Weekly Top 200 Dynasty PPR Rankings (1 Viewer)

[laughinboy_2000]

So this will be my first installment of the weekly Top 200 Dynasty Rankings. Lots of people wanted some type of Dynasty Rankings, so Ive spent some time looking over players and have come up with my list. I may change how I deliver the material weekly, but the list itself will always be included. The main purpose of this thread is to get some discussion and possibly help people out with questions about their Dynasty rosters. I will try and have these updated and sent out each Wednesday or Thursday. Being this is a long list, PLEASE PLEASE PLEASE delete players that you dont have questions about from the response so it does not create a LONG response…

In this weeks installment, I have some comments listed beside some of the players regarding their situation, how they are playing, and future outlooks. Enjoy and Discuss!

1. Ray Rice, RB Ravens – Better O-Line and QB only reason he’s above ADP

2. Adrian Peterson, Vikings - Vikes need to surround AP with some more talent

3. LeSean McCoy, RB Eagles

4. Calvin Johnson, WR Lions -

5. Aaron Rogers, QB Packers – Absolutely surgical…

6. Darren McFadden, RB Raiders – Starting to show off some MAD skills

7. Arian Foster, RB Texans: Looks to be finally healthy, which can only mean good things for his owners

8. Chris Johnson, RB Titans – Notoriously slow starter, but he’s starting to warm up

9. Tom Brady, QB Patriots

10. Andre Johnson, WR Texans

11. Maurice Jones- Drew, RB Jaguars

12. Larry Fitzgerald, WR Cardinals

13. Drew Brees, QB Saints

14. Hakeem Nicks, WR Giants – Absolute STUD when healthy. Huge believer in Nicks!

15. Phillip Rivers, QB Chargers

16. Mike Vick, QB Eagles

17. Mike Wallace, WR Steelers – Speed Kills

18. Dez Bryant, WR Cowboys – Talent is undeniable, but needs to stay healthy

19. Ryan Matthews, RB Chargers – Looks completely different than he did last year.

20. Matt Forte, RB Bears - Last year of contract but major O-Line concerns

21. Rashard Mendenhall, RB Steelers

22. Greg Jennings, WR Packers

23. Miles Austin, WR Dallas

24. DeSean Jackson, WR Eagles

25. Matthew Stafford, QB Lions: Starting to live up to his hype!

26. Vincent Jackson, WR Chargers

27. Jeremy Maclin, WR Eagles

28. Roddy White, WR Falcons

29. Cam Newton, QB Panthers – I’ve NEVER seen a rookie QB have this much of an impact

30. Julio Jones, WR Falcons – Star in the making

31. Jamaal Charles, RB Chiefs

32. AJ Green, WR Bengals

33. Rob Gronkowski, TE Patriots

34. Mark Ingram, RB Saints – A bit worried on how the Saints plan on using him?

35. Jermichael Finley, TE Packers

36. Wes Welker, WR Patriots

37. Jonathan Stewart, RB Panthers

38. Kenny Britt, WR Titans

39. Jahvid Best, RB Lions – Worried about his YPC, but does most of his damage through the air.

40. Santonio Holmes, WR Jets

41. Ben Roethlisberger, QB Steelers

42. Tony Romo, QB Cowboys

43. Matt Ryan, QB Falcons

44. Percy Harvin, WR Vikings

45. Peyton Manning, QB Colts

46. Aaron Hernandez, TE Patriots

47. Jimmy Graham, TE Saints – I see a top 5 TE for years to come

48. Felix Jones, RB Cowboys

49. Chris “Beanie” Wells, RB Cardinals – Best year of his pro career

