Is this a steal - trade Barkley, Adams for Zeke, Bell, Ridley (1 Viewer)

I been offered the following trade:

Bell, Zeke and Ridley for Barkley and Adams.

Do I pull the trigger?

Thanks!

Yes.   I make that trade. 

Do it...

Yeah I would agree and make that trade, assuming you're not in a dire situation waiting on Adams to get back. Do it.

Would you mind taking a look at mine? https://forums.footballguys.com/forum/topic/781372-josh-jacobs-keeper-trade-advice-needed-whir/

If this is a dynasty/keeper league accept right away.  If this is a redraft it would depend on your roster and starting requirements for me. 

I think I misread it.  I would want the Barkley side in a dynasty league easily.  In a redraft I would lean towards the Zeke side depending on starting requirements and roster. 

Personally, I see this trade as about even.

What are the scoring rules, PPR or standard?  Dynasty, keeper, or redraft?

Besides the league rules, what I would do with this offer depends heavily on how you value Barkley.

If he is all world and the generational talent that some thinks he is, then I easily take the Barkley side.

If you think he is about the same value as Zeke, take the Zeke side.

I can easily see good arguments both way.

I would take the Zeke side because I do not see Barkley as the all world next generational talent, but this offer is for you and not me.

I think the NY Giants have a big rebuild on their hands in real life.

Hope this helps.

I thing you pull the trigger on this deal as soon as possible.  I like Zeke over Barkley moving forward.  Ridley and Bell for a hurt Adams is very fair.  

Please see my post:

https://forums.footballguys.com/forum/topic/781401-trade-obj-and-ty-johnson-for-hopkins/