Pick a Side, Any Side (1 Viewer)

12 team ppr dynasty

I turned down this trade....Roster aside, which would you prefer?

2.05, 2.11, Tua, Waller, Gaskin

Kyler Murray, Keenen Allen, Singletary

It is close if it is a TE required league.  If not it is easily the Murray side for me.  

TE required (Can also Flex a second one) but no premium scoring. 

Prefer the Murray Allen side

Seems close.  The two 2nd rounders are lotto tickets I'd imagine.  Tua is still an unknown, didn't look great.  But people fail to acknowledge that he is still coming off a major injury.  And I'd be surprised if Gaskin is the main guy next year.  Singletary took a major downturn after that promising rookie year.  Keenan Allen is close to the downside of his career, but still relevant.

I lean towards Murray/Allen over Waller without knowing much more specifics of the league.

I know you said to disregard the remainder of the roster, but I still have to devalue the side with 5 items vs the side with 3 items. If the picks were higher maybe, but those aren't great picks, so I would lean toward MurrAllSing. Disclaimer: I've never been in a TE mandatory league. So I don't have a good feel of just how valuable a TE is, but obviously I understand that they are significantly more valuable that way.

eighsse said:

I know you said to disregard the remainder of the roster, but I still have to devalue the side with 5 items vs the side with 3 items. If the picks were higher maybe, but those aren't great picks, so I would lean toward MurrAllSing. Disclaimer: I've never been in a TE mandatory league. So I don't have a good feel of just how valuable a TE is, but obviously I understand that they are significantly more valuable that way.

Click to expand...

In the end, I ended up moving the picks plus a first and a third and Tua for Mahomes