Te premium superflex

[blakeus36 1]

I've been trying to shop chris carson a little, I'm in a superflex te premium dynasty and I got offered mike gesicki straight up, my te is tragic so is this a good trade?

[jwsbowler 212]

league size, starting requirements, roster, scoring???  IMO, my gut on just the players without any other information is no, I would not do it based on player value.  I have Carson value much higher.

[Gally 4,699]

3 hours ago, jwsbowler said:

league size, starting requirements, roster, scoring???  IMO, my gut on just the players without any other information is no, I would not do it based on player value.  I have Carson value much higher.

While this may be true, if the owner has RB depth and this doesn't hurt their starting lineup it may still be a decent move to make (especially in a TE premium league).  Gesicki is a hard one to evaluate because Tua is so inconsistent.  If you believe Tua will improve on that, then Gesicki should be a top 5-8ish TE moving forward.  

 

I don't mind the trade as I have never been a fantasy fan of Carson (I think he is a very good NFL back that is injury prone and sometimes disappears so seems frustrating to own).  

[jwsbowler 212]

8 hours ago, Gally said:

While this may be true, if the owner has RB depth and this doesn't hurt their starting lineup it may still be a decent move to make (especially in a TE premium league).  Gesicki is a hard one to evaluate because Tua is so inconsistent.  If you believe Tua will improve on that, then Gesicki should be a top 5-8ish TE moving forward.  

 

I don't mind the trade as I have never been a fantasy fan of Carson (I think he is a very good NFL back that is injury prone and sometimes disappears so seems frustrating to own).  

I do agree with you, with no other information it is tough to figure out.  If the team has the pieces, then... it might make sense.