2024 Rookie QB Comparison **UPDATED Through Wk 18** See OP (1 Viewer)

[Joe Schmo]

Week 11:

Rd

Pick

Age

Gms

Comp

Att

Comp%

Yds

TD

Int

Ru ATT

Ru Yds

RR TD

Sack

Yds Lost

Fu

Fu Lost

1​

1​

CHI

Caleb Williams

22​

10​

201​

325​

62%​

2016​

9​

5​

49​

306​

0​

41​

278​

4​

2​

1​

2​

WAS

Jayden Daniels

23​

11​

202​

294​

69%​

2338​

10​

3​

92​

482​

4​

23​

131​

3​

0​

1​

3​

NWE

Drake Maye

22​

7​

127​

190​

67%​

1236​

9​

6​

28​

260​

1​

17​

120​

4​

3​

1​

12​

DEN

Bo Nix

24​

11​

234​

357​

66%​

2275​

14​

6​

63​

295​

5​

18​

147​

1​

0​

These are the four qbs getting a real run in their first year and gotta say they are all fairly comparable at this point based on organizational situation and such. Spencer Rattler had a quick sip of coffee but not enough to throw into the mix at this point and outside of him no other rookie qb has done anything of note. Decent start for this class, imo.


Week 17:

Rd	Pick			Age	Gms	Comp	Att	Comp%	Yds	TD	Int	Ru Att	Ru Yds	RR TD	Sack	Yds Lost	Fu	Fu Lost
1	1	CHI	Caleb Williams	22	16	330	533	61.9%	3393	19	6	78	479	0	67	459	9	5
1	2	WAS	Jayden Daniels	23	16	325	468	69.4%	3530	25	9	144	864	6	43	220	5	0
1	3	NWE	Drake Maye	22	12	225	337	66.8%	2276	15	10	54	421	2	33	220	9	6
1	8	ATL	Michael Penix	24	4	40	67	59.7%	463	1	2	6	6	0	3	12	0	0
1	12	DEN	Bo Nix	24	16	350	538	65.1%	3454	25	12	85	383	4	24	198	2	0
5	150	NOR	Spencer Rattler	23	6	104	186	55.9%	1077	3	5	17	135	0	20	124	5	3

Week 18:

Rd	Pick			Age	Gms	Comp	Att	Comp%	Yds	TD	Int	RuAttt	RuYds	RR TD	Sack	Yds Lost	Fu	Fu Lost
1	1	CHI	Caleb Williams	22	17	351	562	62.5%	3541	20	6	81	489	0	68	466	10	5
1	2	WAS	Jayden Daniels	23	17	331	480	69.0%	3568	25	9	148	891	6	47	238	5	0
1	3	NWE	Drake Maye	22	13	225	338	66.6%	2276	15	10	54	421	2	34	229	9	6
1	8	ATL	Michael Penix	24	5	61	105	58.1%	775	3	3	7	11	1	4	14	2	0
1	12	DEN	Bo Nix	24	17	376	567	66.3%	3775	29	12	92	430	5	24	198	3	0
5	150	NOR	Spencer Rattler	23	7	130	228	57.0%	1317	4	5	18	146	0	22	136	5	3

 

[Gatorade]

Rd	Pick			Age	Gms	Comp	Att	Comp%	Yds	TD	Int	Ru ATT	Ru Yds	Ru TD	Sack	Yds Lost	Fu	Fu Lost
1	12	DEN	Bo Nix	24	11	234	357	66%	2275	14	6	63	295	4	18	147	1	0
1	1	CHI	Caleb Williams	22	10	201	325	62%	2016	9	5	49	306	0	41	278	4	2
1	2	WAS	Jayden Daniels	23	11	202	294	69%	2338	10	3	92	482	4	23	131	3	0
1	3	NWE	Drake Maye	22	7	127	190	67%	1236	9	6	28	260	1	17	120	4	3

These are the four qbs getting a real run in their first year and gotta say they are all fairly comparable at this point based on organizational situation and such. Spencer Rattler had a quick sip of coffee but not enough to throw into the mix at this point and outside of him no other rookie qb has done anything of note. Decent start for this class, imo.

