wikkidpissah
Footballguy
i'm still voting your squad over Modogg's - mostly cuz, as i said earlier, DC woulda NEVER showed up to games if he was asked to play the post in his prime - which is kinda vital - and you might as well take ANY pasty PG if you're putting him next to MJ cuz he's turning him into BJArmstrong even if he's John Stockton, but i wish you'd gone Phil Smith (another 5-brilliant-yrs-Achilles guy) or Don Chaney - or taken Doug Collins earlier - @ SG instead of sliding Gus over from PG. woulda been your hype man til the end...(tho that mighta been less effective than making em look up Phil Smith).I have no doubt that Modogg's team will beat mine purely on the basis of recency bias and the amazing back-court; but, I question how, specifically, his team will win. First-things-first....my squad (here are the front-court's career rankings).
C Artis Gilmore
PF Elvin Hayes
SF Dr J
SG Gus Williams
PG John Lucas
Questions:
(1) How will Modogg's team score more than higgins' squad? We all know MJ will get his (plus some) and that Stockton will have to up his scoring but his team simply doesn't have the offensive fire power to put up enough points to contend with my big-3, who rank as the #8, #12, and #27 career scoring leaders. I understand that some people may prefer to ignore career stats and go solely by their peaks BUT even IF we were to take each player's peak scoring season the result would be higgins 123.5 -to- Modogg 114.4. The ABA has the rep (deserved or not) of having less defense than the NBA. But even IF we were to take the top scoring NBA seasons (instead of ABA) for Dr J and Artis (only players that played in the ABA), the tally would still be higgins 120.2 -to- 114.4....which leads me to my next question.
(2) Even IF Stockton has his best scoring day(s) in this series/game, how is his front-court going to score more than a minimum? Did you see the defensive rankings for my front-court? Majerle, LJ and DC weren't ever the alpha dogs on their own teams? How are they going to score against all-time defensive alpha dogs?....which leads me to my next question.
(3) How is Modogg's team going to get more than a minimum of rebounds? Again, please take a look at the rebound rankings from the link above....now answer the question.
My guess is that the only answer Modogg would be able to come up with is that IF Stockton has the offensive series/game of his life and IF we ignore the offensive peaks of the ABA years and IF we were playing in modern, spread offense-terms (which benefits his team), that his team could very well win.
Again, I fully expect Modogg's squad to win this voting -- my only question is whether they deserve to.
Last edited by a moderator: