What's new
Fantasy Football - Footballguys Forums

This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

2007 NFL Draft, picks #1-10...let's discuss needs. (1 Viewer)

Ministry of Pain

Footballguy
1. Oakland Raiders: They have a lot of holes to fill. Everyone is talking about them taking JeMarcus Russell in the upcoming draft. Certainly Aaron Brroks being cut would make you think they are clearing the way, but I also think it will be another mistake by a team that can’t get out of its own way. They lose Gruden in 2001, fire Calahan 2 seasons later, Turner 2 seasons later, Art Shell 1 year after that…the problem is up top in the front office. Maybe it is the owner is going senile but they are just not picking players that pan out in the NFL.

The Raiders would be better served to bring in a guy like Jake Plummer(who they can’t get because he wears a Broncos uniform), or go get Jeff Garcia who could surely deliver the ball to Moss and Porter. An in the draft they should work on that horrible OL and bring in Joe Thomas from Wisconsin. This guy runs a 4.9 40 time, eats defenders up at the point of attack, simply is the answer at LT for almost every team that has a top5 or top10 pick. You draft Thomas, move Gallery over to RT where he is better suited…this would make the Raiders a better team. They have skills position players and the defense is not the absolute worst in the league. A good ground game and a decent offense can protect a marginal defense.

Will the Raiders do this? Probably not but it makes the most sense. The other thing Oakland could do is draft Calvin Johnson with the #1 pick. When they drafted Tim Brown, that seemed to work out well for them so why not take what many believe is the best player in the draft.

Edited to add that they have gone out and done what we said they should. Perhaps now they start to turn their attention to Calvin Johnson.

2. Detroit Lions: I think Detroit is the closest to getting things turned around than almost anyone else with top10 picks this year. They have a good QB they can start for right now...the WR are solid, they have a hole at RB for the 1st half of the season but they did draft Brian Calhoun last year. They can probably bring in a veteran to hold the fort down for awhile since the RB is never going to get 20+ carries a game in a Mike Martz offense. I again think the biggest weakness the Lions have is probably the OL and also they need some help along the DL. I see 2-3 sure fire prospects for them. Again if Joe Thomas form Wisconsin is available it would make a lot of sense for them to take him. However I also think they could use a little pop at DE and get more rush from the corners.

They have Cory Redding and Shaun Rodgers at DT and they can potentially make one of the best 1-2 punches at DT in the NFL. But they need some speed coming around the edges. Jamaal Anderson from Arkansas is a 6”6', 280 lb freak of nature that reminds a lot of people of Julius Peppers. I also like Gaines Adams from Clemson a lot but they could trade down to get that guy.

You could see Detroit take Adrian Peterson here as well but I don’t think his pass catching abilities will make him a hot prospect in Martz’s eyes. Coach Marinelli came from the Bucs and knows that to win championships you need to be good in the trenches. Look for Detroit to improve themselves on either side of the ball along the line.

3. Cleveland Browns: Team has just been snakebit when it comes to their draft picks and free agent acquisitions. If AP is on the board then expect the Browns to take him if for nothing else to try and appease the fans, giving them someone to root for. The team is a long way from being in the playoffs but they have an exciting young WR in Braylon Edwards, maybe a good young RB will help them along. They still have major OL needs but I look for them to address those issues in the 2nd and 3rd rounds of the draft. They could also trade down and get some additional picks to get that OL turned around.

4. Tampa Bay Buccaneers: A lot of people expect Gruden to jump all over Calvin Johnson if he is there at #4. Certainly CJ is one of the best prospects in the top5 along with Joe Thomas. I just think the Bucs need to decide if Simms is really going to be their QB. He did lead them to the playoffs in 2005 but that was more because of the injury to Brian Griese. Simms looked terrible last season and that is because the OL for TB is one of the worst in the league. Again I would say with such a high pick they should try and trade up to secure Joe Thomas from Wisconsin. He would/could be the centerpiece to build the rest of the OL around. The Raiders seem to like to trade with the Bucs, why not swap the picks and they can still get Russell is they desire him at #4…if he is gone somehow, the Raiders could still take Brady Quinn.

I understand why the Bucs will want to get Johnson, but they still have Galloway and Michael Clayton which isn’t a terrible 1-2 at WR. They need a better OL to help “Cadillac” become the #5 pick he was supposed to be 2 seasons ago. They went 11-5 in 2005 because they got good protection at QB and good run blocking for Cadillac. Time to get back to what works in the NFL…BLOCKING!!! There are only 2 things you do 90% of the time as a football player on the filed, block and tackle…if the OL cannot block then expect to do nothing well on offense.