50. Stevie Johnson, WR Bills

51. Vernon Davis, TE 49ers – If only he had a decent QB. Is that too much to ask for?

52. Mike Williams, WR Bucs

53. Josh Freeman, QB Bucs

54. Dwayne Bowe, WR Chiefs

55. Sam Bradford, QB Rams

56. Ahmad Bradshaw, RB Giants

57. Jason Witten, TE Dallas

58. Brandon Marshall, WR Dolphins – Worried about his QB situation and drops. Not good

59. Jordy Nelson, WR Packers

60. Brandon Lloyd, WR Broncos

61. Joe Flacco, QB Ravens

62. LeGarrette Blount, RB Bucs

63. Daniel Thomas, RB Dolphins

64. Steve Smith, WR Panthers – It should be fun watching Smittee and Cam for the next few years

65. DeAngelo Williams, RB Panthers

66. Frank Gore, RB 49ers

67. James Starks, RB Packers

68. Peyton Hillis, RB Browns

69. Antonio Gates, TE Chargers: Injured foot has me VERY worried at this point

70. Fred Jackson, RB Bills

71. Michael Turner, RB Falcons

72. Denarius Moore, WR Raiders

73. Steven Jackson, RB Rams

74. Daniel Thomas, RB Dolphins

75. Mario Manningham, WR Giants

76. Anquan Boldin, WR Ravens

77. Matt Shaub, QB Texans

78. Stefan Ridley, RB Patriots: Too explosive to leave off the field, and just a rookie.

79. Reggie Wayne, WR Colts

80. Sidney Rice, WR Seahawks

81. Randall Cobb, WR Packers

82. Jacoby Ford, WR Raiders

83. Kendall Hunter, RB 49ers This kid will be the new man in S.F. before you know it.

84. Eli Manning, QB Giants

85. Marques Colston, WR Saints

86. CJ Spiller, RB Bills

87. Michael Crabtree, WR 49ers

88. Greg Little, WR Browns

89. Shonne Greene, RB Jets – Not making the most of his opportunity

90. Tim Hightower, RB Redskins

91. Ben Tate, RB Texans

92. Dustin Keller, TE Jets

93. Greg Olsen, TE Panthers – Olson career gets a shot in the arm with Cam

94. Kevin Kolb, QB Cardinals

95. Santana Moss, WR Redskins

96. Austin Collie, WR Colts – Man does he miss Peyton

97. Jay Cutler, QB Bears

98. Cedric Benson, RB Bengals

99. Owen Daniels, TE Texans – One of the most underrated TEs if you ask me.

100 Johnny Knox, WR Bears

101 Eric Decker, WR Broncos

102 Dallas Clark, TE Colts

103 Knowshon Moreno, RB Broncos: I’m convinced he just does not have the “it” to be an NFL RB

104 Fred Davis, TE Redskins

105 Mike Thomas, WR Jaguars

106 Roy Helu, RB Redskins

107 Mark Sanchez, QB Jets

108 Mike Tolbert, RB Chargers

109 Delone Carter, RB Colts – Should not be too long before the Colts unleash this guy.

110 Reggie Bush, RB Dolphins

111 Mercedes Lewis, TE Jaguars

112 Lance Moore, WR Saints

113 Robert Meachem, WR Saints

114 Jake Locker, QB Titans – Future is bright for this kid with CJ2k, Britt, and Cook

115 Blaine Gabbart, QB Jaguars

116 Brandon Pettigrew, TE Lions

117 Ryan Williams, RB Cardinals

118 Torrey Smith, WR Ravens

119 Shane Vereen, RB Patriots

120 Mikel Leshoure, RB Lions

121 Pierre Garcon, WR Colts

122 Steve Smith, WR Eagles

123 Braylon Edwards, WR 49ers

124 Ryan Fitzpatrick, QB Bills – Bills need to hurry up and resign this kid for the next few years

125 Zach Miller, TE Seahawks

126 Lance Kendricks, TE Rams

127 Julies Thomas, TE Broncos

128 Christian Ponder, QB Vikings – Will be starting by mid-season if you ask me

129 Mike Sims-Walker, WR Rams

