funny enough, the bolded above was one of the main things i was thinking when i posted in here. I think Vick is a little different cause he did time for his poor choices and gave the impression he was contrite when he came out. That being said, i was definitely a less of a fan of the Eagles when he played for them. wasn't necessarily a conscious thing, but i had a hard time cheering when he scored a TD and honestly lost some interest in the team, and thus NFL overall, during his time with the Eagles. Even with him doing jail time and all of that, it just never really sat ok with me to cheer him on. I was still a big fan with the rest of the team, but the nature of the QB position made it so that i couldn't ignore or overlook him enough.
With Smallwood, i was not happy with it when they drafted him. I have heard people talk about the situation and speak about Smallwood in a postiive light, but still bothers me. it is hard to tell what is actually the case and which isn't because it seems many fans are able to make excuses for their team (speaking of the reports i heard from WVU).
Completely agree with you with the smoking weed thing, and am always annoyed when they group an issue of smoking weed in with the rest of these DV and dog fighting issues. People talked about Josh Gordon coming to Philly before this off-season and i remember discussing this ad nauseum.
as for Elliot and the court not making anything of it, i dont hold much weight to that. Domestic violence is tricky when it comes to the courts and convictions, but for me all the pictures of his girlfriend were good enough to make me think he has some growing up along with other issues. Really bothers me how he says he is "disappointed" with the NFL after the veridct when those pictures and everything else came out. seems a lot of these guys could use some help understanding how this looks for the public eye.
But my question is when you have multiple players like this on your team, how much can you overlook. For me, i don't know my own answer, but i did realize with the Vick stuff that i wouldn't be able to simply overlook it and that it did wear on me. i do think there isn't a clear answer for everybody, but i also think every fan should think about it for themselves. If people can overlook all of these issues and having multiple players on the team who seem like crappy citizens, then so be it. But i also think people should take an honest look at themselves and this and really think about what they stand for and if it fine with them to cheer and encourage people who suck at being a citizen.