Post your 2012 Rookie Draft (1 Viewer)

[griff321]

I know it's early but i'm excited to see some of these start popping up! Anyone starting yet?

http://football33.myfantasyleague.com/2012/options?L=44263&O=17&DISPLAY=DIVISION01Hyper and Active sides have started on this one

Looks like Ryan locked these up...I apologize Ryan if I shouldn't have posted the link

Sorry, was not because of you. A couple of our owners requested this. I will post when they are finished.

Thanks for posting the draft. Looks like a really fun league. Do you ever think about doing a 32 team one? Now that's a pot.

 

[cstu]

2.02 15. Tenacious D Jenkins, A.J. SFO WR ® Sat Apr 28 10:40:27 p.m. ET 2012 Earlier than I wanted to take him, but I was sold on Jenkins prior to the draft. Santonio Holmes-esque.

I'm not sure that's a compliment

There were a lot of gambles after him that I didn't like. Jenkins is only 21 and Manningham is signed to a 2 year deal. I also don't think Crabtree will be in SF very long. I'm not expecting much more than low WR2 numbers out of Jenkins but I feel he's a safe pick for that.

 

[chris_dub]

Any IDP rookie drafts start? My 12-team league drafts on Saturday & I am interested to see where guys are going in an IDP draft.

 

[kylechoffman]

Usually there is a link to the zealot drafts at some point as well as an ADP of zealot leagues.

 

[JaYz0618]

Ours is still in progress. But here is how its gone so far.

12 Team PPR Dynasty QBs 4 pts pass td

1. Trent Richardson

2. Michael Floyd (Irish fan, not that its a reach, just worth nothing )

3. Doug Martin

4. Robert Griffin 3

5. David Wilson

6. Justin Blackmon

7. Andrew Luck

8. Ronnie Hillman

9. Ryan Broyles

10. Kendall Wright

11. Lamar Miller

12. Stephen Hill

13. Alshon Jeffery

14. Brian Quick

15. Isiah Pead

16. Lamichael James

17. Coby Fleener

18. Reuben Randle

19. Mohammed Sanu

20. Marvin Jones

21. Aj Jenkins

22. Chris Polk

 

[Hoosier16]

21. Aj Jenkins 22. Chris Polk

Odd to see Polk get picked only one spot behind the 4th WR taken in the draft.

 

[identikit]

Ours is still in progress. But here is how its gone so far.

12 Team PPR Dynasty QBs 4 pts pass td

1. Trent Richardson

2. Michael Floyd (Irish fan, not that its a reach, just worth nothing )

3. Doug Martin

4. Robert Griffin 3

5. David Wilson

6. Justin Blackmon

7. Andrew Luck

8. Ronnie Hillman

9. Ryan Broyles

10. Kendall Wright

11. Lamar Miller

12. Stephen Hill

13. Alshon Jeffery

14. Brian Quick

15. Isiah Pead

16. Lamichael James

17. Coby Fleener

18. Reuben Randle

19. Mohammed Sanu

20. Marvin Jones

21. Aj Jenkins

22. Chris Polk

 

[ljbrown]

Here is our IDP rookie Vet draft My link

We start 1 QB,2rbs,3wrs,1te, 1flex(rb,wr,te) 1dt/de, 2lbs, 2dbs, and 1 ST

 

[Casting Couch]

Reddog - Draft (with some FBG staffers)

1.01 1. Tony Spera Richardson, Trent CLE RB ® Sun Apr 29 9:29:34 a.m. ET 2012 This one is for you Robbie

1.02 2. Robbie Brooks Blackmon, Justin JAC WR ® Sun Apr 29 9:39:12 a.m. ET 2012 It is okay Tony. HOpe you can trade Richardson for a ton. In 5 years you will wish you had Luck or Griffin.

1.03 3. Robbie Brooks Luck, Andrew IND QB ® Sun Apr 29 10:04:43 a.m. ET 2012 Probably too high but I look back at Manning, Moss and Edge. Peyton was maybe the best pick back than and Luck comparison is eerie. Why I need other things more, I still have 1.7 and 1.9 to add there.

