Ramblin Wreck
Footballguy
The drama is realwe're going backward here. anti-vaxxers are killing us and complaining at the same time.
The drama is realwe're going backward here. anti-vaxxers are killing us and complaining at the same time.
Not that it has to do with this, but the wife was telling me today there is a brewery in northern WI that are planning a vaccination party for the end of may. Present proof of vaccination, and get a free beer. The replies on FB, are predictable, sad, and funny at the same time. (their ad had something to do with "a taste of freedom" , or something like that).we're going backward here. anti-vaxxers are killing us and complaining at the same time.
I've got no problem with businesses trying to have freebies or encouraging vaccination. To me that's different than requiring it for employment/service. I'm not sure how much success they will have in doing it, but doing it in a fun way or offering it while at a game such as the Braves did last night, will be much more effective with hesitant folks than government statements will be.Not that it has to do with this, but the wife was telling me today there is a brewery in northern WI that are planning a vaccination party for the end of may. Present proof of vaccination, and get a free beer. The replies on FB, are predictable, sad, and funny at the same time. (their ad had something to do with "a taste of freedom" , or something like that).
We sure are an odd species.
- "wow, talk about discrimination!"
- "This isn’t freedom. Show your papers. Sounds like Russia or China."
- "This isn’t freedom it’s corersion. Forcing someone to get something that they don’t want or is not healthy for them. That is not freedom"
Plus, it's one day - it's not like it's their policy going forward.I've got no problem with businesses trying to have freebies or encouraging vaccination. To me that's different than requiring it for employment/service. I'm not sure how much success they will have in doing it, but doing it in a fun way or offering it while at a game such as the Braves did last night, will be much more effective with hesitant folks than government statements will be.
Yeah if it's seen as a political thing it's not going to work. I know people who have taken the vaccine who really had a problem with the Braves doing that for instance. I would get the objection if it was required for entrance. But if they are simply offering it, that's a convenience for the willing people who want the shot.Plus, it's one day - it's not like it's their policy going forward.
If I am thinking correctly, this place is a little bit of a lightning rod though, as there was a bit of a to-do over them putting up a *gasp* Biden sign during the campaign. North WI not messing around!
I am require to have the annual flu shot to remain employed. Also required of employees of vendors. Been that way for well over a decade. Granted this is a healthcare organization, though I am physically nowhere near doctors or patients (1500 miles). Don't see how this would/should be different?I've got no problem with businesses trying to have freebies or encouraging vaccination. To me that's different than requiring it for employment/service
It's different for two reasons.I am require to have the annual flu shot to remain employed. Also required of employees of vendors. Been that way for well over a decade. Granted this is a healthcare organization, though I am physically nowhere near doctors or patients (1500 miles). Don't see how this would/should be different?
Not really. The lack of people getting vaccinated at this point is the #1 barrier to normalcy and reduction in deaths in the US.The complete lack of focus on ventilation is killing far more people than anything else you guys ever talk about.
And that is 100% the fault of "experts"
1) Sure, but that will likely change.It's different for two reasons.
1) None of the covid-19 vaccines are fully FDA-approved. Of course, this is mainly because the FDA is a dysfunctional organization that served the country incredibly poorly during the pandemic -- in a sane world, the three leading vaccines would have been approved months ago. But the point remains that it's understandable why we (as a society) might be skittish about requiring people to take non-approved drugs.
2) The poster wasn't talking about you, and I'm sure you probably knew that when you were typing up your reply. If you work in a field that requires a spectrum of vaccinations now, then you can reasonably expect to see the covid-19 vaccine added to that list in the near future, after the FDA gets around to doing its job. For most of us, mandatory vaccination is not currently a thing, and covid-19 shouldn't be an exception IMO.
This we can agree on.sho nuff said:And a side benefit of a little odor protection when entering a public restroom.
I strongly disagree with you. I think it SHOULD be an exception. Simply put, we should allow businesses, transportation, schools, actually ALL venues to demand proof of vaccination of employees, passengers, students, customers, etc., and strongly encourage them to do so. You should not be able to resume a “normal”, pre-2020 life in this country unless you’ve been vaccinated for Covid-19.For most of us, mandatory vaccination is not currently a thing, and covid-19 shouldn't be an exception IMO.
How many were dead before the vaccine was available?Not really. The lack of people getting vaccinated at this point is the #1 barrier to normalcy and reduction in deaths in the US.
