Awful when healthy? dude posted a 39 point game! he puts up a solid 10-13 points a week when healthy. When he has the full load, or majority... he will produce.
. His longest run was 30 yards this year and he hasn't had a reception over 20 yards since 2011.
On the other hand he was only healthy for a few games to start the season and one of those games he had 4 runs over 20 yards. You know who else had a game this year with 4 20+ yard runs? No one, that's who.
Sounds about right. I see McFadden as little more than COP at this point. He can handle the load for a couple of games, but he's a breakdown waiting to happen. As a vet, I expect his blitz pick-up is probably good enought (though can't say that I've seen him enough in that capacity) that he'd make a potent third down back and maybe carve out some FF relevance in a Woodhead type role, but that's his top range.
No one is debating his injury history.
But because you've been hurt in the past does not insure you will be hurt in the future. Opposite is also true. We are talking about a guy who has never had a major surgery and played several seasons of big time college football without missing a game. He's established himself as a massive injury risk/red flag but none of that means it's going to happen, just means he should be downgraded for the potential risk he's earned.
His ceiling is not Woodhead.
Fred Taylor (AKA Fragile Freddie) couldn't stay healthy for an entire season, until all of a sudden he could. With his track record I sure wouldn't bet that DMC won't miss any games due to injury, but there is a precedent that the injury prone label can be shed.
And going back to the stat of no receptions over 20 yards since 2011 - for what it is worth, in one of the early games this year he had a 40+ yard reception that went for a TD that was called back due to a penalty on the other side of the field that was unrelated to the play. I think it is premature to conclude that he doesn't have it anymore (not saying that he does, but I haven't seen enough to draw a conclusion either way).