1.04 4. "Real Sean" Thompson Floyd, Michael ARI WR ® WR poor

1.05 5. Tony Spera Griffin III, Robert WAS QB ® Sun Apr 29 10:19:40 a.m. ET 2012

So the guy at 2 had a shot at him and said he'd regret not taking griffin and then he got him anyway at 5? Ouch.

Even better that he took Blackmon at 1.02. Tony killed it.

The only thing crazier than all of that is Doug Martin NOT in the top 5.

 

[Heep]

My PPR Dynasty Rookie Draft (This league has Dev Players so Floyd, Richardson, Jeffrey, Blackmon,Broyles, Fuller, Wilson, Gray, Criner, Polk, Sanu, and Miller all rostered)

1.01 - A. Luck

1.02 - RG3

1.03 - D. Martin

1.04 - K. Wright

1.05 - S. Hill

1.06 - C. Fleener

1.07 - R. Randle (I really considered Pead here)

1.08 - R. Hillman

1.09 - I. Pead

Bold - My Picks. I had 5 out of the first 7.

Enjoy.

 

[cstu]

9. Ryan Broyles

OOF.

 

[Dawg Pound 69]

My PPR Dynasty Rookie Draft (This league has Dev Players so Floyd, Richardson, Jeffrey, Blackmon,Broyles, Fuller, Wilson, Gray, Criner, Polk, Sanu, and Miller all rostered)

1.01 - A. Luck

1.02 - RG3

1.03 - D. Martin

1.04 - K. Wright

1.05 - S. Hill

1.06 - C. Fleener

1.07 - R. Randle (I really considered Pead here)

1.08 - R. Hillman

1.09 - I. Pead

Bold - My Picks. I had 5 out of the first 7.

Enjoy.

How the heck are Fuller & Gray rostered, but not Luck ? Is this a local league where all 12 owners are alumni of Texas A&M ?

 

[Eminence]

1.01 RB Trent Richardson, Cle $32.00 for 3 yr min

1.02 WR Michael Floyd, Ari $31.00 for 3 yr min

1.03 WR Justin Blackmon, Jac $30.00 for 3 yr min

1.04 QB Robert Griffin III, Was $29.00 for 3 yr min

1.05 QB Andrew Luck, Ind $28.00 for 3 yr min

1.06 RB Isaiah Pead, Stl $27.00 for 3 yr min

1.07 RB Doug Martin, TB $25.00 for 3 yr min

1.08 RB David Wilson, NYG $22.00 for 3 yr min

1.09 WR Kendall Wright, Ten $21.00 for 3 yr min

1.10 WR Alshon Jeffery, Chi $20.00 for 3 yr min

1.11 TE Coby Fleener, Ind $19.00 for 3 yr min

1.12 WR Rueben Randle, NYG $18.00 for 3 yr min

(My pick in bold.)

 

[Heep]

How the heck are Fuller & Gray rostered, but not Luck ? Is this a local league where all 12 owners are alumni of Texas A&M ?

Have you seen developmental drafts before? A lot of players don't pan out and before this year in 12 team leagues where only 12 dev players get picked, QBs don't really get picked in them. Barkley is going in some this year but I think that is because of the QB love fest going on right now.

 

[ctrlaltdefeat]

Start 1qb, 2rb, 3wr, 1te and 1 flex (wr, rb or te)

Draft in progress

http://football32.myfantasyleague.com/2012/options?L=69606&O=17

 

[Chimp Magnet]

Start 1qb, 2rb, 3wr, 1te and 1 flex (wr, rb or te)Draft in progresshttp://football32.myfantasyleague.com/2012/options?L=69606&O=17

Luck at 1.09?Trade of 1.02 for 1.08 and 2.02?Odd league if you ask me.

 

[Donsmith753]

1.01 RB Trent Richardson, Cle $32.00 for 3 yr min

1.02 WR Michael Floyd, Ari $31.00 for 3 yr min

1.03 WR Justin Blackmon, Jac $30.00 for 3 yr min

1.04 QB Robert Griffin III, Was $29.00 for 3 yr min

1.05 QB Andrew Luck, Ind $28.00 for 3 yr min

1.06 RB Isaiah Pead, Stl $27.00 for 3 yr min

1.07 RB Doug Martin, TB $25.00 for 3 yr min

1.08 RB David Wilson, NYG $22.00 for 3 yr min

1.09 WR Kendall Wright, Ten $21.00 for 3 yr min

1.10 WR Alshon Jeffery, Chi $20.00 for 3 yr min

1.11 TE Coby Fleener, Ind $19.00 for 3 yr min

1.12 WR Rueben Randle, NYG $18.00 for 3 yr min

(My pick in bold.)

