Another keeper question (1 Viewer)

[billmatic]

12 team PPR. We can keep 2 players (1 at no draft cost, 1 costing the round they were drafted at the prior year), and I also have the #1 pick.

After playing out some scenarios with my 2 keeper options and who's going to be available in the draft pool with my #1 pick, I wind up with Justin Jefferson regardless. Then the other 2 come down to a decision between the below 2 pairs of players. I give up my 8th round pick in both cases so it really just comes down to which 2 players I prefer.

AJ Brown & Kyren
or
Gibbs & Puka

 

[Jaruby]

Does it need to be AJ and Kyren, Gibbs and Puka? Why not AJ and Gibbs or Puka Kyren?
What pick would keeping AJ and Puka cost you? That’s who I’d keep and still pick Jefferson.

 

[billmatic]

Essentially it's a 2 keeper league, and the 2 keepers have to be different positions. You can specify one as your 'franchise' player which doesn't cost a draft pick, the other does cost a draft pick.

On my team I have the below players with the listed draft pick cost
JJ (1)
Gibbs (2)
Kyren (8)
Puka (8)

After all the keepers are removed from the pool, AJ Brown will be the BPA

So my choices are

1. Franchise JJ, keep Kyren for an 8th and then draft AJ w/ the #1 pick
2. Franchise GIbbs, keep Puka for an 8th and then draft JJ w/ the #1 pick

So that's how it comes down to a choice between AJ/Kyren or Gibbs/Puka

 

[Big Nate]

Essentially it's a 2 keeper league, and the 2 keepers have to be different positions. You can specify one as your 'franchise' player which doesn't cost a draft pick, the other does cost a draft pick.

On my team I have the below players with the listed draft pick cost
JJ (1)
Gibbs (2)
Kyren (8)
Puka (8)

After all the keepers are removed from the pool, AJ Brown will be the BPA

So my choices are

1. Franchise JJ, keep Kyren for an 8th and then draft AJ w/ the #1 pick
2. Franchise GIbbs, keep Puka for an 8th and then draft JJ w/ the #1 pick

So that's how it comes down to a choice between AJ/Kyren or Gibbs/Puka

I like Gibbs over Kyren and would be very happy with Puka if you can get JJ back with the #1 pick.