally of about 10-12 each, and songs are continuing to move around in those tiers. I had actually done the whole write-up for a different song before deciding to move those down instead. Even now I look and think I should have switched just those two... I had to start this thread just so I'd commit to the rankings and stop thinking about it.Eh, it's all subjective. God Bless picking on the White Album, though.
I kid. Every Beatles album has great songs on it. I just need to be in the right frame of mind to listen to the later stuff. I also thought I couldn't listen to the early to mid '70s Kinks, either, and simey got me into Muswell Hillbillies, which wound up being this year's Xmas gift from the folks, so ignore the barbs from this part of the audience and maybe I'll have some new stuff to revere when the list drops and becomes more into focus for the rest of us.
This is a Herculean effort, as far as online rankings are considered. Fun. Love your and Mr. Krista's comments about the songs. I totally cannot analyze music in that way. Impressed.This list is fluid, too. It was a last-minute decision to drop Not a Second Time and Little Child down in the rankings - they were ~8 slots up earlier today (not that that's a huge difference). I have these in not-sure-how-many tiers at this point, generally of about 10-12 each, and songs are continuing to move around in those tiers. I had actually done the whole write-up for a different song before deciding to move those down instead. Even now I look and think I should have switched just those two... I had to start this thread just so I'd commit to the rankings and stop thinking about it.
Exactly. If I’ve learned anything from the first dozen songs on this list, it is that I don’t dislike any songs by the Beatles.Well, this the Beatles we're talking about.
Thanks. I haven’t done much analysis yet (“these drums make me angry” probably won’t qualify), but promise to include a lot more once we get to songs I rank more highly. Right now I’m just slogging through to get to my favorite stuff.This is a Herculean effort, as far as online rankings are considered. Fun. Love your and Mr. Krista's comments about the songs. I totally cannot analyze music in that way. Impressed.
Oh man. You don’t have to apologize when I’m the d*ck.Gr00vus said:I should have been clearer. I was just hoping that @krista4 would note in the summary list where the good stuff starts. It would be nice for those of us who can't keep up with the thread to know where to start listening in while avoiding the dregs.
Sorry if my initial post came off as snarky, that was not my intent.
YOU GET NO APPETIZER!!!!!Oh man. You don’t have to apologize when I’m the d*ck.
When Krista makes an epic thread ranking your posts, my color would be something like:YOUR HILLBILLY ### NEEDS TO ROOT FOR BAMA!!!!
Ain't nobody south of the Mason Dixon line would ever consider these two jagaloons even close to The Beatles.
Still very popular.
I was raised well.When Krista makes an epic thread ranking your posts, my color would be something like:
”Strong capslock game and EXCELLENT use of the jagaloon. Timeless. Not a lot of dudes using multiple punctuation marks at that time, either.”
My favorite transition is between Polythene Pam and She Came In Through the Bathroom Window. Kills me every time. Look out!!Wow - I fell behind here. I had never heard the Abbey Road medley with Her Majesty shoved in the middle, though I knew that was the intent.
Thank God they cut it out of there, as the Mustard/Pam smash cut is one of my favorite things in all of Beatledom. Majesty kills that medley vibe dead
Did not know that about the medley. Coo-ul and right choicekrista4 said:ARrrrrrgghhhhh, just typed all this up and lost it. Here's a newly truncated version.
196. Her Majesty (Abbey Road, 1969)
This is one of the songs that made it easier to draw pimples & such on sis's Beatle posterkrista4 said:Speaking of covers that aren't as good as the originals...
195. Chains (Please Please Me, 1963)
Hitmaking. Each four bars here there's a one-note change off a proven Beatle motif. If the adults have lots of cash, sometimes you listen...194. Not a Second Time (With the Beatles, 1963)
By 'clangy', i meant the ringing sound of Rickenbackers that made their filler songs perky enough to be forgiven. This is more clunkyIt's a "With the Beatles" run:
193. Little Child (With the Beatles, 1963)
Between 1965-75, i hitchhiked almost a quarter of a million miles. It's lonely work and, in sparser regions, you end up doing little more than staring at a lot of pavement for hours on end. Singing WDWDIITR as you do helps.One more so east-coasters have something to talk about in the morning. I have freaking conference calls starting at 7 a.m., so I'll be back in the later morning to see how it goes.
Reminder that we're in the realm of not-awful now, but it's the Beatles so something still has to be in the 190s, and I'm sure I have this lower than many of you would.
192. Why Don't We Do It in the Road? (White Album, 1968)
I think this is a spot-on position for this dreck. This came on the Beatles channel a few nights ago when my wife was with me, and I hadn't heard it in a long time. Granted, she is not the Beatles appreciator I am, but, after about 30 seconds of Paul repeating himself, she was like "Is this song about what I think it's about? If so, it's dumb." And I had to agree.One more so east-coasters have something to talk about in the morning. I have freaking conference calls starting at 7 a.m., so I'll be back in the later morning to see how it goes.
Reminder that we're in the realm of not-awful now, but it's the Beatles so something still has to be in the 190s, and I'm sure I have this lower than many of you would.
