Who Would You Rather Have? Melvin Gordon or Fournette? (1 Viewer)

[Rebel Ted]

12 team PPR

Team A gave up: Fournette 

Team B gave up: Melvin Gordon and 3.09

 

[twistedude]

Keeper league or not? If not, definitely Gordon.

 

[fightingillini]

I assume this is a keeper league and the 3.09 is in 2018.

This is a pretty even deal in dynasty, due to Fournette being younger than Gordon.  I lean towards Gordon, since we know what he's capable of.  We don't know what Fournette will do in the NFL yet.

 

[travdogg]

Regardless of league type, I'd say Gordon. By a wide margin if its not a dynasty league.

 

[Kam2]

Gordon for reasons already mentioned and the fact that Jacksonville's offense isn't good.

 

[Gally]

I would go with Gordon simply because he has proven he can perform at the NFL level.  I think Gordon will be better in the short terms for sure and they are even long term.