Why would you require schoolkids to get it?I strongly disagree with you. I think it SHOULD be an exception. Simply put, we should allow businesses, transportation, schools, actually ALL venues to demand proof of vaccination of employees, passengers, students, customers, etc., and strongly encourage them to do so. You should not be able to resume a “normal”, pre-2020 life in this country unless you’ve been vaccinated for Covid-19.
So that it doesn’t spread?Why would you require schoolkids to get it?
I agree that businesses should be allowed to require vaccination. Of course, most businesses don't currently do that for other infectious diseases, and I don't expect that covid will be different. That's just a prediction, not a prescription.I strongly disagree with you. I think it SHOULD be an exception. Simply put, we should allow businesses, transportation, schools, actually ALL venues to demand proof of vaccination of employees, passengers, students, customers, etc., and strongly encourage them to do so. You should not be able to resume a “normal”, pre-2020 life in this country unless you’ve been vaccinated for Covid-19.
It's not even approved for kids. I mean I guess down the road we are assuming it will be but there have been no outbreaks at my daughters' schools nor my wife's who teaches in a large district. The cases the kids at their schools have had have been caught from parents and when they've gotten it it's been drowsiness/headaches those type symptoms. So I guess if it's eventually approved and shown safe for those age groups we look at it then. But today it's not an issue and frankly kids that age just don't seem to be getting very sick at all if they happen to contract it from all the data that I can find.So that it doesn’t spread?
Right, I think I understand your viewpoint. For me it’s a prescription. (I want businesses to make an exception for COVID.)I agree that businesses should be allowed to require vaccination. Of course, most businesses don't currently do that for other infectious diseases, and I don't expect that covid will be different. That's just a prediction, not a prescription.
It will be approved shortly: weeks, not months. I would frankly like to see a vaccine created for newborns, so we can treat this like polio and smallpox in the future.It's not even approved for kids. I mean I guess down the road we are assuming it will be but there have been no outbreaks at my daughters' schools nor my wife's who teaches in a large district. The cases the kids at their schools have had have been caught from parents and when they've gotten it it's been drowsiness/headaches those type symptoms. So I guess if it's eventually approved and shown safe for those age groups we look at it then. But today it's not an issue.
The kids get it and infect their unvaccinated grandparents. I think that’s the primary concern. Also there have been kids who have suffered from long Covid even though it’s atypical.It's not even approved for kids. I mean I guess down the road we are assuming it will be but there have been no outbreaks at my daughters' schools nor my wife's who teaches in a large district. The cases the kids at their schools have had have been caught from parents and when they've gotten it it's been drowsiness/headaches those type symptoms. So I guess if it's eventually approved and shown safe for those age groups we look at it then. But today it's not an issue and frankly kids that age just don't seem to be getting very sick at all if they happen to contract it from all the data that I can find.
Honestly, at some point if people choose to be unvaccinated that's on them. I chose to get the vaccine and likely would choose for my kids to as well. I realize the risk is non-zero, but I can think of a lot more unsafe activities our children freely engage in than if they were to contract Covid. So based on that it's pretty hard for me to say to a parent, you must vaccinate your child or face penalties such as your child being removed from school. Oh by the way, the reason you must do so is to protect someone who freely chose not to vaccinate themselves.The kids get it and infect their unvaccinated grandparents. I think that’s the primary concern. Also there have been kids who have suffered from long Covid even though it’s atypical.
No disagreement that lack of focus on ventilation in the past was one of the primary causes of unnecessary deaths. Then again, other countries similarly botched that topic and still kept death rates way lower than us.How many were dead before the vaccine was available?
And the "lack of people getting vaccinated" isnt a government response.
How do you know that kids were getting covid from parents, and not the other way around?It's not even approved for kids. I mean I guess down the road we are assuming it will be but there have been no outbreaks at my daughters' schools nor my wife's who teaches in a large district. The cases the kids at their schools have had have been caught from parents and when they've gotten it it's been drowsiness/headaches those type symptoms. So I guess if it's eventually approved and shown safe for those age groups we look at it then. But today it's not an issue and frankly kids that age just don't seem to be getting very sick at all if they happen to contract it from all the data that I can find.
I would agree with this if we had a 100% effective vaccine. But we don't. So anytime someone chooses not to get vaccinated, they are risking not only their own lives but also the lives of others.Honestly, at some point if people choose to be unvaccinated that's on them.
Odds would say if a kid in a class came down with Covid, nobody else in the class has Covid, yet their entire household has Covid, the Covid infection started in the household.How do you know that kids were getting covid from parents, and not the other way around?