5. Arizona Cardinals: It is obvious they have talent, lots of it at WR, QB, and Edge is still a good RB. They need an OL plain and simple. Assuming Joe Thomas is gone it is time for Levi Brown to come off the board. He started as ®Freshman at Penn St and never let it go. He is a big kid but has good strength. Not the same impact player that Joe Thomas is…in fact I think Thomas many notches better then the rest of his OL class, just like Calvin Johnson is for the WR class. I have seen where the Cardinals are slated to take a DE like a Jamaal Anderson…they certainly need that as well but they need an OL to protect their investment on offense and to give them at least a little bit of a running game.

6. Washington Redskins: They gave up a lot of yards on the ground last season, time to bring in a DT they can build around. Alan Branch a Junior DT from Michigan is just what the doctor ordered. They need to rebuild the DL and why not start in the middle so they can plug up the run. There is talk they might move down in the draft, but I think the wise move is to shore up the defense. The OL is solid, great RB, good WR, QB will be a bit shaky but time to get work on the defense.

7. Minnesota Vikings: Very interested to see who they take. I have heard and read that Childress doesn’t believe in taking 1st round WR…that seems short sighted…maybe he doesn’t like reaching for them when he has a top10 pick. The Vikings have the makings of a good OL. I don’t think Tavaris Jackson is the answer at QB…I really think they should look at Brady Quinn at the point. They need an upgrade at the position, argue all you like but they need to address it. They might be able to nab another QB with a lesser pedigree in the 2nd or even 3rd round so maybe they should try for Gaines Adams with this pick and lay the groundwork for a solid DL. Adamas isn’t going to get the fans excited in Minnesota but in the end it may make the most sense on draft day.

If the Raiders take Calvin Johnson then look for Jamarcus Russell to be drafted by the Vikings.

8. Houston Texans: I see several areas of need for them. If they can work a trade for Jake Plummer then they will have a lot of options and ways they could go on draft day. Let’s examine the needs.

QB: Could bite the bullet and take Brady Quinn if they do not find a decent veteran to bring in. Could Jeff Garcia be a possible addition for this team?

RB: Dominic Davis “Williams”, Ron Dayne, Wali Lundy…I could see them going after Marshawn Lynch for his ability to run and catch. Might not be the best pick and they could trade down and still get Lynch but it is an area they need to address.

WR: They need something better on the opposite side of Andre Johnson. Dwayne Jarrett would make a fine addition to this team. The 6”5’ WR can get separation and has terrific hands. I would think he would make a good compliment to the speed AJ on the other side.

OL: Nothing around this pick that would justify the selection. If Levi Brown were still on the board, he would be worth a look.

Defense: If they wanted to address the defense they would likely trade down for a LB but they took Mario Williams #1 last year so I think Kubiak will get to use the 1st round this year to build the offense.

9. Miami Dolphins: Again if Levi Brown falls they should jump on him as they need OL help. They have Ronnie Brown, Chris Chambers, Culpepper, McMichael, I think Cam Cameron can work with what he has. They need to upgrade at the OL.

The defense needs some help but around this pick they would be looking at one of 3 possible DBs…Reggie Nelson from UF, LaRon Landry from LSU…I like Landry and he has the potential to fill a void Miami has had since Louis Oliver. They need a guy that can come up and lay a lick on a guy. Leon Hall from Michigan would get a look here but he probably would not have the 1st year impact they are looking for form this pick.

10. Atlanta Falcons: Probably have their sights set on a Safety. Nelson and Landry will be on their short list of possibilities. Could also see them look at a DT like Quinn Pitcock here. Might be a tad early for that pick though.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
8. Houston Texans: I see several areas of need for them. If they can work a trade for Jake Plummer then they will have a lot of options and ways they could go on draft day. Let’s examine the needs.QB: Could bite the bullet and take Brady Quinn if they do not find a decent veteran to bring in. Could Jeff Garcia be a possible addition for this team?RB: Dominic Davis “Williams”, Ron Dayne, Wali Lundy…I could see them going after Marshawn Lynch for his ability to run and catch. Might not be the best pick and they could trade down and still get Lynch but it is an area they need to address.WR: They need something better on the opposite side of Andre Johnson. Dwayne Jarrett would make a fine addition to this team. The 6”5’ WR can get separation and has terrific hands. I would think he would make a good compliment to the speed AJ on the other side. OL: Nothing around this pick that would justify the selection. If Levi Brown were still on the board, he would be worth a look.Defense: If they wanted to address the defense they would likely trade down for a LB but they took Mario Williams #1 last year so I think Kubiak will get to use the 1st round this year to build the offense.
The Texans need to address defense as much as they do offense. While they have invested heavily on the DL, they have invested poorly. The Texans need a pure pass rushing DE, CB, DT and FS as much as upgrading Eric Moulds. There would be more of an uproar for drafting Brady Quinn, no matter what happens with Carr, than any of those positions. On trading down, many teams would love to trade out and gain extra picks, but especially at the top of the draft, a team has next to zero control over their ability to do so.
 