130 Kellen Winslow, TE Browns

131 Colin Kaepernick, QB 49ers

132 Jared Cook, TE Titans – Tremendous size for a TE. Has the making for a top 10 TE

133 Titus Young, WR Lions

134 David Nelson, WR Bills – PPR stud

135 Colt McCoy, QB Browns – Has potential to be special. Browns need to get some talent around him

136 Ryan Grant, RB Packers

137 Darren Sproles, RB Saints

138 BenJarvis Green-Ellis, RB Patriots

139 Willis McGahee, RB Broncos

140 Brandon Jacobs, RB Giants

141 Jerome Simpson, WR Bengals

142 Michael Bush, RB Raiders

143 Emmanuel Sanders, WR Steelers

144 Danario Alexander, WR Rams – If only his knees would let this guy play!

145 Deion Branch, WR Patriots

146 Dexter McCluster, RB Chiefs

147 Vincent Brown, WR Chargers

148 Antonio Brown, WR Steelers

149 Montario Hardesty, RB Browns

150 Marshawn Lynch, RB Seahawks

151 Bernard Scott, RB Bengals

152 Joe Addai, RB Colts

153 Kyle Orton, QB Broncos

154 Bilal Powell, RB Jets: He may be getting his opportunity before people think

155 Tim Tebow, QB Broncos – Not convinced he will be an NFL QB

156 Andy Dalton, QB Bengals

157 Ed Dickson, TE Ravens: Has looked good in the Ravens offense at times this year

158 Kyle Rudolph, TE Vikings

159 Nate Burleson, WR Lions

160 Arrelious Benn, WR Bucs

161 Pierre Thomas, RB Saints

162 Devon Bess, WR Dolphins

163 James Jones, WR Packers

164 Rex Grossman, QB Redskins

165 Toby Gerhart, RB Vikings

166 Alex Green, RB Packers – Would love to see what this kid could do on the field?

167 Jacquizz Rodgers, RB Falcons

168 Vince Young, QB Eagles

169 Nate Washington, WR Titans

170 Victor Cruz, WR Giants – Keep an eye on this kid. He could be shooting up the rankings soon

171 Michael Floyd, WR Chargers

172 Brandon LaFell, WR Panthers

173 Joe McKnight, RB Jets

174 Evan Moore, TE Browns

175 Mohamed Massaquoi, WR Browns

176 Deji Karim, RB Jaguars

177 Jonathan Baldwin, WR Chiefs

178 Golden Tate, WR Seahawks

179 Jason Campbell, QB Raiders

180 Matt Hasselbeck, QB Titans

181 Danny Woodhead, RB Patriots

182 Lee Evans, WR Ravens

183 Jacoby Jones, WR Texans

184 Chad Ochocinco, WR Patriots

185 Plaxico Burress, WR Jets

186 Rashad Jennings, RB Jaguars

187 Tony Gonzalez, TE Chiefs

188 Ryan Mallett, QB Patriots – Meet Tom Brady’s replacement, whenever that may be?

189 Jerome Harrison, RB Browns

190 Andre Roberts, WR Cardinals

191 Tashard Choice, RB Cowboys

192 Early Doucet, WR Cardinals

193 Dion Lewis, RB Eagles

194 Darrius Heyward-Bey, WR Raiders

195 Dane Sanzenbacher, WR Bears

196 Chad Henne, QB Dolphins

197 Ronnie Brown, RB Eagles

198 Javon Ringer, RB Titans

199 Ryan Torain, RB Redskins

200 Donald Jones, WR Bills

 

[jonboltz]

Just my opinion, but...Too high:

24. DeSean Jackson, WR Eagles33. Rob Gronkowski, TE Patriots37. Jonathan Stewart, RB Panthers45. Peyton Manning, QB Colts46. Aaron Hernandez, TE Patriots59. Jordy Nelson, WR Packers71. Denarius Moore, WR Raiders72. Kendall Hunter, RB 49ers – Will be the new man in S.F. before you know it.81. Randall Cobb, WR Packers86. CJ Spiller, RB Bills110 Delone Carter, RB Colts – Should not be too long before the Colts unleash this guy.127 Lance Kendricks, TE Rams128 Julies Thomas, TE Broncos

