QB: B+ Cam will play and his running stats will help. Volek would be a wasted pick on a thin roster.
You would rather have Phillip Rivers and Cam Newton than Bradford and Schaub??
Rivers and Newton.Last year Rivers outscored the Schuab/Bradford 8 of 16 weeks - push.
Last year Rivers scored 423 (included Clausen's 11 pts in wk 10 for River's bye) v. S/B total of 404 - advantage Rivers.
Last year posted 20 or more points in 12 wks v. 12 for the S/B combo - push.
Last year adding Bradford to Schaub netted you 6 (wk 1) + 2 (3) + 3 (4) + 21 (7 Schaub bye) + 9 (8) + 5 (11) + 13 (12) + 2 (16). Tossing out the bye week, that's only 40 pts Bradford added over 15 weeks.
Bradford should improve but adding Newton to the equation should offset this.
Just for discussion, Bradford would have helped River's by 32 points (excluding bye) and Schaub would have helped Rivers by 54 pts.
Adding that second QB when your primary doesn't get hurt usually doesn't add many points. I did this excerise earlier for addig Flacco to Brees and as I recall Flacco improved the total by 15 points.
Anyway, that's why you got a B- (4-5 teams will outscore you) and he got a B+ (2-3 teams will outscore him). A B- is a high grade in my book.