8 Team Keeper Question (1 Viewer)

[BDSC]

I play in a 8 team full PPR league. We are allowed to keep one player from last year’s team at the round that player was drafted last year or if the player was initially not drafted, they will count as our 16th round pick. We can only keep a player one year. Here are my choices:

Puka Nacua - 16th
Sam Laporta- 16th
Kyren Williams - 16th
Gibbs - 8th

Thoughts?

 

[Gally]

With only keeping 1 player I just keep the best player. That is Gibbs for me out of this group

 

[pkroper22]

I would go Gibbs, with Puka in a close 2nd. Like Gally said, with one keeper I'm going with the best player regardless of round. IMO, that is Gibbs.

 

[Big Nate]

Third vote for Gibbs. I'm such a big fan and its tough to find a difference maker at the RB position and Gibbs can be that guy.

 

[Pip's Invitation]

There is no wrong answer here. In an 8-team league, just go with the best player, which is Gibbs.

 

[treat88]

I play in a 8 team full PPR league. We are allowed to keep one player from last year’s team at the round that player was drafted last year or if the player was initially not drafted, they will count as our 16th round pick. We can only keep a player one year. Here are my choices:

Puka Nacua - 16th
Sam Laporta- 16th
Kyren Williams - 16th
Gibbs - 8th

Thoughts?

Gibbs in the 8th round seems like the best value to me. The others are all 16th-round keepers, so you're not giving up much. Gibbs has more upside and could be a steal in the 8th round.

 

[BDSC]

Gibbs it is! It was between him and Puka in my mind.

 

[Big Nate]

Gibbs it is! It was between him and Puka in my mind.

Such is the way with only 1 keeper. Tough decisions as Puka is a great player and will have a long career too. I just find it is hard to get a stud difference maker at RB so I lean Gibbs. But Puka would be a nice keeper to have.

 

[loslakes]

I agree with the pack. Gibbs would be my pick, but Puka & Kyren are both very solid options as well.