Sure, probably would go with the odds that a kid got it from someone in their household. Or from their neighbors. Or daycare. Or from another kid on a sports team. Or from an asymptomatic kid in class who never got tested. Etc.Odds would say if a kid in a class came down with Covid, nobody else in the class has Covid, yet their entire household has Covid, the Covid infection started in the household.
This is where I fundamentally disagree with you. We have just suffered the greatest catastrophe to hit this nation, and planet, since World War II. In the United States alone 900,000 people have died due to COVID (Thats per a new study by the University of Washington.)Honestly, at some point if people choose to be unvaccinated that’s on them.
So what's the answer then short of the state mandating 100% vaccination from its citizenry? If your point is that the unvaccinated put those at risk who are vaccinated, on a small statistical scale we agree. So how do you fix that? The only way I can come up with is if you want it to be as close to zero as possible you would have to mandate it to everyone. I don't think we as a country are anywhere near able to go there.I would agree with this if we had a 100% effective vaccine. But we don't. So anytime someone chooses not to get vaccinated, they are risking not only their own lives but also the lives of others.
The reason why it's bad for Biden to wear a mask is because it sends a message that the vaccines don't really work or aren't really reliable. For example, this guy seems to think that vaccinated people face some kind of significant risk from unvaccinated people, which simply isn't the case. If you've been fully vaccinated, the probability of you catching covid is very close to zero, and your probability of dying from covid, which is what really matters, is even lower. This is good news that for some reason isn't breaking through, and the president is uniquely positioned to shape that narrative.Sure, probably would go with the odds that a kid got it from someone in their household. Or from their neighbors. Or daycare. Or from another kid on a sports team. Or from an asymptomatic kid in class who never got tested. Etc.
Anyway, back to the thread topic, glad that the biggest issue we face right now is Joe Biden wearing a mask.
See my post above, We don’t need to mandate it. (I wish we could but too many problems.) But we can, and should, make normal life as untenable as possible for those who are not vaccinated. Can’t go on an airplane or train, Cant go to a movie. Can’t put your kid in school. Etc etc.So what's the answer then short of the state mandating 100% vaccination from its citizenry? If your point is that the unvaccinated put those at risk who are vaccinated, on a small statistical scale we agree. So how do you fix that? The only way I can come up with is if you want it to be as close to zero as possible you would have to mandate it to everyone. I don't think we as a country are anywhere near able to go there.
I disagree with this as well.The reason why it's bad for Biden to wear a mask is because it sends a message that the vaccines don't really work or aren't really reliable. For example, this guy seems to think that vaccinated people face some kind of significant risk from unvaccinated people, which simply isn't the case. If you've been fully vaccinated, the probability of you catching covid is very close to zero, and your probability of dying from covid, which is what really matters, is even lower. This is good news that for some reason isn't breaking through, and the president is uniquely positioned to shape that narrative.
I don't really want to mandate it, but hopefully we find creative ways to "nudge" people to get vaccinated. Once we reach herd immunity, I'll probably stop caring about it.So what's the answer then short of the state mandating 100% vaccination from its citizenry? If your point is that the unvaccinated put those at risk who are vaccinated, on a small statistical scale we agree. So how do you fix that? The only way I can come up with is if you want it to be as close to zero as possible you would have to mandate it to everyone. I don't think we as a country are anywhere near able to go there.
I don't disagree with you. The flip side is that Biden not wearing a mask sends a message to really dumb people that this is all over already, regardless of vaccination rates. It's a tough balance.The reason why it's bad for Biden to wear a mask is because it sends a message that the vaccines don't really work or aren't really reliable. For example, this guy seems to think that vaccinated people face some kind of significant risk from unvaccinated people, which simply isn't the case. If you've been fully vaccinated, the probability of you catching covid is very close to zero, and your probability of dying from covid, which is what really matters, is even lower. This is good news that for some reason isn't breaking through, and the president is uniquely positioned to shape that narrative.
It is on them. I can't force those who don't want to take it to take the shot, neither can you. There's nothing you can do about that even if you want to. I won't feel guilty if and when they get sick either. I've had my shots, I'm assuming you have. What part is on us?This is where I fundamentally disagree with you. We have just suffered the greatest catastrophe to hit this nation, and planet, since World War II. In the United States alone 900,000 people have died due to COVID (Thats per a new study by the University of Washington.)
We cannot treat this as a freedom of choice issue. Ita not on them. It’s on all of us.
Unvaccinated people aren't taking their cues from Biden. They're going maskless now, and have been this whole time. That's on Trump, among others.I disagree with this as well.
