the first round if drafted today (1 Viewer)

[The Moz]

1. AD - 1st

2. A. Foster - a 5th - 8th

3. CJIII - 1st

4. MJD - 1st

5. A. Bradshaw 4th - 5th

6. R. Mendenhall - 1st - 2nd

7. R. Wayne - 2nd

8. L. Tomlinson - 8th-12th

9. R. White - 2nd - 3rd

10 P. Manning - 2nd - 3rd

11. M. Austin - 2nd

12. DMC ( higher if no injury ) 7th - 10th

 

[two_dollars]

The first round if drafted today would not look like the draft 4 weeks ago, and it won't look like the draft 4 weeks from now.

 

[BroadwayG]

Gore slides easily into the 4 slot

 

[swirvenirvin]

ABC

CDE

wtf is DMC

 

[Lascelle]

wtf is DMC

Darren "Run DMC" McFadden

 

[bulger2holt]

A-Fro = A Foster

 

[az_prof]

1. AD - 1st2. A. Foster - a 5th - 8th3. CJIII - 1st4. MJD - 1st5. A. Bradshaw 4th - 5th6. R. Mendenhall - 1st - 2nd7. R. Wayne - 2nd8. L. Tomlinson - 8th-12th9. R. White - 2nd - 3rd10 P. Manning - 2nd - 3rd11. M. Austin - 2nd12. DMC ( higher if no injury ) 7th - 10th

No way would I include TOmlinson (currently 10th RB in my ppr), McFadden (5th RB but that was without Bush, who now has a chance to start), or Austin (currently WR16 in my PPR). Austin has been a disappointment to date. McFadden is the classic "flash in the pan." And Tomlinson has been good, but not THAT good, and do you expect him to keep it up all season? I don't.I would add: Best and McCoy. I expect the two of them to keep up their production too. I would also include Rice--I fully expect he will be top 10 when all is said and done.

 

[HenryMuto]

1. AD - 1st2. A. Foster - a 5th - 8th3. CJIII - 1st4. MJD - 1st5. A. Bradshaw 4th - 5th6. R. Mendenhall - 1st - 2nd7. R. Wayne - 2nd8. L. Tomlinson - 8th-12th9. R. White - 2nd - 3rd10 P. Manning - 2nd - 3rd11. M. Austin - 2nd12. DMC ( higher if no injury ) 7th - 10th

People don't draft staight off current points scored. They draft on projected points the rest of the way.I did a draft last week.Bradshaw was not the 5th pick, LT 8th overall ? Ya that didn't happen.Here is what the 1st round looked like as of last weekPPR league1 C-Johnson2 Peterson3 Gore4 M-Drew5 M-Turner6 Foster7 R-Rice8 Austin9 R-White10 A-Johnson11 R-Moss12 MendenhallThat was your 1st round as of 1 week ago.For your players listed aboveBradshaw went at end of the 3rd (pick 36)McFadden in 4th (pick 38)LT went in the 4th (pick 40)P-Manning went in the 2nd (pick 17)

 

[basher]

1. AD - 1st2. A. Foster - a 5th - 8th3. CJIII - 1st4. MJD - 1st5. A. Bradshaw 4th - 5th6. R. Mendenhall - 1st - 2nd7. R. Wayne - 2nd8. L. Tomlinson - 8th-12th9. R. White - 2nd - 3rd10 P. Manning - 2nd - 3rd11. M. Austin - 2nd12. DMC ( higher if no injury ) 7th - 10th

No way would I include TOmlinson (currently 10th RB in my ppr), McFadden (5th RB but that was without Bush, who now has a chance to start), or Austin (currently WR16 in my PPR). Austin has been a disappointment to date. McFadden is the classic "flash in the pan." And Tomlinson has been good, but not THAT good, and do you expect him to keep it up all season? I don't.I would add: Best and McCoy. I expect the two of them to keep up their production too. I would also include Rice--I fully expect he will be top 10 when all is said and done.

