Edmonds or Lindsay

[jmble 58]

1 point ppr league.

In a perfect world I won't have to start either.  Lindsay is currently the fifth running back on my roster.  Both would be keepable and neither would cost me any draft picks to keep.

Who would you rather have for the future and a potential emergency start?  Phillip Lindsay or Chase Edmonds?

 

[CMU37484 6]

I think THIS year it's Lindsay but long term I might rather own Edmonds.  Hard to see Kenyon Drake as the long term solution in Arizona and he seems more injury prone.  Melvin Gordon is the main back in Denver probably for at least a couple years.  In the short term, if you were forced to play one, I'd play Lindsay.

 

Please see mine.................https://forums.footballguys.com/forum/topic/788505-trade-for-mccaffery/

[jmble 58]

I admit, part of my asking is that the League Dominator has Edmonds about seven spots higher than Lindsay on their "rest of the season" rankings.  I wasn't sure if it was just the potential turf toe or if they think Edmonds has a decent chance of breaking out ahead of Lindsay.