This one is an absolute classic and Honestly, the only reason I can bear to share it is because I hope that every guy that ever thinks he wants to quit FF and his luck is bad will remember this story.
It is what I call "The Curse of Lee Evans":
It begins in 2006 and I have Lee Evans on my dyansty team. I'm going through the season and he is freakishly inconsistent. I start him and he duds; I sit him and he rocks. I lose 2 games because of him. So, I trade him.
Week 10: I play the guy I trade him to and I'm hoping to catch him on a dud day. BEFORE I EVEN SIT DOWN TO WATCH THE GAMES, Evans has a freaking 83 yard TD. Not even five minutes later, the gametracker says he has TWO TDs; both for 83 yards! I'm thinking " nah, they have an error". Nope! Sure enough: two 83 yard TDs in the first quarter!. He goes on to have what is probably still his career day. I miss the playoffs by one game.
Fast forward to 2007: My team is good and I have a lead in my division and #1 overall record in the league. In week 7, I play the guy I traded him to and Lee Evans has been NOWHERE TO BE FOUND all season, but my opponent starts him because of bye week issues. Evans goes 5/138/1, scores his 1st TD of the year, and I lose by less than 5 points. My lead in the division shrinks.
The very next week, I face my next opponent and on Saturday night, the Lee Evans owner sells high and trades Evans to my opponent. He goes 9/165/1 and scores his 2nd TD of the year and I lose by less than 10. My lead shrinks again.
Week 13: Last week of the season and I am now tied in my division and it comes down to the division winner gets a first round bye; the runner up becomes the #5 seed and has to play next week. Of course, I am playing against Lee Evans again and he hasn't scored a touchdown since the two weeks I played him. In that game, Evans catches 2 balls the entire game and, yup, BOTH WERE TOUCHDOWNS.
I lose the game, I lose the division, I play the following week and my guys fall on their face. I am out of the playoffs. In the next two weeks, My guys explode and I would have had the highest score of any of the playoff teams and would have won the league easily.
That "bad beat" was two years in the making and it almost made me quit FF.