What's new
Fantasy Football - Footballguys Forums

Welcome to Our Forums. Once you've registered and logged in, you're primed to talk football, among other topics, with the sharpest and most experienced fantasy players on the internet.

Microwave Propulsion: no-fuel spaceships (1 Viewer)

El Floppo

Footballguy
Surprised the other Mars Rover nerds didn't post this yet... (speaking of Mars Rover... just saw that Opportunity is still chugging along and broke the Ruskie's Mars rover's off-world distance record recently)

Cannae drive technology, a way of propelling spaceships using microwave energy, has been successfully tested by NASA. Such an engine, if thoroughly developed, could shorten the time needed for a trip to Mars from months to weeks. The biggest surprise of the test was that the system worked at all -- theory said the engine would not be able to produce any amount of thrust -- even the small amounts of power seen in the test.

The experiment involved filling a specially-designed container with microwaves. The uneven shape of the canister creates a difference in radiation pressure, causing a thrust forward, toward the larger end of the vessel. Despite what most physicists predicted, the device started to produce a small amount of thrust, slightly over 0.0001 ounces.

That amount of force is not large, but just the fact that any at all was measured baffles scientists. The conservation of momentum states that no thrust at all should be produced by such a system.

A pair of Cannae drives were produced for the tests. While one was built according to its design, the other was purposely manufactured to fail. Investigators were shocked when each of the drives produced a net thrust.

NASA performed earlier tests on the Cannae drive that also showed similar levels of thrust from the improbable engine. Those experiments were carried out in August 2013 and January 2014. This new study was an updated test of the system.

Some scientists believe the drive may be interacting with the quantum vacuum of the Universe. This is the lowest energy state possible for any piece of matter.

If further tests of similar systems are successful in larger Cannae engines, the design could allow the manufacture of ultra-lightweight rockets that could bring human travelers to the nearest star in just 30 years.



"Approximately six days of test integration were required, followed by two days of test operations, during which, technical issues were discovered and resolved... [T]he test article was tested on the bench, then moved to the chamber, then moved back as needed to resolve issues," NASA officials detail in a paper describing the results of the experiment.

Cannae Drive is a private company, owned and operated by Guido Fetta, who has a bachelor's degree in chemical engineering.

"Space missions that once lived only in the realm of science fiction are now feasible. From dramatically reduced satellite costs, to manned missions to the outer solar system and beyond, the Cannae Drive is the enabling technology for 21st century space travel," Cannae drive developers wrote on their website.
 
Sarnoff said:
Here's a link to another article on it: http://sploid.gizmodo.com/nasa-reveals-new-impossible-engine-can-change-space-t-1614549987

However, there are some skeptics that believe it's too early to celebrate these results. NASA may have jumped the gun with the announcement for the PR win.
Don't see how this is a PR win for NASA. They confirmed that it does work like the Chinese said it would. Although they didn't get anything like the thrust the Chinese claimed. So publishing it now seems more like saying previous work was right.

 
Interesting though if the microwaves do interact with quantum virtual plasma to produce thrust. Mind boggling what that could lead to.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
Sarnoff said:
Here's a link to another article on it: http://sploid.gizmodo.com/nasa-reveals-new-impossible-engine-can-change-space-t-1614549987

However, there are some skeptics that believe it's too early to celebrate these results. NASA may have jumped the gun with the announcement for the PR win.
Don't see how this is a PR win for NASA. They confirmed that it does work like the Chinese said it would. Although they didn't get anything like the thrust the Chinese claimed. So publishing it now seems more like saying previous work was right.
Maybe more of a "throw some more money at us" kind of thing. IIRC, the criticism was that this news release came before experimental error was eliminated as the cause for the unusual measurements. This kind of drive is called "The Impossible Drive", and there's the usual caveat of extraordinary claims requiring extraordinary proof before being touted like this.

I hope it is true, but, it could be too early to celebrate.

 
Sarnoff said:
Here's a link to another article on it: http://sploid.gizmodo.com/nasa-reveals-new-impossible-engine-can-change-space-t-1614549987

However, there are some skeptics that believe it's too early to celebrate these results. NASA may have jumped the gun with the announcement for the PR win.
Don't see how this is a PR win for NASA. They confirmed that it does work like the Chinese said it would. Although they didn't get anything like the thrust the Chinese claimed. So publishing it now seems more like saying previous work was right.
Maybe more of a "throw some more money at us" kind of thing. IIRC, the criticism was that this news release came before experimental error was eliminated as the cause for the unusual measurements. This kind of drive is called "The Impossible Drive", and there's the usual caveat of extraordinary claims requiring extraordinary proof before being touted like this.

I hope it is true, but, it could be too early to celebrate.
Aren't they the sixth lab to get positive results? And really the Casimir effect has been known about for over 70 years and is used in practical applications today. It would seem this is tied up in that. There are two possibilities it doesn't work like multiple researchers claimed it did. Or it works and it's an area where classical physics gives way to quantum physics. No such thing as impossible in quantum physics. Highly improbable certainly but not truly impossible.

 

Users who are viewing this thread

Top