Andor was masterful. I loved Mando but this far surpasses it. All of the acting was superb, no one fell short and there was some truly great acting as well. Stellen deserves every award possible that he could be up for with that performance. He knocked it out of the park. It was nice to see an actual Andy versus his performances behind CG. (He is extremely under appreciated as an actor I think because he does so much of that CG character stuff, people don't know him as an actor). The casting director did an absolutely magnificent job.
The directing and writing, two things that I feel often is below average to awful from many of the Disney + shows, was all exceptional. The storyline was well thought out and the dialogue was at times some of the best Star Wars has ever produced. It didn't seem like they strained to throw in some cameo or tie in.
The production, SFX, CGI, etc was all top notch feature film quality.
There really was no weak point in this offering. There is no good explanaton if you don't like this unless you have ADHD and can't sit still for 5 seconds then maybe some flashy light elsewhere takes your attention away and 'you got bored' or you are 8 years old- then I get it. Otherwise, I think this can be enjoyed by any adult that enjoys quality.
I can not wait until season 2. Hopefully Marvel can get some inspiration on this and produce something that can take the bad taste away from the crap they have been doing on Disney + of late.
Just finished episode 12, and I like Andor. I thought Mando was better though. I thought Andor was a bit too much acting, and dialogue.....which were both superb.....just not enough action. Mando was a good balance. And had lots of very memorable characters.....I thought the characters in Mando rival any of the movies, and definitely way better than anything since the original trilogy......it just felt more like Star Wars to me...the music, the spaghetti western feel all added to Mando in and made it feel fresh.....I think Mando was just what Star Wars needed. Andor is very good, don't get me wrong, just a bit too dramatic for my taste......and where are all the funky Star Wars aliens? It was mostly humans.....BORING!!!
My 10 yo son was completely bored with Andor.....he loved Mando.