192. Why Don't We Do It in the Road? (White Album, 1968)
Beatles version: Spotify YouTube
As I look back at it, I probably should have kept this in a lower position, since it's the only song left that kind of irritates me. What's done is done!
Paul knocked this out without input from John or George, which apparently hurt John's feelings, though John later professed (perhaps sarcastically) to loving this song. I appreciate Paul's description of the inspiration for the song, which was based on an experience in India: "I was up on the flat roof meditating and I'd seen a troupe of monkeys walking along in the jungle and a male just hopped on to the back of this female and gave her one, as they say in the vernacular. Within two or three seconds he hopped off again, and looked around as if to say, 'It wasn't me,' and she looked around as if there had been some mild disturbance but thought, Huh, I must have imagined it, and she wandered off. And I thought, bloody hell, that puts it all into a cocked hat, that's how simple the act of procreation is, this bloody monkey just hopping on and hopping off. There is an urge, they do it, and it's done with. And it's that simple. We have horrendous problems with it, and yet animals don't. So that was basically it. Why Don't We Do It In The Road? could have applied to either ####### or ####ting, to put it roughly. Why don't we do either of them in the road? Well, the answer is we're civilised and we don't. But the song was just to pose that question. Why Don't We Do It In The Road? was a primitive statement to do with sex or to do with freedom really. I like it, it'd just so outrageous that I like it."
I appreciate the sentiment here (how you doin'?), but what makes the song irritating to me is Paul's vocal. What is he trying to do? This is one of those times when I feel like Paul's ability to perform in different genres almost slips into unintended parody, unlike John's "Yer Blues," which will be ranked much higher.
But as to Paul's vocal, let's have Mr. krista take over: "Such a throwaway track. One good line, but the song doesn’t really go anywhere. Pretty half-assed. Can you imagine if George had had something to do with it, like a killer guitar part? George could have really helped that song. So dumb, so half-assed. Trying to sound like BB King. Shut your British hole. You're doing it in the bed, the curtains closed. It's a well appointed room, or whatever the opposite of a road is. [20-minute diatribe regarding English people trying to co-opt the blues, complete with comparison to if we tried to make a Native American song by doing the woo-woo-woo with our hands hitting our mouths and saying "how?".]
Suggested cover: Lowell Fulsom Holy hell, this is how blues should sound. And listen to those angry guitars.
A little late to the game, but I agree with wikkid here. One of my favorite Beatles tunes, but different viewpoints are what make this thread. And then again, I like just about anything by George.krista4 said:
I love this song. I will grant they have so much good that there is a ton that was "better," but while the ones that have been posted before it won't make me stop too often to listen, this one will every time. Which I guess is one of the intended/unintended points to this exercise - there is so much here.One more so east-coasters have something to talk about in the morning. I have freaking conference calls starting at 7 a.m., so I'll be back in the later morning to see how it goes.
Reminder that we're in the realm of not-awful now, but it's the Beatles so something still has to be in the 190s, and I'm sure I have this lower than many of you would.
192. Why Don't We Do It in the Road? (White Album, 1968)
at taking a burning building and dying man to lunch everyday .A little late to the game, but I agree with wikkid here. One of my favorite Beatles tunes, but different viewpoints are what make this thread. And then again, I like just about anything by George.
And this was my first lunch box. :rampart:
BRRRRAAAAANNNNNGGGGG.....A little late to the game, but I agree with wikkid here. One of my favorite Beatles tunes, but different viewpoints are what make this thread. And then again, I like just about anything by George.
And this was my first lunch box. :rampart:
I like this oneat taking a burning building and dying man to lunch everyday .
Nowadays they would take Zam into the school shrink to make sure he didn't identify with the arsonist.at taking a burning building and dying man to lunch everyday .
With the 3rd grade girls, made me as suave as Randolph Mantooth.at taking a burning building and dying man to lunch everyday .
That song has been stuck in my head all morning now. LOL.By the way, loving the different perspectives being expressed, particularly on Why Don't We Do It in the Road, which seems pretty polarizing. I'm not doing a good job of responding because I am trying to get more songs posted. Am I posting them too fast? Too slow?
i'll never sleep again....I have a few minutes between meetings.
I've realized from this exercise that I enjoy the White Album significantly more as a whole than as the sum of its parts. Some songs from it will be ranked highly; I'm just kinda feeling sorry for it right now. On that theme:
191. Good Night (White Album, 1968)
Calling it now: he's going to be the show-stealing breakout star in all of this. Like Melissa McCarthy in Bridesmaids.BroncoFreak_2K3 said:I like the cut of Mr. krista’s jib
You have 190 more to go. So, you know... whatever works for you.I'm not doing a good job of responding because I am trying to get more songs posted. Am I posting them too fast? Too slow?
Thanks for the reminder that I'm less than 7% done.You have 190 more to go. So, you know... whatever works for you.
Never a personal favorite, which is funny, because Billy Joel's Lullabye is basically the same song message and feel wise, and Iove that.I have a few minutes between meetings.
I've realized from this exercise that I enjoy the White Album significantly more as a whole than as the sum of its parts. Some songs from it will be ranked highly; I'm just kinda feeling sorry for it right now. On that theme:
191. Good Night (White Album, 1968)
Beatles version: Spotify YouTube