2017 Keeper Thread (1 Viewer)

[rschroeder1]

Thought I would start a thread for people to post their keeper questions for 2017.

I know it's a long ways off, but I find it helpful to get others' input to check my biases and overvaluing from the 2016 season.  Here are my candidates:


League information: 12 teams, 17 roster spots, .5 PPR, QB, 2 RB, 2 WR, TE, RB/WR/TE, K, DEF
Keeper rules: keep up to 4, each keeper costs one round higher than their round the year before. Can keep until they are kept as a first round pick.

Josh Doctson (8th round cost for 2017 draft)
Devonta Freeman (13)
CJ Prosise (14)
CJ Anderson (15)
Thomas Rawls (16)
Donte Moncrief (16)
Tyrell Williams (17)
Hunter Henry (17)

Thank you for your input.

 

[OldTomMesko]

Freeman. Doctson. I love Hunter Henry, especially at that price. Then either Anderson or Moncrief. 

 

[Gally]

I assume the round listed is the cost for next year and not this year's draft round. 

I would keep Freeman, Henry, Moncrief and I would wait on the 4th and choose between Prosise/Rawls/Anderson depending on how training camp/FA/coaches shake out.  

There is no way I keep Doctson at that price since he has shown very little at the NFL level and is still having injury issues. 

 

[Hurl Bruce]

I'm in a keeper league where we are keeping 6 guys.  PPR

Right now, I have more than 6 that I believe are worth keeping.  I am currently looking to make 2 for 1 deals to get to that 6.

My options are:

1. Leveon Bell
   
2. David Johnson
   
3. Julio Jones
   
4. Deandre Hopkins
   
5. Rob Gronkowski
   
6. Keenan Allen
   
7. Jay Ajayi
   
8. Michael Thomas
   

I currently have been offered Amari Cooper for Gronk and Keenan.  I'm thinking of taking that.  That would leave me with 1 choice out of Thomas and Ajayi.

Who should I keep? 

 

[DaBeers]

Kinda long winded but here goes....

10 team, 18 roster spots,  PPR with a minimum 3 keepers but as many as 9 or 10 (if things play out well for a team).   Here's who I am tentatively keeping (final keepers do not need to be locked in stone until mid-August):

Juilo Jones

D. Freeman

Lamar Miller

Dez

Rawls

CJ Anderson

Jamal Charles

The original plan was to keep Mike Evans along with either JJ or Freeman, but a combination of the Falcons guys having really good week 17's and Winston laying an egg means Evans goes into the 2017 draft.

Rawls, CJ, and Chaz are speccative keeps but the better options in the tier they fall in...

My real question is if Lamar Miller is the better choice over Zach Ertz and Jimmy Graham (Dez can be kept regardless).   I can either lock up my TE position or have the RB potential.   

Thoughts?

 

[Snorkelson]

I'm in a keeper league where we are keeping 6 guys.  PPR

Right now, I have more than 6 that I believe are worth keeping.  I am currently looking to make 2 for 1 deals to get to that 6.

My options are:

1. Leveon Bell
   
2. David Johnson
   
3. Julio Jones
   
4. Deandre Hopkins
   
5. Rob Gronkowski
   
6. Keenan Allen
   
7. Jay Ajayi
   
8. Michael Thomas
   

I currently have been offered Amari Cooper for Gronk and Keenan.  I'm thinking of taking that.  That would leave me with 1 choice out of Thomas and Ajayi.

Who should I keep? 

Keep 1-5 and try to sell the other 3 for 1. I would understand if you wanted to trade gronk instead and keep some youth.

Kinda long winded but here goes....

10 team, 18 roster spots,  PPR with a minimum 3 keepers but as many as 9 or 10 (if things play out well for a team).   Here's who I am tentatively keeping (final keepers do not need to be locked in stone until mid-August):

Juilo Jones

D. Freeman

Lamar Miller

Dez

Rawls

CJ Anderson

Jamal Charles

The original plan was to keep Mike Evans along with either JJ or Freeman, but a combination of the Falcons guys having really good week 17's and Winston laying an egg means Evans goes into the 2017 draft.

Rawls, CJ, and Chaz are speccative keeps but the better options in the tier they fall in...

My real question is if Lamar Miller is the better choice over Zach Ertz and Jimmy Graham (Dez can be kept regardless).   I can either lock up my TE position or have the RB potential.   

Thoughts?

So I guess you can keep so many from certain tier, so Evans isn't an option. I'd keep rb potential over the tes. Perhaps swap jc for Ertz if you want a te.