Pead over Martin?

 

[Dragon1952]

1QB, 2-3RB, 2-3WR, 1-2TE 1PPR, 5 pt passing TD

1.01 1. ShamokinU Richardson, Trent CLE RB ® Sun Apr 29 4:24:24 p.m. PT 2012

1.02 2. Galveston Wave Martin, Doug TBB RB ® Sun Apr 29 4:56:12 p.m. PT 2012

1.03 3. ShamokinU Luck, Andrew IND QB ® Sun Apr 29 4:57:48 p.m. PT 2012

1.04 4. ShamokinU Blackmon, Justin JAC WR ® Sun Apr 29 4:58:14 p.m. PT 2012

1.05 5. Team RAMROD Floyd, Michael ARI WR ® Sun Apr 29 5:02:22 p.m. PT 2012

1.06 6. Harbor Rats Griffin III, Robert WAS QB ® Sun Apr 29 5:25:34 p.m. PT 2012

1.07 7. Harbor Rats Wilson, David NYG RB ® Sun Apr 29 5:35:26 p.m. PT 2012

1.08 8. STONE Hill, Stephen NYJ WR ® Sun Apr 29 6:35:47 p.m. PT 2012

1.09 9. Galveston Wave Fleener, Coby IND TE ® Sun Apr 29 7:08:50 p.m. PT 2012

1.10 10. Harbor Rats Wright, Kendall TEN WR ® Sun Apr 29 7:22:01 p.m. PT 2012

1.11 11. ShamokinU Pead, Isaiah STL RB ® Sun Apr 29 7:22:58 p.m. PT 2012

1.12 12. Team RAMROD Jeffery, Alshon CHI WR ® Sun Apr 29 7:23:41 p.m. PT 2012

 

[Dragon1952]

1QB, 2-3RB, 3-4WR, 1-2TE, 1PPR, 4pt passing TD

1.01 1. Top Gun Richardson, Trent CLE RB ® Mon Apr 30 6:00:17 a.m. PT 2012

1.02 2. SlingBlades Martin, Doug TBB RB ® Mon Apr 30 6:11:03 a.m. PT 2012

1.03 3. Top Gun Luck, Andrew IND QB ® Mon Apr 30 6:46:20 a.m. PT 2012

1.04 4. Cool Hand Luke Wilson, David NYG RB ® Mon Apr 30 10:09:31 a.m. PT 2012

 

[metoo]

Start 1qb, 2rb, 3wr, 1te and 1 flex (wr, rb or te)Draft in progresshttp://football32.myfantasyleague.com/2012/options?L=69606&O=17

Luck at 1.09?Trade of 1.02 for 1.08 and 2.02?Odd league if you ask me.

All fbg.

 

[Dragon1952]

Start 1qb, 2rb, 3wr, 1te and 1 flex (wr, rb or te)Draft in progresshttp://football32.myfantasyleague.com/2012/options?L=69606&O=17

Luck at 1.09?Trade of 1.02 for 1.08 and 2.02?Odd league if you ask me.

All fbg.

How on earth do you take Mohammed Sanu at 1.8 (and ahead of Luck)?

 

[metoo]

Start 1qb, 2rb, 3wr, 1te and 1 flex (wr, rb or te)Draft in progresshttp://football32.myfantasyleague.com/2012/options?L=69606&O=17

Luck at 1.09?Trade of 1.02 for 1.08 and 2.02?Odd league if you ask me.

All fbg.

How on earth do you take Mohammed Sanu at 1.8 (and ahead of Luck)?

Same guy traded the 1.2 for 1.8 and 2.2. I wish I knew that's all he wanted.

 

[ctrlaltdefeat]

Start 1qb, 2rb, 3wr, 1te and 1 flex (wr, rb or te)Draft in progresshttp://football32.myfantasyleague.com/2012/options?L=69606&O=17

Luck at 1.09?Trade of 1.02 for 1.08 and 2.02?Odd league if you ask me.