Austin is a disappointment? He has 2 10 catch 140+ yard 1 td games this year and one bad game. He had his bye week so he has only played three games. Not sure how that is ANYTHING close to a disappointment. Also, adding best or mccoy over Gore? puuhhhhhhllllleeeeeaaasssssssseeee

 

[Judge Smails]

1. AD - 1st2. A. Foster - a 5th - 8th3. CJIII - 1st4. MJD - 1st5. A. Bradshaw 4th - 5th6. R. Mendenhall - 1st - 2nd7. R. Wayne - 2nd8. L. Tomlinson - 8th-12th9. R. White - 2nd - 3rd10 P. Manning - 2nd - 3rd11. M. Austin - 2nd12. DMC ( higher if no injury ) 7th - 10th

Well then, I drafted well. 12 team redraft, 11th slot. Went Austin/Manning/Foster/Gates/Tomlinson. Traded Gates for MJD (would have had 5 on your list) but it got shot down by my main league.

 

[DukeBroadway]

1. AD - 1st

2. A. Foster - a 5th - 8th

3. CJIII - 1st

4. MJD - 1st

5. A. Bradshaw 4th - 5th

6. R. Mendenhall - 1st - 2nd

7. R. Wayne - 2nd

8. L. Tomlinson - 8th-12th

9. R. White - 2nd - 3rd

10 P. Manning - 2nd - 3rd

11. M. Austin - 2nd

12. DMC ( higher if no injury ) 7th - 10th

I like your top 12, like that I have 4 of them rostered. I dont think McFadden makes the list. McCluster is the real DMC.

 

[bostonfred]

Gotta think Gates is up there, at least in some formats.

 

[ScottyDog]

Hillis? He has more points in my league than all those guys except for AP and Foster and Manning.

1. AD - 1st2. A. Foster - a 5th - 8th3. CJIII - 1st4. MJD - 1st5. A. Bradshaw 4th - 5th6. R. Mendenhall - 1st - 2nd7. R. Wayne - 2nd8. L. Tomlinson - 8th-12th9. R. White - 2nd - 3rd10 P. Manning - 2nd - 3rd11. M. Austin - 2nd12. DMC ( higher if no injury ) 7th - 10th

 

[Man In The Box]

Now, imagine Hillis is black.

 

[Kilgore]

Now, imagine Hillis is black.

Too funny.

 

[purestrength]

No Austin Collie?

 

[Badgers Fan]

If I was drafting today:

1. AP

2. CJ

3. Foster

4. Gore

5. SJax (is going to explode as long as Bradford keeps playing how he is)

6. MJD

7. Ray Rice

8. Andre (still no wr id rather have)

9. Miles Austin

10. Peyton Manning

11. Rashard Mendenhall

12. Roddy White/ Reggie Wayne/Michael Turner

-I doubt the health for a full season of Bradshaw, DMC, Best

- I do not like Lesean Mccoy's remaining schedule.

-I dont fully buy into LT or Hillis yet

-Jamaal Charles is going to be a top 15 player, and if i was drafting today he'd prob go in the 4th round and be a steal. The chiefs had the bye to review game tape, maybe they'll realize that the guy that got 1000 yards in 8 games last year is pretty good and doubling jones output.

 

[moderated]

Hillis? He has more points in my league than all those guys except for AP and Foster and Manning.

please tell me you're kidding. hillis has been good but as of now there is no way he is worth a top 12 pick in fantasy leagues, any format.

 

[atcdav]

our original 1st. non ppr 2rb/2wr/1flex

AP

CJ

MJD

Rice

Gore

Turner

AJ

SJax

DWill

RMoss

CalJohn

ARogers

Foster and Best both went 3.04 and 3.05

If Draft was todaty

AP

Foster

Gore

CJ

SJax

MJD

Mendy

Manning

AJ

White

Rogers

Moss

 

[shortbow]

Now, imagine Hillis is black.

Tolbert?

Gore slides easily into the 4 slot

I realise foster has done amazingly above expectations but why wouldnt gore be in the 3?APCJGoreFosterBestWayneMendeWhiteMJDRiceP. manningGates

 

[TitanicHornet]

No Gore? Dude continues to be underrated even 4 weeks into a season.

