Anyone trade for Santonio Holmes before week 5? (1 Viewer)

[Brady Gaga]

 

[Ping Pong]

I just traded Santonio & Tampa Mike for DeSean.

 

[kolejo]

Just picked him up off the waiver wire

 

[shredhead]

Just picked him up off the waiver wire

Me too, Now I can get rid of that under-achieving Bowe....maybe.

 

[Steelers4Life]

14 team dynasty league

I traded Gore, Huggins, and a 2nd rounder that should be in the 20's somewhere for MJD and Santonio

 

[Topes]

14 team dynasty leagueI traded Gore, Huggins, and a 2nd rounder that should be in the 20's somewhere for MJD and Santonio

Ouch!

 

[atcdav]

I just traded Santonio & Tampa Mike for DeSean.

You got Desean? nice trade

 

[DaWidowMaker]

2 weeks ago I traded Cedric Benson for Thomas Jones and Santonio Holmes.

 

[Wheezer34]

In my PPR league yesterday, Holmes was traded for Ryan Torrain

 

[Iwannabeacowboybaby!]

S. Holmes is the best receiver on this team. The Jets are proving they can throw the ball. I look for Holmes to be a solid Wr 2.

 

[TheWick]

RR gave up Kolb, Kevin PHI QB;Holmes, Santonio NYJ WR

TH gave up Manning, Eli NYG QB;Meachem, Robert NOS WR

 

[Brady Gaga]

Who wins in a Shonne Greene for Santonio Holmes trade?

 

[FunkyPlutos]

Traded Steve Smith (NYG) for him in a dynasty in week 1.

 

[FUBAR]

I just offered him for Chris Wells. No response yet.

 

[lyon812]

Traded Bradshaw for Holmes and a 3rd round pick in a salary league. I needed a WR, he needed a RB.

 

[Brady Gaga]

I wouldn't trade Holmes for Beanie (but good luck). I would trade him for Bradshaw.

Was offered Shonn Greene - not sure.

 

[Koya]

I traded Eddie royal and holmes for Calvin Johnson before last weeks games fwiw.

 

[JahVideo_Kilt_Radio_Star]

Might not be fantasy consistent this year, but I think he's going to be a enormous help to the Jets.

 

[JahVideo_Kilt_Radio_Star]

I wouldn't trade Holmes for Beanie (but good luck). I would trade him for Bradshaw.Was offered Shonn Greene - not sure.

Think you're going to regret that Beanie move. And you aren't getting Bradshaw for him (insane to even think that)I love Holmes as part of the future of the Jets (I think he gets retained, not Edwards). Too many mouths to feed this year however.

 

[Brady Gaga]

I wouldn't trade Holmes for Beanie (but good luck). I would trade him for Bradshaw.

Was offered Shonn Greene - not sure.

Think you're going to regret that Beanie move. And you aren't getting Bradshaw for him (insane to even think that)I love Holmes as part of the future of the Jets (I think he gets retained, not Edwards). Too many mouths to feed this year however.

The Beanie/Bradshaw for Holmes trade offers were someone else's. I was just replying.

The trade possibility I was considering was Shonn Greene for Santonio Holmes.

I don't like it.

 

[boojee]

In a 12-team dynasty, I dealt:

Reggie Bush

Devin Hester

Ben Watson

late 2nd

late 4th

for

Fred Taylor

Santonio

Kellen Winslow

mid 3rd

 

[JahVideo_Kilt_Radio_Star]

The Beanie/Bradshaw for Holmes trade offers were someone else's. I was just replying.

The trade possibility I was considering was Shonn Greene for Santonio Holmes.

I don't like it.

Redraft league, I'd probably do it. Upside of Greene is much higher than that of Holmes this year. (I think Holmes is a Top 20 dynasty WR. I just don't believe this year fantasy wise he's going to make much of a consistent impact)Long way to go. LT unquestionably looks better than Greene, but Greene becomes a Top 15 (at worst IMO) if LT goes down. Weather turns cold, I think you're going to see NYJ ground and pound more. (May even see Greene as a worthy flex play with a healthy LT)

 

[Lash]

obtained SHolmes in 4 leagues this offseason which should give a wide range view...

pre-NFL draft (yeah i know been ahwile but you said "before week 5" LOL) ... FJax for SHolmes

Ocho Cinco for SHolmes

2011 1st for SHolmes and a 2010 4th (the 2011 1st should be pick 1.14 1.15 or 1.16)

and drafted him in 6th rd in dyno startup

 

[vonbrocklin]

I traded Holmes for Tolbert immediately after Mathews went down -- to be honest I'm kind of regretting it. Holmes (in theory) would have replaced Crabtree and with Mathews back (in theory) I'd probably be in better shape with Holmes.

 

[The Moz]

Holmes is the #3 receiving option on a run first team with a mediocre QB. He no more than a average WR 3 in a 12 team league. He might get you 2-3 100 yd games and a score but many 2 for 28 games. Edwards is the playmaker and Keller is the redzone guy -- not mention Cotch and LT gettign dump offs. maybe 40 - 500 - 3 is the best you hope for.

 

[FUBAR]

Holmes is the #3 receiving option on a run first team with a mediocre QB. He no more than a average WR 3 in a 12 team league. He might get you 2-3 100 yd games and a score but many 2 for 28 games. Edwards is the playmaker and Keller is the redzone guy -- not mention Cotch and LT gettign dump offs. maybe 40 - 500 - 3 is the best you hope for.

Holmes is a much better WR than Edwards. Keller will get his but Holmes is the deep threat and top WR. I don't disagree too much with the 40 receptions but if that's all he gets he will still have more like 600 yards and 5 TDs. I suspect it will be more like 50/750/5. In 12 games that isn't bad.

 

[cr8f]

I drafted him late.

 

[LionBastards]

I gave B Jackson and Clayton for him. I think it was after just before or just after week 3 games. I wasn't sold on Clayton yet...hope I don't regret it. I was thinking Holmes would be a WR2...he's definitely worth more than Braylon.

 

[PeterSam]

Holmes is the #3 receiving option on a run first team with a mediocre QB. He no more than a average WR 3 in a 12 team league. He might get you 2-3 100 yd games and a score but many 2 for 28 games. Edwards is the playmaker and Keller is the redzone guy -- not mention Cotch and LT gettign dump offs. maybe 40 - 500 - 3 is the best you hope for.

Agreed. Edwards' drops are far more dazzling than Holmes acrobatic catches (see Superbowl, game-winning).

 

[Interception Irwin]

I think if you can get Wells for Holmes, that's a hell of a good deal. He is very undervalued lately.

I own both players, for what it's worth.