4 pts for passing tds and start 1 qb - it's not out of the question that qb's drop like that. I've seen many drafts so far where Luck or RG3 dropped to 7 and 8.

 

[cstu]

Start 1qb, 2rb, 3wr, 1te and 1 flex (wr, rb or te)Draft in progresshttp://football32.myfantasyleague.com/2012/options?L=69606&O=17

Luck at 1.09?Trade of 1.02 for 1.08 and 2.02?Odd league if you ask me.

All fbg.

How on earth do you take Mohammed Sanu at 1.8 (and ahead of Luck)?

Same guy traded the 1.2 for 1.8 and 2.2. I wish I knew that's all he wanted.

I'd say that guy isn't too good at this.

 

[cstu]

1.01 RB Trent Richardson, Cle $32.00 for 3 yr min

1.02 WR Michael Floyd, Ari $31.00 for 3 yr min

1.03 WR Justin Blackmon, Jac $30.00 for 3 yr min

1.04 QB Robert Griffin III, Was $29.00 for 3 yr min

1.05 QB Andrew Luck, Ind $28.00 for 3 yr min

1.06 RB Isaiah Pead, Stl $27.00 for 3 yr min

1.07 RB Doug Martin, TB $25.00 for 3 yr min

1.08 RB David Wilson, NYG $22.00 for 3 yr min

1.09 WR Kendall Wright, Ten $21.00 for 3 yr min

1.10 WR Alshon Jeffery, Chi $20.00 for 3 yr min

1.11 TE Coby Fleener, Ind $19.00 for 3 yr min

1.12 WR Rueben Randle, NYG $18.00 for 3 yr min

(My pick in bold.)

Pead over Martin?

I love Pead and it might work out but that's a trade down spot if he liked Pead that much.

 

[Heep]

My PPR Dynasty Rookie Draft (This league has Dev Players so Floyd, Richardson, Jeffrey, Blackmon,Broyles, Fuller, Wilson, Gray, Criner, Polk, Sanu, and Miller all rostered)

1.01 - A. Luck

1.02 - RG3

1.03 - D. Martin

1.04 - K. Wright

1.05 - S. Hill

1.06 - C. Fleener

1.07 - R. Randle (I really considered Pead here)

1.08 - R. Hillman

1.09 - I. Pead

Bold - My Picks. I had 5 out of the first 7.

Enjoy.

1.10 - B. Quick(I just traded up to this pick for a late developmental pick next year...)1.11 - A. Jenkins

1.12 - M. Jones

 

[Buck Stop]

12 team PPR dynasty, starting 1qb, 2rb, 3wr, 1te, 1 flex at rb/wr/te (my pick in bold)

1.1 Richardson

1.2 Martin

1.3 Blackmon

1.4 Luck

1.5 RG3

1.6 Wilson

1.7 Floyd

1.8 Hill

1.9 Jeffrey

 

[cstu]

12 team PPR dynasty, starting 1qb, 2rb, 3wr, 1te, 1 flex at rb/wr/te (my pick in bold)

1.1 Richardson

1.2 Martin

1.3 Blackmon

1.4 Luck

1.5 RG3

1.6 Wilson

1.7 Floyd

Good job passing on Floyd.

 

[Buck Stop]

12 team PPR dynasty, starting 1qb, 2rb, 3wr, 1te, 1 flex at rb/wr/te (my pick in bold)

1.1 Richardson

1.2 Martin

1.3 Blackmon

1.4 Luck

1.5 RG3

1.6 Wilson

1.7 Floyd

Good job passing on Floyd.

Easy decision for my team, I needed a RB and felt he was B.P.A.

 

[Buck Stop]

12 team PPR dynasty, starting 1qb, 2rb, 3wr, 1te, 1 flex at rb/wr/te (my picks in bold) (UPDATED)

1.1 Richardson

1.2 Martin

1.3 Blackmon

1.4 Luck

1.5 RG3

1.6 Wilson

1.7 Floyd

1.8 Hill

1.9 Jeffrey

1.10 Pead

1.11 Wright

1.12 Fleener

2.1 Hillman

2.2 Miller

2.3 Quick

2.4 James

2.5 Sanu

2.6 Broyles

2.7 Randle

2.8 Toon

2.9 Hilton

2.10 Jenkins

2.11 Givens

2.12 Allen

3.1 Posey

3.2 Pierce

 