5. Unless Thomas falls I think the Cards will make a surprising pick or try to trade down, Levi Brown is a huge reach at #5 and Vermeil made a good point at the combine - good OL can be found later in the draft. The Cards Secondary pretty much sucks, the only bright spot being Adrian Wilson. Theres not really a Corner (it seems) worthy of a top 5 pick this year though.

My choice of targets: LaRon Landry S, Alan Branch DT, Gaines Adams & Jamaal Anderson DE

 
5. Unless Thomas falls I think the Cards will make a surprising pick or try to trade down, Levi Brown is a huge reach at #5 and Vermeil made a good point at the combine - good OL can be found later in the draft. The Cards Secondary pretty much sucks, the only bright spot being Adrian Wilson. Theres not really a Corner (it seems) worthy of a top 5 pick this year though.My choice of targets: LaRon Landry S, Alan Branch DT, Gaines Adams & Jamaal Anderson DE
There is a big drop off after Levi Brown from what I have read and seen.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
5. Unless Thomas falls I think the Cards will make a surprising pick or try to trade down, Levi Brown is a huge reach at #5 and Vermeil made a good point at the combine - good OL can be found later in the draft. The Cards Secondary pretty much sucks, the only bright spot being Adrian Wilson. Theres not really a Corner (it seems) worthy of a top 5 pick this year though.My choice of targets: LaRon Landry S, Alan Branch DT, Gaines Adams & Jamaal Anderson DE
There is a big drop off after Levi Brown from what I have read and seen.
Well there was supposed to be a big drop off from Brick Ferguson to McNeill last year too, but who made the Pro Bowl ? IMO reaching for need is not the way to become a contender, they have a high 2nd rd pick to adress OL. But all this is just my personal opinion of course :ptts:
 
I'm curious to hear why you think Tarvaris Jackson "isn't the answer" at QB for the Vikings. His body of work is only 2 and a half games if I remember correctly. Are they honestly going to allow him no time to develop?

 
DE is the other position that the Redskins are getting linked with currently. The two names that is bounced around are J. Anderson and G. Adams. Between either of them to Branch are the strongest possibilities. BTW - Good job!

 
I'm curious to hear why you think Tarvaris Jackson "isn't the answer" at QB for the Vikings. His body of work is only 2 and a half games if I remember correctly. Are they honestly going to allow him no time to develop?
He was a project IMO to begin with, and I don't think he is close to being ready. 2.5 games last season did nothing to change that. You think Jackson can help them lift a Lombardi Trophy in the next couple of seasons? No way.
 
DE is the other position that the Redskins are getting linked with currently. The two names that is bounced around are J. Anderson and G. Adams. Between either of them to Branch are the strongest possibilities. BTW - Good job!
Thank you.I also have seen them linked to the 2 DE you mention but I really think they should try and plug the holes up the middle first. There isn't much out there in FA so get one while you can.
 
5. Unless Thomas falls I think the Cards will make a surprising pick or try to trade down, Levi Brown is a huge reach at #5 and Vermeil made a good point at the combine - good OL can be found later in the draft. The Cards Secondary pretty much sucks, the only bright spot being Adrian Wilson. Theres not really a Corner (it seems) worthy of a top 5 pick this year though.My choice of targets: LaRon Landry S, Alan Branch DT, Gaines Adams & Jamaal Anderson DE
There is a big drop off after Levi Brown from what I have read and seen.
Well there was supposed to be a big drop off from Brick Ferguson to McNeill last year too, but who made the Pro Bowl ? IMO reaching for need is not the way to become a contender, they have a high 2nd rd pick to adress OL. But all this is just my personal opinion of course :thumbup:
They need almost an entire new OL...so whether they draft on early, in the middle, late, they need an overhaul of that OL. Why not grab one in the 1st a solid 2nd rounder too...they need help. Levi Brown is going to go off the board in the first 10 picks, they might as well grab him with #5. I don't think they definitely will but I am saying they should. They have a terrible OL.
 