Too low:

28. Roddy White, WR Falcons29. Cam Newton, QB Panthers – I’ve NEVER seen a rookie QB have this much of an impact54. Dwayne Bowe, WR Chiefs56. Ahmad Bradshaw, RB Giants58. Brandon Marshall, WR Dolphins – Worried about his QB situation and drops. Not good66. Frank Gore, RB 49ers68. Peyton Hillis, RB Browns79. Reggie Wayne, WR Colts83. Fred Jackson, RB Bills123 Steve Smith, WR Eagles150 Marshawn Lynch, RB Seahawks

Silly low:

152 Joe Addai, RB Colts155 Tim Tebow, QB Broncos – Not convinced he will be an NFL QB179 Darren Sproles, RB Saints

 

[toots magroots]

FYI - Jimmy Graham is listed twice - at #47 and #102

By the way, thanks for doing this.

 

[laughinboy_2000]

FYI - Jimmy Graham is listed twice - at #47 and #102By the way, thanks for doing this.

Thanks GB, adjustments have been made...

 

[ZWK]

No Nate Washington?

 

[laughinboy_2000]

No Nate Washington?

Give it sometime Grasshopper! You may see him next week...

 

[Dawg Pound 69]

Is this PPR or non-PPR ?

 

[laughinboy_2000]

Is this PPR or non-PPR ?

PPR... I need to clarify that in the title of the thread... Thanks!

 

[ExaltedOne]

Lots of TEs on here, but no Jermaine Gresham?

 

[jeter23]

 

[laughinboy_2000]

Lots of TEs on here, but no Jermaine Gresham?

Agreed, I had to have overlooked him. I took off Kyle Rudolph, the TE from Minni. who has done next to nothing so far. UPDATED

 

[eakfootball]

Kendall Hunter ahead of Stevan Jackson and Fred Jackson?

Aaron Hernandez as the #3 TE?

 

[laughinboy_2000]

Kendall Hunter ahead of Stevan Jackson and Fred Jackson?Aaron Hernandez as the #3 TE?

Excellent Question... Let's Discuss!Let's remember first these are Dynasty Rankings. SJax to me is done. I'm not going to sugarcoat it. The Rams have absolutely run him into the ground, and I doubt he stays healthy and productive this year. His best days are gone.On the other hand, Hunter will be the main guy if/when Frank Gore goes down. Let's remember, he got his first NFL "start" last week and posted a respectable 100+ total yards. Gore's injury history frightens me and frankly he has not looked good so far. Call me crazy, but Hunter could end up outproducing SJax this year. Crazier things have happened. Long term though, I want no part of SJax. F-Jax is having a great year, there's no doubt. He's on the wrong side of 30 though, and I just don't know how long he can keep up his current pace. If these were not DYNASTY Rankings, FJax would of course be higher. Regarding Hernandez as the #3 TE, I love the situation this guy is in. He's on a team that refuses to use there RBs, and why would they with the Brady sitting back there. Also, look at how they were using Hernandez on offense. He's listed as a TE but the Pats use him him in WR sets. He's young and athletic and in the perfect offense. He was producing before he got hurt and I don't see the Pats ignoring him he comes back.