[scothawk]

My PPR Dynasty Rookie Draft (This league has Dev Players so Floyd, Richardson, Jeffrey, Blackmon,Broyles, Fuller, Wilson, Gray, Criner, Polk, Sanu, and Miller all rostered)

1.01 - A. Luck

1.02 - RG3

1.03 - D. Martin

1.04 - K. Wright

1.05 - S. Hill

1.06 - C. Fleener

1.07 - R. Randle (I really considered Pead here)

1.08 - R. Hillman

1.09 - I. Pead

Bold - My Picks. I had 5 out of the first 7.

Enjoy.

1.10 - B. Quick(I just traded up to this pick for a late developmental pick next year...)1.11 - A. Jenkins

1.12 - M. Jones

Interesting draft. I would have taken Martin at 1.01 and then whichever of the 2 QBs fell to me, but it doesnt really matter does it?

 

[imagroid]

Start 1qb, 2rb, 3wr, 1te and 1 flex (wr, rb or te)Draft in progresshttp://football32.myfantasyleague.com/2012/options?L=69606&O=17

Luck at 1.09?Trade of 1.02 for 1.08 and 2.02?Odd league if you ask me.

All fbg.

mostly fbg, but not all and yeah odd is an understatement.

 

[identikit]

Start 1qb, 2rb, 3wr, 1te and 1 flex (wr, rb or te)

Draft in progress

http://football32.my...ns?L=69606&O=17

Luck at 1.09?Trade of 1.02 for 1.08 and 2.02?

Odd league if you ask me.

All fbg.

mostly fbg, but not all and yeah odd is an understatement.

'FBG' isn't some sort of stamp of approval necessarily.

 

[TheLurkerBelow]

12 team PPR dynasty, starting 1qb, 2rb, 3wr, 1te, 1 flex at rb/wr/te (my pick in bold)

1.1 Richardson

1.2 Martin

1.3 Blackmon

1.4 Luck

1.5 RG3

1.6 Wilson

1.7 Floyd

Good job passing on Floyd.

Many people have Wilson ahead of Floyd in their rankings, including this site's own Sigmund Bloom. (http://subscribers.footballguys.com/2012/12bloom100_postdraft.php). Floyd is the #2 WR on a team with a below average QB, and Wilson is an exciting prospect on a team who loves to run the ball, and he's only behind a player who has an injury history while sharing carries. It's not a stretch to think Wilson could be the feature back (60% or more of the carries) in NY by mid-season. That's just not going to happen with Floyd, his upside is limited, at least until the QB improves or Fitzgerald slows down. Please don't take this as a knock on Floyd, I'm just saying it's far from a clear cut distinction in rankings between the two of them.

 

[imagroid]

Start 1qb, 2rb, 3wr, 1te and 1 flex (wr, rb or te)

Draft in progress

http://football32.my...ns?L=69606&O=17

Luck at 1.09?Trade of 1.02 for 1.08 and 2.02?

Odd league if you ask me.

All fbg.

mostly fbg, but not all and yeah odd is an understatement.

'FBG' isn't some sort of stamp of approval necessarily.

Completely agree. It's odd because of league members not this deal...lol..but fun. Yeah I kinda notice that people have a "problem" when a guy goes a few spots ahead of where they think he should. Like Sanu @8, and Broyles @9 above. One thing I know for sure, is that come August these drafts won't look like they do now and it's certainly feasible that Martin won't be the best player out of Martin/Sanu/Fleener. He just didn't get enough value from that 1.2.

 

[Skeletore Eh]

Start 1qb, 2rb, 3wr, 1te and 1 flex (wr, rb or te)Draft in progresshttp://football32.myfantasyleague.com/2012/options?L=69606&O=17

Luck at 1.09?Trade of 1.02 for 1.08 and 2.02?Odd league if you ask me.

All fbg.

How on earth do you take Mohammed Sanu at 1.8 (and ahead of Luck)?

Same guy traded the 1.2 for 1.8 and 2.2. I wish I knew that's all he wanted.

I'd say that guy isn't too good at this.

