I don't feel either was worth a 1st round pick. RB's are only worthy of 1sts if they are truly elite talents. There are 5 in the NFL right now in my opinion. CMC, Chubb, Cook, Kamara, and Henry, and even then Henry(and probably Kamara) is somewhat situation dependent. Barkley was probably on the list too, before his ACL tear, though he was a reach at #2 to me as well.
I really hated a team that has a solid RB in Robinson, and an ok backup in Hyde, taking a RB in round 1, when they have holes all over. Also, Robinson, despite being an undrafted FA, played well at the NFL level, and I doubt he'll be cast aside easily.
I am actually pretty concerned about Urban Meyer's tenure. I was very unimpressed by what then Jags did with the league's most cap space, and I'm unimpressed by this 1st round, not counting Lawrence who anyone would have taken at #1.