 

[strong]

there needs to be more dynasty/keeper content in the pool and in the subscriber articles/rankings.

cam newton: there's no other qb i'd trade cam for straight up in dynasty. i know it's only been four games, but no other qb has ever come out firing like this. ever. that's EVER. this isn't a running back whose wheels tend to come off. this is a QB and they tend to improve with playing time. wait until he he's had some experience and is reading defenses better. add to that how much he loves to call his own number inside the five, and there you have it. i could see an argument for rodgers in 6pt/passing TD leagues or if you're concerned that the panthers will tell cam to stop rushing so much inside the five, but in any other dynasty league i'd hang my hat on cam. i'd happily trade brady, brees, rivers, vick, and stafford away for cam. i'd probably be willing to throw in a serviceable RB/WR, too.

jeremy maclin: i don't think he should be ahead of roddy white, aj green, wes welker, and stevie johnson. i like him, but i think if/when that offense loses vick, his value dips a bit. (i don't think vick has much in the tank--he's little, takes too many sacks, etc.) while you could say the same about welker and brady, i think roddy, green, and stevie would produce with other QBs.

fred jackson: silly low. i think age should definitely come into play in dynasty, but i'd be happy to take this and next year's production from him (and cross my fingers for any production from him after 32) over the careers of kendall hunter, blount, starks, ridley, etc. he's the type of guy that could win you a ring or two as a RB2.

 

[laughinboy_2000]

fred jackson: silly low. i think age should definitely come into play in dynasty, but i'd be happy to take this and next year's production from him (and cross my fingers for any production from him after 32) over the careers of kendall hunter, blount, starks, ridley, etc. he's the type of guy that could win you a ring or two as a RB2.

30 years old and...3 full seasons

2008 - 817 total yards, 3 TDs

2009 - 1400 total yards, 4 TDs

2010 - 1100 yards, 7 TDs

My reaction... Meh...

Just Sayin...

 

[Craig_MiamiFL]

Too low:

150 Marshawn Lynch, RB Seahawks

Not at all IMO. He's significantly worse than a whole lot of backup NFL RB's (from a talent AND fantasy perspective). He's a guy you'll never start. And has no upside. Guy runs like he's a 30 year old back on his last legs.If someone kept him out of the Top 200....really wouldn't have a problem with it. Expect the RB upgrade in Seattle next year. I think the only good run he had in a Hawk uniform last year (vs. Saints) had Carroll thinking he was a good RB.----------------Nice work on the rankings. I'd bump up all Falcons on your list (Julio at 24 isn't bad, but I think you'll see him being a Top 12 dynasty pick next year)

 

[runner06]

Too low:

150 Marshawn Lynch, RB Seahawks

Not at all IMO. He's significantly worse than a whole lot of backup NFL RB's (from a talent AND fantasy perspective). He's a guy you'll never start. And has no upside. Guy runs like he's a 30 year old back on his last legs.If someone kept him out of the Top 200....really wouldn't have a problem with it. Expect the RB upgrade in Seattle next year. I think the only good run he had in a Hawk uniform last year (vs. Saints) had Carroll thinking he was a good RB.----------------Nice work on the rankings. I'd bump up all Falcons on your list (Julio at 24 isn't bad, but I think you'll see him being a Top 12 dynasty pick next year)

I wouldn't say he has no upside. He had a couple of solid seasons in Buffalo. If Seattle got a solid offensive line and passing game, he might be a solid RB2. He's only 25 too.

 

[Craig_MiamiFL]

Too low:

150 Marshawn Lynch, RB Seahawks

Not at all IMO. He's significantly worse than a whole lot of backup NFL RB's (from a talent AND fantasy perspective). He's a guy you'll never start. And has no upside. Guy runs like he's a 30 year old back on his last legs.If someone kept him out of the Top 200....really wouldn't have a problem with it. Expect the RB upgrade in Seattle next year. I think the only good run he had in a Hawk uniform last year (vs. Saints) had Carroll thinking he was a good RB.----------------Nice work on the rankings. I'd bump up all Falcons on your list (Julio at 24 isn't bad, but I think you'll see him being a Top 12 dynasty pick next year)

I wouldn't say he has no upside. He had a couple of solid seasons in Buffalo. If Seattle got a solid offensive line and passing game, he might be a solid RB2. He's only 25 too.