I would say giving up the 1.2 for 1.8 and 2.2 wasn't very smart. Then luck falls to him at 8, which would have completely flipped the trade because he would have gotten luck and picked up the 2.2 basically for free. Then he passes on luck and the trade flips back to being a bad one. Very peculiar.

 

[Touchdown There]

12 team PPR dynasty, starting 1qb, 2rb, 3wr, 1te, 1 flex at rb/wr/te (my pick in bold)

1.1 Richardson

1.2 Martin

1.3 Blackmon

1.4 Luck

1.5 RG3

1.6 Wilson

1.7 Floyd

Good job passing on Floyd.

Many people have Wilson ahead of Floyd in their rankings, including this site's own Sigmund Bloom. (http://subscribers.footballguys.com/2012/12bloom100_postdraft.php). Floyd is the #2 WR on a team with a below average QB, and Wilson is an exciting prospect on a team who loves to run the ball, and he's only behind a player who has an injury history while sharing carries. It's not a stretch to think Wilson could be the feature back (60% or more of the carries) in NY by mid-season. That's just not going to happen with Floyd, his upside is limited, at least until the QB improves or Fitzgerald slows down. Please don't take this as a knock on Floyd, I'm just saying it's far from a clear cut distinction in rankings between the two of them.

cstu agrees with you and so do I. His thumbs up was not sarcastic.

 

[doowain]

We are through 2 rounds now.

http://football9.myfantasyleague.com/2012/options?L=22034&O=17

 

[Buck Stop]

We are through 2 rounds now.http://football9.myfantasyleague.com/2012/options?L=22034&O=17

you are owning that draft. these guys don't have a clue you're drafting with do they?

 

[humans_being]

Start 1qb, 2rb, 3wr, 1te and 1 flex (wr, rb or te)Draft in progresshttp://football32.myfantasyleague.com/2012/options?L=69606&O=17

No Bernard Pierce after 3 full rounds??

 

[cstu]

Start 1qb, 2rb, 3wr, 1te and 1 flex (wr, rb or te)Draft in progresshttp://football32.myfantasyleague.com/2012/options?L=69606&O=17

Luck at 1.09?Trade of 1.02 for 1.08 and 2.02?Odd league if you ask me.

All fbg.

How on earth do you take Mohammed Sanu at 1.8 (and ahead of Luck)?

Same guy traded the 1.2 for 1.8 and 2.2. I wish I knew that's all he wanted.

I'd say that guy isn't too good at this.

I would say giving up the 1.2 for 1.8 and 2.2 wasn't very smart. Then luck falls to him at 8, which would have completely flipped the trade because he would have gotten luck and picked up the 2.2 basically for free. Then he passes on luck and the trade flips back to being a bad one. Very peculiar.

The crazy thing is that he could have had Luck and Fleener (or if he was taken, Randle) for the 1.02, which would have been a good deal. I really like the Fleener pick but he screwed up with the Sanu pick.

 

[cstu]

People are making a mistake letting AJ Jenkins slip into the 3rd round and taking lesser receivers like Toon, Marvin Jones and Graham.

 

[TheLurkerBelow]

12 team PPR dynasty, starting 1qb, 2rb, 3wr, 1te, 1 flex at rb/wr/te (my pick in bold)

1.1 Richardson

1.2 Martin

1.3 Blackmon

1.4 Luck

1.5 RG3

1.6 Wilson

1.7 Floyd

Good job passing on Floyd.

Many people have Wilson ahead of Floyd in their rankings, including this site's own Sigmund Bloom. (http://subscribers.footballguys.com/2012/12bloom100_postdraft.php). Floyd is the #2 WR on a team with a below average QB, and Wilson is an exciting prospect on a team who loves to run the ball, and he's only behind a player who has an injury history while sharing carries. It's not a stretch to think Wilson could be the feature back (60% or more of the carries) in NY by mid-season. That's just not going to happen with Floyd, his upside is limited, at least until the QB improves or Fitzgerald slows down. Please don't take this as a knock on Floyd, I'm just saying it's far from a clear cut distinction in rankings between the two of them.

cstu agrees with you and so do I. His thumbs up was not sarcastic.

Ahh, then we're all on the same page. For some reason I took that as a sarcastic comment, I can be too much the cynic sometimes I guess.