When you add in McCarthy and Penix, this could be one of the best QB classes ever

 

[Joe Schmo]

Rd	Pick			Age	Gms	Comp	Att	Comp%	Yds	TD	Int	Ru ATT	Ru Yds	Ru TD	Sack	Yds Lost	Fu	Fu Lost
1	12	DEN	Bo Nix	24	11	234	357	66%	2275	14	6	63	295	4	18	147	1	0
1	1	CHI	Caleb Williams	22	10	201	325	62%	2016	9	5	49	306	0	41	278	4	2
1	2	WAS	Jayden Daniels	23	11	202	294	69%	2338	10	3	92	482	4	23	131	3	0
1	3	NWE	Drake Maye	22	7	127	190	67%	1236	9	6	28	260	1	17	120	4	3

These are the four qbs getting a real run in their first year and gotta say they are all fairly comparable at this point based on organizational situation and such. Spencer Rattler had a quick sip of coffee but not enough to throw into the mix at this point and outside of him no other rookie qb has done anything of note. Decent start for this class, imo.

When you add in McCarthy and Penix, this could be one of the best QB classes ever

If nothing else it's a back fill for the lousy 2019 and mediocre 2021 drafts. 2020 looks like a golden year for qbs: Burrow, Tagovailoa, Herbert, Love and Hurts.

 

[VikingFrog]

Rd	Pick			Age	Gms	Comp	Att	Comp%	Yds	TD	Int	Ru ATT	Ru Yds	Ru TD	Sack	Yds Lost	Fu	Fu Lost
1	12	DEN	Bo Nix	24	11	234	357	66%	2275	14	6	63	295	4	18	147	1	0
1	1	CHI	Caleb Williams	22	10	201	325	62%	2016	9	5	49	306	0	41	278	4	2
1	2	WAS	Jayden Daniels	23	11	202	294	69%	2338	10	3	92	482	4	23	131	3	0
1	3	NWE	Drake Maye	22	7	127	190	67%	1236	9	6	28	260	1	17	120	4	3

These are the four qbs getting a real run in their first year and gotta say they are all fairly comparable at this point based on organizational situation and such. Spencer Rattler had a quick sip of coffee but not enough to throw into the mix at this point and outside of him no other rookie qb has done anything of note. Decent start for this class, imo.

Hooked on Bo Nix works for me…

Also, as his biggest Sharkpool fan, can we please get recieving stats added to this chart?

 

[Joe Schmo]

Three of the above are on a bye this coming week with only Caleb Williams playing.

 

[Leroy Hoard]

I agree with the rankings other than Caleb/Jayden I would switch.

 

[Joe Schmo]

As of now, Daniels has improved some since week 11 while Nix has taken a small step back, both Williams and Maye are doing ok but treading water at this point. Williams is taking a Ton of sacks for big losses and needs to knock that off or he's gonna be toast a couple of years. O-line issues for sure but he doesn't help himself much either.

 

[Joe Schmo]

As we're coming to the end of the season I added Penix and Rattler for a more complete review of this qb class. Jayden Daniels is the clear front runner at this point, imo. Yesterday's win was a statement game against a division rival with a tough defense and super bowl aspirations. Overall, the class is looking good with solid play by most of the qbs. and offers hope to the teams that drafted them. Should be interesting to watch this class evolve.

 

[Joe Schmo]

Definite tier to this class with Daniels head and shoulders on top followed by Nix who looks very promising then some order of Williams(horrible organization and coaching) and Maye(similar to Williams) who aren't necessarily helping their causes, with Penix TBD and Rattler, well let's just say Rattler doesn't look the part. Still hope for some teams but others(NO) should keep looking, imo.

 

[Gatorade]

Looks like an amazing QB class. Even Penix looked great this weekend. Could be five studs for years to come. Rattler has shown some promise considering his 5th round selection.

 

[Joe Schmo]

Final update for the season. Nix and Daniels are in the post season while the rest lick their wounds. Daniels and Nix are big hits for their franchises while Williams and Maye have promise but need help from their organizations to stabilize the situation, else they end up on the what coulda been pile. I think Penix might be a thing to be honest but obviously he needs more run. Rattler comes across as just a guy, imo.

 

[rockaction]

Good thread. All of it sounds right, although people are higher on Maye’s potential than you seem to be.

 

[Joe Schmo]

With Maye it's the turnovers that give me pause, he's too loose with the ball. It can be corrected but until it is I'm not sold on him being The Guy for NE. A good coach and stable front office can help with that, imo.