Those solid years were several years ago. Were they overly impressive? Not any more than Slaton, Kevin Smith and host of other replaceable backs. Those guys were upgraded upon and so will Lynch.Truly stunning IMO this guy is still a starting RB in the NFL. He has no upside because he's not fantasy starting material now & won't be an NFL starting RB much longer.

 

[flc735]

if im drafting a dynasty team today based off the adp, my team would look like this

1.6 foster - looks like the #1 back again

2.7 mathews - not bpa, but going on a wr run after this

3.6 britt - is a top 5 wr

4.7 stevie johnson bpa

5.6 bowe - anticipating a new qb

6.7 Decker - too much value. pass on Dthomas here unless he shows me he can catch 1-3 passes per game this year

7.6 sidney - too many WRs i like in this draft

8.7 collie - i thought he was a top 5 wr this year with peyton. should be the same only cheaper next year

9.6 fred davis

10.7 fitzP -going qbbc in this draft. lucky that fitzP is still here

11.6 d nelson- wr value in this list seems ridiculous

notes: theres a lot of WR2 guys that i like on this list, will have to adjust with trades. value looks great in the 3-5 rounds, may be enough to get me to trade out of the 1-2 rounds, something that i would never do.

the top TEs should drop a little due to the position being so deep now. id much rather have a davis/petigrew/keller in the 9th over a finley/gronk/hernandez in the 4th.

ryan williams and leshore may be RB targets i plan part of my draft around

 

[flc735]

178 Darren Sproles, RB Saints

move him up 130 spots

 

[laughinboy_2000]

BUMP...

 

[Dr. Octopus]

I'd suggest just breaking it out by position. Cross positional rankings are really league dependant - plus it's easier to follow. Of course, it's just a suggestion and it's your gig so do it as you see fit.

Good job by the way.

 

[laughinboy_2000]

I'd suggest just breaking it out by position. Cross positional rankings are really league dependant - plus it's easier to follow. Of course, it's just a suggestion and it's your gig so do it as you see fit.Good job by the way.

Will certainly take a look at doing that in the future. Thanks for the feedback!

 

[Joseph]

I'd suggest just breaking it out by position. Cross positional rankings are really league dependant - plus it's easier to follow. Of course, it's just a suggestion and it's your gig so do it as you see fit.Good job by the way.

Will certainly take a look at doing that in the future. Thanks for the feedback!

The first thing I did upon opening this thread was to copy the list into excel, sort by position and show the position rankings.

 

[jeter23]

I'd suggest just breaking it out by position. Cross positional rankings are really league dependant - plus it's easier to follow. Of course, it's just a suggestion and it's your gig so do it as you see fit.Good job by the way.

Will certainly take a look at doing that in the future. Thanks for the feedback!

I actually like it as is. This gives us a good idea of trade value across positions. Maybe present it in both forms?

 

[FavreAndAwayAnIdiot]

First of all, I commend you for attempting a top-200 overall dynasty rankings list. It's very difficult to do, but they are very useful to us dynasty guys-- if anything, to establish overall trade value.

Now with that said, Frank Gore should not be in the top 100, Sidney Rice should be higher and RB Ryan Williams shouldn't be ranked at all until we see if he can recover.

 

[laughinboy_2000]

First of all, I commend you for attempting a top-200 overall dynasty rankings list. It's very difficult to do, but they are very useful to us dynasty guys-- if anything, to establish overall trade value.

Now with that said, Frank Gore should not be in the top 100, Sidney Rice should be higher and RB Ryan Williams shouldn't be ranked at all until we see if he can recover.

Just not a big fan of Rice. Especially with the QB mess in Seattle. He'll have some good games, but unless the Seahawks get a decent QB, Rice's potential is limited IMO.Not a big fan of Gore either, and that's why I have Hunter closely behind. Gore showed he had a little something left last week, but I personally see Gore sliding down my rankings unless he can prove he can be consistent.

It's unfortunate what happen to Ryan Williams, but the big think with him is that he's YOUNG! Give this guy a chance to recover. PT's and doctors can do wonders these days. Give him a year or two and he could be valuable.