5. Unless Thomas falls I think the Cards will make a surprising pick or try to trade down, Levi Brown is a huge reach at #5 and Vermeil made a good point at the combine - good OL can be found later in the draft. The Cards Secondary pretty much sucks, the only bright spot being Adrian Wilson. Theres not really a Corner (it seems) worthy of a top 5 pick this year though.My choice of targets: LaRon Landry S, Alan Branch DT, Gaines Adams & Jamaal Anderson DE
There is a big drop off after Levi Brown from what I have read and seen.
Well there was supposed to be a big drop off from Brick Ferguson to McNeill last year too, but who made the Pro Bowl ? IMO reaching for need is not the way to become a contender, they have a high 2nd rd pick to adress OL. But all this is just my personal opinion of course :shrug:
They need almost an entire new OL...so whether they draft on early, in the middle, late, they need an overhaul of that OL. Why not grab one in the 1st a solid 2nd rounder too...they need help. Levi Brown is going to go off the board in the first 10 picks, they might as well grab him with #5. I don't think they definitely will but I am saying they should. They have a terrible OL.
The line actually did show signs of life late in the year, once Green stopped shuffling them around every week. If I was a decision maker in the desert (everybody probably thank their lucky stars I'm not) I'd be looking to spend big in FA. Max Starks OT Pittsburgh is RFA and from what I hear they are very pleased with his backup (Colon I think is his name), thats a possible option I would look into. I would make an effort to re-sign Leonard Davis for less money and move him to guard, thats LG and LT already taken care of :D . The rest of the line is servicable, but an argument could be made about replacing Leckey at Center and the high 2nd round pick is a nice spot to land Kalil. This would be a completely revamped line :banned: Next I go all in to try and get Clements to come play corner for me, instantly moving Rolle to #2With my 5th overall pick I pick Laron Landry, the tandem of Landry & Wilson would be the best in the league, that pick and the huge addition of Clements in FA suddenly makes the secondary a strength not a weakness.2nd round - I feel Leckey is servicable but Kalil is too nice of an option to pass up here.Rest of the draft - depth, depth, depthMany things have to go just right in this scenario, but suddenly the Cards in my eyes is a contender :shock:
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Slider said:
Ministry of Pain said:
1. Oakland Raiders: go get Jeff Garcia who could surely deliver the ball to Moss and Porter.
He can't throw it much more than 30 yards. Bad idea.
Moss, when he cares, is one of the best in the business at adjusting to underthrown balls. The Raiders certainly would do better with Garcia at QB than Walter, and I'm not sure either of the top rookies grade out well enough to take that high.
 
Senile or not, I don't see Al Davis drafting a QB. He will go after a free agent QB hard, and Garcia seems to fill the bill. Doesn't hurt that he starred across the bay in SF.

In the last 20 years, he's taken as many Kickers in the first round as quarterbacks. I think he will go OL and I'm betting that whoever drafts Thomas will have the biggest immediate upside this year.

 
Great analysis...I think you are right on with the Lions. They will go Thomas and go defense in round 2 and 3 or trade down and take one of the DEs and go Oline in rounds 2 or 3...

 
3. Cleveland Browns: Team has just been snakebit when it comes to their draft picks and free agent acquisitions. If AP is on the board then expect the Browns to take him if for nothing else to try and appease the fans, giving them someone to root for. The team is a long way from being in the playoffs but they have an exciting young WR in Braylon Edwards, maybe a good young RB will help them along. They still have major OL needs but I look for them to address those issues in the 2nd and 3rd rounds of the draft. They could also trade down and get some additional picks to get that OL turned around.

If they want to appease fans, they'll trade down more than once. AP is not a fan favorite. There really isn't a fan favorite. Quinn, Thomas, Branch, Johnson and AP all have followers, but the most common statement is... "If we can't trade down, then we should take this guy..." Free agency is gonna say a lot about how the Browns draft. Phil's normally gonna take BPA that's a need. He won't reach for a need and he won't pick a BPA that will sit the bench either.

 
Senile or not, I don't see Al Davis drafting a QB. He will go after a free agent QB hard, and Garcia seems to fill the bill. Doesn't hurt that he starred across the bay in SF.

In the last 20 years, he's taken as many Kickers in the first round as quarterbacks. I think he will go OL and I'm betting that whoever drafts Thomas will have the biggest immediate upside this year.
Agree 100%...he will help make teams look a lot better immediately on offense.
 
Bumping with the Raiders now signing Garcia.

What changes if anything?
Is that confirmed?If so, I don't think it changes much. I still think Jamarcus is the guy. Between Al's comments regarding thinking about Leinart last year, to interviewing Russell's QB guy, Martinez, to signing a stopgap guy like Garcia, signs are pointing to QB, IMO.

