A Look Back (1 Viewer)

[tytyty]

Evey year I write something like I the following request but it falls on deaf ears most of the time. But haven't been on the forums that much this year so I apologize if this has come to fruition.

I would like to see and am not quite sure why it hasnt been done... A look back at last year. Basically taking the ranking and/or projections from say last week in August 07 and compare and analyze them to the EOY Actual rankings. Now being off on Ronnie Brown because he only played 7 games or whatever doesnt need to be disected.

But how a Romo was so great and how a Sjax wasn't and how Sleepers came to be or Tanks came not to be.

I wouldn't look at this as judging FBG or it's staff but I have always felt there would be a lot to learn and maybe patterns would emerge for the future.

So calling all FBG staffers. Would love to see it on here or an article.

 

[Tom in Albany]

Something like this?

http://forums.footballguys.com/forum/index...howtopic=412456

 

[tytyty]

That is what sparked my annual beg for my post. This is just a loose look at one article. Although it hits some of the topics, I and a lot iof people from what i get are looking for a side by side view of before and after with comments which i dont think is too much to ask. Plus I would like it to come from the guys who do the rankings/projections. From other people it is conjecture. I like to hear an "oh darn thats right i had him ranked too high and this is why" or "i nutted that one when everyone said i was crazy".

when you go to the rankings that have all the fbg guys on it and one guy has brady lets say at #5 and another expert has him at 17, they can really do a good look back at why one was right and one was wrong. brady not specific example.

i think it might have been chase last year that responded and almost threatened to do it but it never happened.

 

[tytyty]

Got to say.. Disappointing