Disagree with both of those points.
Not about realism, per se, but consistency to a world the creators developed. Inconsistency and sloppiness takes away from that. Let alone the goofy cartoon villains they use to drive drama instead of focusing on bigger picture ideas of how society and individuals move forward.
And everybody having it.. doesn't really change anything, or seen illogical... If it's a consistent part of this world. When you die, you turn. So people have to take steps for that eventuality.
I mean if the goal is altruistic then surviving this thing is killing all the walkers and repopulating. The fact that the virus is sticky then it takes motivation to be a white hat beyond what is logical as the species is already extinct. This plot element was really only used in the early seasons, and they got married to it when the team went to the CDC so there's that. It wasn't a huge matter in the late seasons.
Wut?
Why play good guy if everyone is going to be a zombie when they die? The world is at that point over.
This makes less than zero sense.
It seems like the fact that people turn when they die is nothing more than a mild inconvenience. It would appear that almost the entirety of that threat would be curbed with an incredibly small amount of provisions.
I mean let's think this thru. If your goal was to white hat this thing, the main objective would be breeding as many women as possible. You probably need 3 live births to survive the dead fetus eating the woman from the inside as part of a mis-carriage, plus death in childbirth. This, also to account for just lower lifespan from poor hygiene, nutrition, etc. Would women go for this knowing at any time they could be eaten alive from the inside? They only briefly touched on this risk in the early seasons, then let it go.
You also have inbreeding problems that will develop so you need a diverse and well selected gene pool, and a system in place to feed, raise, and keep healthy your breeding stock as the demographic shifts much younger.
Existing as a nomadic lifestyle worked fine for the BC to 1500s in the US for everyone, but not now. Fixing to a single location marries you to weather patterns, and crop failure. Livestock seems gone.
Going black hat seems the only reasonable way forward.
I kind of get the premise of how despair-filled it would be based on the idea everyone turns. Even if you eradicate all existing walkers and rebuild society there will always be the threat of a new Walker outbreak with every death. You’d have to develop a very draconian system for dealing with death, disease, injury, etc. and you’d always still have risk associated with accidental deaths, murders or things like stroke or heart attack. Given that framework, seems a large percentage of society would just say f’ it.
Walker outbreaks would be almost impossible to happen now that people are already living it and would actually be prepared
Can’t say I agree with “almost impossible,” even the show itself addressed this on multiple occasions. For one example, all it took was one person dropping dead in the night from swine flu to wipe out half the prison in season 4.
Bad writing and dumb characters aside, you’re talking about a society that would have to be eternally vigilant as well as continually armed to the teeth. After seeing how society handled the most recent real life pandemic, put me down on the side that wouldn’t expect humans to last very long or rebuild out of a zombie apocalypse.
Is it that hard to simply have people sleep with a lock on their door? I mean how vigilant do you really need to be? C'mon now.
It would be the equivalent of people taking their medication.
Now, if we are talking about real society, yeah we would be screwed, maybe forever, in terms of organized society, but it wouldn't end the human population. No way.
On a side note, I have always thought that if Covid was more deadly, say it killed 5% of people who got it, we would NOT have had the huge political divide on handling things. A lot more people would have died, but we also would have had almost everyone working together and not politicizing masks, quarantines, and shut downs.
Now if it was a zombie apocalypse? Theoretically we should be able to handle that with NO problem given the slow rate of death after a bite and also a lag between death and reanimation. I don't think any major outbreaks would even have happened at the start.
However, we also don't know how hysterical society would get in general. If everyone working at the water/electric/gas companies all gave up we would be screwed, but the problem itself would not in actuality be tough to contain.