If they decide to cut Jordan, rather than pay him the bonus, I think people will read that as a sign that Peterson is in the crosshairs, but I won't. I think it'll just show what they think about jordan. Kind of how Brooks getting cut doesn't mean Russell is the guy, just that they didn't want Brooks.

Shoot, you could make an argument for all the top prospects for the Raiders, and have a solid argument.

EDIT: Garcis deal appears (presently) dead.

http://sfgate.com/cgi-bin/article.cgi?f=/c...SPGSTOEE2V3.DTL

 
Last edited by a moderator:
1. Oakland Raiders:

They have skills position players and the defense is not the absolute worst in the league. A good ground game and a decent offense can protect a marginal defense.
I'm not saying we're there yet, but you make it sound like our defense played like crap last year, they're the ones that even kept us in games. Certainly they showed tons of improvement last year (ranked 3rd overall), all of the starters and key backups are under contract through 07, so I certainly wouldn't call them marginal.
 
1. Oakland Raiders:

They have skills position players and the defense is not the absolute worst in the league. A good ground game and a decent offense can protect a marginal defense.
I'm not saying we're there yet, but you make it sound like our defense played like crap last year, they're the ones that even kept us in games. Certainly they showed tons of improvement last year (ranked 3rd overall), all of the starters and key backups are under contract through 07, so I certainly wouldn't call them marginal.
Agreed, you have a very solid defense. 2 great corners among the top duos in the league, a promising LB corps (Howard I think will be a stud), solid line incl. an elite passrusher in Burgess and at safety Huff will only continue to improve. Sands has been retained and so has the DC, I don't really see whats not to like. If only the offense could put together a drive once in a while you'd be in great shape.
 
1. Oakland Raiders:

They have skills position players and the defense is not the absolute worst in the league. A good ground game and a decent offense can protect a marginal defense.
I'm not saying we're there yet, but you make it sound like our defense played like crap last year, they're the ones that even kept us in games. Certainly they showed tons of improvement last year (ranked 3rd overall), all of the starters and key backups are under contract through 07, so I certainly wouldn't call them marginal.
Good points WE, but I did say they weren't the worst so that part was true. :angry:
 
6. Washington Redskins: They gave up a lot of yards on the ground last season, time to bring in a DT they can build around. Alan Branch a Junior DT from Michigan is just what the doctor ordered. They need to rebuild the DL and why not start in the middle so they can plug up the run. There is talk they might move down in the draft, but I think the wise move is to shore up the defense. The OL is solid, great RB, good WR, QB will be a bit shaky but time to get work on the defense.
I don't disagree with any of the above if the Redskins in fact use their 1.06 to draft a player. I'm a big advocate of them trading down this year however. At 1.06 they figure to be able to grab one of the handful of most coveted players in the draft depending upon who goes in front of them, and remarkably we really can't rule anyone out. Any of Quinn, Russell, Johnson, Peterson, Anderson, or Thomas figures to be there for them. This puts them in a prime position to trade down while on the clock with a team that covets the particular player(s) still on the board.

Branch is nice, but I'd like for them to trade down lower into the first round where they can still grab one of the better d-line prospects and also pick up one or two other first day picks.

 
2. Detroit Lions: I think Detroit is the closest to getting things turned around than almost anyone else with top10 picks this year. They have a good QB they can start for right now...the WR are solid, they have a hole at RB for the 1st half of the season but they did draft Brian Calhoun last year. They can probably bring in a veteran to hold the fort down for awhile since the RB is never going to get 20+ carries a game in a Mike Martz offense. I again think the biggest weakness the Lions have is probably the OL and also they need some help along the DL. I see 2-3 sure fire prospects for them. Again if Joe Thomas form Wisconsin is available it would make a lot of sense for them to take him. However I also think they could use a little pop at DE and get more rush from the corners.

They have Cory Redding and Shaun Rodgers at DT and they can potentially make one of the best 1-2 punches at DT in the NFL. But they need some speed coming around the edges. Jamaal Anderson from Arkansas is a 6”6', 280 lb freak of nature that reminds a lot of people of Julius Peppers. I also like Gaines Adams from Clemson a lot but they could trade down to get that guy.

You could see Detroit take Adrian Peterson here as well but I don’t think his pass catching abilities will make him a hot prospect in Martz’s eyes. Coach Marinelli came from the Bucs and knows that to win championships you need to be good in the trenches. Look for Detroit to improve themselves on either side of the ball along the line.
With Foster and Bell in town, and the loss of James Hall, I'm betting on the Lions taking Anderson in the 1st or a guy like Spencer in the 2nd. I'd lean towards Anderson. BUT Detroit may sign D White, which would lower this need.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top