 

[FUBAR]

I like Peyton Manning but why would he be a 1st round pick today in any league where he was a 2nd or 3rd before the season? He's done well but no better than was expected IMO.

 

[Man In The Box]

Now, imagine Hillis is black.

Tolbert?

Yes! Because their situations are nearly identical!Tolbert will be getting about 6 touches a game 3 weeks from now. Try again.

 

[T.Rex]

1. AD - 1st2. A. Foster - a 5th - 8th3. CJIII - 1st4. MJD - 1st5. A. Bradshaw 4th - 5th6. R. Mendenhall - 1st - 2nd7. R. Wayne - 2nd8. L. Tomlinson - 8th-12th9. R. White - 2nd - 3rd10 P. Manning - 2nd - 3rd11. M. Austin - 2nd12. DMC ( higher if no injury ) 7th - 10th

No Gore no Best.. this list is.... not so much.

 

[ScottyDog]

Why not? The goal is to score the most points every week ya?

Hillis? He has more points in my league than all those guys except for AP and Foster and Manning.

please tell me you're kidding. hillis has been good but as of now there is no way he is worth a top 12 pick in fantasy leagues, any format.

 

[emge]

Gates should be here... he's outscoring all TE and WR

 

[Crippler]

The middle of next week will give you the data you want with the 2nd part of the FBG Survivor leagues drafting again. I think 4 drafts somewhere middle of next week.

 

[shortbow]

Now, imagine Hillis is black.

Tolbert?

Yes! Because their situations are nearly identical!Tolbert will be getting about 6 touches a game 3 weeks from now. Try again.

I think I was as close as possible, they are both big bruiser type backs, im sure tolbert spent some time as a FB at some point and in Mathews absence he has performed above everyones expectations. How is this not an accurate comparison?Id wager Hillis wont be the back in Cleveland all year, dont underestimate Mangini and his futility.

 

[Runningman]

Gore slides easily into the 4 slot

And where is collie?

 

[candymanvandyfan]

Austin has been a disappointment to date.

You haven't seen the ball since kickoff, have you? That's what I thought.

 

[Man In The Box]

Now, imagine Hillis is black.

Tolbert?

Yes! Because their situations are nearly identical!Tolbert will be getting about 6 touches a game 3 weeks from now. Try again.

I think I was as close as possible, they are both big bruiser type backs, im sure tolbert spent some time as a FB at some point and in Mathews absence he has performed above everyones expectations. How is this not an accurate comparison?Id wager Hillis wont be the back in Cleveland all year, dont underestimate Mangini and his futility.

Barring injury, Hillis will be the man all season in Cleveland. I don't think Mangini could even screw that up. The big difference in the two situations is that Hillis doesn't have a first round pick, who the organization traded way up to get, ready to take most of the team's carries. You can't possibly say that if you had Hillis, you'd trade him straight up for Tolbert.

 

[Truman]

If Hardesty were healthy Hillis and Tolbert would have an identical situation.

I have heard rumours Hardesty is injured however.

 

[de Tocqueville]

The first round if drafted today would not look like the draft 4 weeks ago, and it won't look like the draft 4 weeks from now.

two thumbs up.

 

[cr8f]

1. AD - 1st

2. A. Foster - a 5th - 8th

3. CJIII - 1st

4. MJD - 1st

5. A. Bradshaw 4th - 5th

6. R. Mendenhall - 1st - 2nd

7. R. Wayne - 2nd

8. L. Tomlinson - 8th-12th

9. R. White - 2nd - 3rd

10 P. Manning - 2nd - 3rd

11. M. Austin - 2nd

12. DMC ( higher if no injury ) 7th - 10th

Injury is almost his middle name.

 

[Da Guru]

The first round if drafted today would not look like the draft 4 weeks ago, and it won't look like the draft 4 weeks from now.

That is why pre-season and even weekly rankings do not mean squat once the game kicks off.

 

[Darth Cheney]

The first round would have about 10 of the same 12 players as the first round in August.