 

[Warpig]

We have a draft starting tonight. 12 team ppr with IDP. Will try to post as often as I can. I have a feeling it will be a creeper though.

 

[cstu]

12 team PPR dynasty, starting 1qb, 2rb, 3wr, 1te, 1 flex at rb/wr/te (my pick in bold)

1.1 Richardson

1.2 Martin

1.3 Blackmon

1.4 Luck

1.5 RG3

1.6 Wilson

1.7 Floyd

Good job passing on Floyd.

Many people have Wilson ahead of Floyd in their rankings, including this site's own Sigmund Bloom. (http://subscribers.footballguys.com/2012/12bloom100_postdraft.php). Floyd is the #2 WR on a team with a below average QB, and Wilson is an exciting prospect on a team who loves to run the ball, and he's only behind a player who has an injury history while sharing carries. It's not a stretch to think Wilson could be the feature back (60% or more of the carries) in NY by mid-season. That's just not going to happen with Floyd, his upside is limited, at least until the QB improves or Fitzgerald slows down. Please don't take this as a knock on Floyd, I'm just saying it's far from a clear cut distinction in rankings between the two of them.

cstu agrees with you and so do I. His thumbs up was not sarcastic.

Ahh, then we're all on the same page. For some reason I took that as a sarcastic comment, I can be too much the cynic sometimes I guess.

Understandable since most people are high on him, but I'm not.

 

[imagroid]

Start 1qb, 2rb, 3wr, 1te and 1 flex (wr, rb or te)Draft in progresshttp://football32.myfantasyleague.com/2012/options?L=69606&O=17

Luck at 1.09?Trade of 1.02 for 1.08 and 2.02?Odd league if you ask me.

All fbg.

How on earth do you take Mohammed Sanu at 1.8 (and ahead of Luck)?

Same guy traded the 1.2 for 1.8 and 2.2. I wish I knew that's all he wanted.

I'd say that guy isn't too good at this.

I would say giving up the 1.2 for 1.8 and 2.2 wasn't very smart. Then luck falls to him at 8, which would have completely flipped the trade because he would have gotten luck and picked up the 2.2 basically for free. Then he passes on luck and the trade flips back to being a bad one. Very peculiar.

The crazy thing is that he could have had Luck and Fleener (or if he was taken, Randle) for the 1.02, which would have been a good deal. I really like the Fleener pick but he screwed up with the Sanu pick.

I would agree that Luck is the better pick there in a vacuum, but I can see passing on him too, especially if you are set at QB.

 

[griff321]

I would agree that Luck is the better pick there in a vacuum, but I can see passing on him too, especially if you are set at QB.

I have Rodgers in a 16 team league where top QBs can be very valuable, and I'm not sure I'd be able to pass on Luck just from a pure value standpoint. The topic deserves a spinoff thread IMO.

 

[FreeBaGeL]

I would agree that Luck is the better pick there in a vacuum, but I can see passing on him too, especially if you are set at QB.

I have Rodgers in a 16 team league where top QBs can be very valuable, and I'm not sure I'd be able to pass on Luck just from a pure value standpoint. The topic deserves a spinoff thread IMO.

There is one: http://forums.footballguys.com/forum/index.php?showtopic=639931

 

[menobrown]

Start 1qb, 2rb, 3wr, 1te and 1 flex (wr, rb or te)

Draft in progress

http://football32.my...ns?L=69606&O=17

Luck at 1.09?Trade of 1.02 for 1.08 and 2.02?

Odd league if you ask me.

All fbg.

mostly fbg, but not all and yeah odd is an understatement.

'FBG' isn't some sort of stamp of approval necessarily.

That draft is actually going fairly similar to a league I'm a silent partner in and most if not all the participants are high stakes fantasy players. In my draft Luck went 1.9 as well. I'd say the only people who went above him that might be considered surprising was Jeffrey and Wright. Most teams just don't have a big need at QB so I don't see him falling as shocking.

 

[cstu]

That draft is actually going fairly similar to a league I'm a silent partner in and most if not all the participants are high stakes fantasy players. In my draft Luck went 1.9 as well. I'd say the only people who went above him that might be considered surprising was Jeffrey and Wright. Most teams just don't have a big need at QB so I don't see him falling as shocking.

I can see the justification for letting him drop even further but not for Sanu.