 

[Joseph]

First of all, I commend you for attempting a top-200 overall dynasty rankings list. It's very difficult to do, but they are very useful to us dynasty guys-- if anything, to establish overall trade value.

Now with that said, Frank Gore should not be in the top 100, Sidney Rice should be higher and RB Ryan Williams shouldn't be ranked at all until we see if he can recover.

Just not a big fan of Rice. Especially with the QB mess in Seattle. He'll have some good games, but unless the Seahawks get a decent QB, Rice's potential is limited IMO.Not a big fan of Gore either, and that's why I have Hunter closely behind. Gore showed he had a little something left last week, but I personally see Gore sliding down my rankings unless he can prove he can be consistent.

It's unfortunate what happen to Ryan Williams, but the big think with him is that he's YOUNG! Give this guy a chance to recover. PT's and doctors can do wonders these days. Give him a year or two and he could be valuable.

I agree he could be valuable someday, but right now the market for him has to be almost non-existant. Anyone looking to buy him is going to offer a price that's pretty low, and for the current owner it won't be worth it to sell.

 

[az_prof]

I like the attempt too although to be really useful IMO you need to differentiate between PPR and TD heavy leagues. For example, you have McFadden very high, and in PPR that is deserving. But in TD heavy leagues I wouldn't put him that high. None of the other top backs, Rice, ADP, Johnson, Slim Shady, share goal line carries. I also think you would be better to rank them not overall, but say the top 60 RBs, top 30 QBs, top 75 WRs, top 35 TEs. Or something like that. The reason is that variation can be huge depending on league scoring. So, in my league I would never have any QB in the top 10. They are just too replaceable compared to backs or WRs, and they only get 4 pts/td in my league, so their comparative value is less. It is better to let people draw their own comparative value between positions based on their own league scoring. You wouldn't want someone taking Tom Brady over Larry Fitzgerald in a league with PPR or a league that allows you to start 4 WRs, for example.

 

[strong]

fred jackson: silly low. i think age should definitely come into play in dynasty, but i'd be happy to take this and next year's production from him (and cross my fingers for any production from him after 32) over the careers of kendall hunter, blount, starks, ridley, etc. he's the type of guy that could win you a ring or two as a RB2.

30 years old and...3 full seasons

2008 - 817 total yards, 3 TDs

2009 - 1400 total yards, 4 TDs

2010 - 1100 yards, 7 TDs

My reaction... Meh...

Just Sayin...

i'm lazy. can we see hunter, blount, starks, and ridley's career numbers, too?

 

[laughinboy_2000]

I like the attempt too although to be really useful IMO you need to differentiate between PPR and TD heavy leagues. For example, you have McFadden very high, and in PPR that is deserving. But in TD heavy leagues I wouldn't put him that high. None of the other top backs, Rice, ADP, Johnson, Slim Shady, share goal line carries. I also think you would be better to rank them not overall, but say the top 60 RBs, top 30 QBs, top 75 WRs, top 35 TEs. Or something like that. The reason is that variation can be huge depending on league scoring. So, in my league I would never have any QB in the top 10. They are just too replaceable compared to backs or WRs, and they only get 4 pts/td in my league, so their comparative value is less. It is better to let people draw their own comparative value between positions based on their own league scoring. You wouldn't want someone taking Tom Brady over Larry Fitzgerald in a league with PPR or a league that allows you to start 4 WRs, for example.

These are indeed PPR Rankings, and I have changed the title of the thread to include that. Sorry it took so long to change it. You are correct, these rankings depend a lot on what your league scoring is. Even at 4 points per passing TD, I would still take Rogers and maybe even Brady over Fitz. Brady and Rogers are on fire, where as Fitz is playing decent, but could be putting up much better numbers if you ask me. I will consider putting the players in their own catagory in the future.Thanks for the suggestions guys!

 

[laughinboy_2000]

Updated!

 

[ready5]