If Biden goes maskless a whole lot of people will assume “it’s over”, and many unvaccinated folks will go maskless, and some folks will catch COVID and some folks will die.
Biden needs to wait until it’s truly over. That’s not now.
It's fine to care, I care. I want as many people to take it as we can get. I think the government pushing it has limits though and mostly the people who are reluctant will actually be pushed moreso in that direction the more they feel the government is pushing it.I don't really want to mandate it, but hopefully we find creative ways to "nudge" people to get vaccinated. Once we reach herd immunity, I'll probably stop caring about it.
I looked but all I could find were more small studies showing no evidence of increased hypoxia. For example, this one looked at 30 total people doing 6 minutes of walking.Terminalxylem said:While that research letter is far from definitive, within the limits of the study (powered to detect a meaningful difference of 2%, IIRC), masks didn’t promote hypoxia.
I’m not sure about the physics of a moisture barrier, but we have no direct evidence impairment in gas exchange is relevant for mask wearers. But we do have at least a couple small studies which suggest otherwise. Here’s another one
I know it’s also a small group, but can you provide any data suggesting to the contrary?
Not really. The message should be "Get vaccinated. If you're not vaccinated, you should keep wearing a mask and stay home. If you are vaccinated, do whatever you want." It's not a complicated message.I don't disagree with you. The flip side is that Biden not wearing a mask sends a message to really dumb people that this is all over already, regardless of vaccination rates. It's a tough balance.
All of the folks with the "govt shutdowns are destroying the economy" narrative would lose their minds if Biden went with your uncomplicated message. That said, I would love to hear that message.Not really. The message should be "Get vaccinated. If you're not vaccinated, you should keep wearing a mask and stay home. If you are vaccinated, do whatever you want." It's not a complicated message.
And there is a not insignificant number of people who can't get vaccinated (my wife who is immuno-compromised) so I appreciate your opinion as well.When the government warned people to evacuate New Orleans before Hurricane Katrina, we still tried to save the people that ignored that advice. I see this as the same. Just because someone has not been vaccinated yet is not a reason to just let them get sick and possibly die. At least until we’ve made some serious efforts to help them.
Why do you care if people continue to avoid re-entering society? I'd like to see life return somewhat to normal, but I really don't care if anyone else decides to hole up in their homes for the next 25 years.What I'm more interested in is the phenomenon of people who seem to have a psychological hang-up with re-entering society. That group of people actually is mostly Biden-friendly and his messaging matters with that group.
Yet another reason we should nudge people to get vaccinated as quickly as possible. Can't imagine how scary and frustrating it must be (for your wife and/or you) to see folks just absolutely unwilling to get vaccinated.And there is a not insignificant number of people who can't get vaccinated (my wife who is immuno-compromised) so I appreciate your opinion as well.
I don’t have issue with Biden wearing a mask. I think it’s pretty obvious he’s broadcasting a message - masks are effective. It’s overly cautious but it is a painless, low effort way to protect people.When the government warned people to evacuate New Orleans before Hurricane Katrina, we still tried to save the people that ignored that advice. I see this as the same. Just because someone has not been vaccinated yet is not a reason to just let them get sick and possibly die. At least until we’ve made some serious efforts to help them.
Thanks. Yeah, its a weird/tough time right now psychologically for her. We have quite a vocal anti-vaxx minority in our area which makes neighborhood social media one of the most depressing and angering places around. And that's the adult vaccine. I dread what the kids vaccine lunacy around here will be like as just the prospect of continued Fall masks in school has the crazies on tilt. Hopefully that 12-15 year old vaccine will be available way before the new Fall school year as that will ease the stress on 2 out of our 3 kids. I may have to get a fake ID for my 9 year old.Yet another reason we should nudge people to get vaccinated as quickly as possible. Can't imagine how scary and frustrating it must be (for your wife and/or you) to see folks just absolutely unwilling to get vaccinated.
It's an interesting psychological phenomenon. Most of us, me included, spent a year and change literally conditioning ourselves to think that the air is poisonous and that other people pose direct and immediate dangers to us. I found it easy to overcome that conditioning, but it's very obvious that other people are struggling with it.Why do you care if people continue to avoid re-entering society?
I personally think the biggest problem with Biden's mask wearing is that it has no rhyme or reason to it.I disagree with this as well.
If Biden goes maskless a whole lot of people will assume “it’s over”, and many unvaccinated folks will go maskless, and some folks will catch COVID and some folks will die.
Biden needs to wait until it’s truly over. That’s not now.
Isnt this a crazy short list?How do we handle people we cannot get the vaccine (some sort of pre-condition)