Best QB's in their first 9 years? (1 Viewer)

[B-Deep]

Do people just not know about our Historical Data Dominator? It only goes back to 1960 . . .

Passing Yards through 9 years:

1 Peyton Manning qb 1998--2006 37586

2 Dan Marino qb 1983--1991 35386

3 Brett Favre qb 1991--1999 30894

4 Warren Moon qb 1984--1992 30200

5 Drew Bledsoe qb 1993--2001 29657

6 Jim Kelly qb 1986--1994 29527

7 John Elway qb 1983--1991 27974

8 Jim Everett qb 1986--1994 27613

9 Jake Plummer qb 1997--2005 27259

10 Kerry Collins qb 1995--2003 26381

11 Troy Aikman qb 1989--1997 26016

12 Boomer Esiason qb 1984--1992 25671

13 Trent Green qb 1997--2005 25621

14 Mark Brunell qb 1994--2002 25309

15 Joe Montana qb 1979--1987 24552

16 Ken O'Brien qb 1984--1992 24386

17 Dan Fouts qb 1973--1981 24256

18 Jeff George qb 1990--1998 23229

19 Fran Tarkenton qb 1961--1969 23140

20 Neil Lomax qb 1981--1988 22771

Passing TD through 9 years:

1 Peyton Manning qb 1998--2006 275

2 Dan Marino qb 1983--1991 266

3 Brett Favre qb 1991--1999 235

4 Jim Kelly qb 1986--1994 201

5 Fran Tarkenton qb 1961--1969 186

6 Warren Moon qb 1984--1992 175

7 Boomer Esiason qb 1984--1992 174

8 Joe Montana qb 1979--1987 172

9 Drew Bledsoe qb 1993--2001 166

10 John Hadl qb 1962--1970 165

11 Jim Everett qb 1986--1994 164

12 Donovan McNabb qb 1999--2006 152

13 Trent Green qb 1997--2005 150

13 Jake Plummer qb 1997--2005 150

15 John Elway qb 1983--1991 148

15 Dave Krieg qb 1980--1988 148

17 Tom Brady qb 2000--2006 147

18 Dan Fouts qb 1973--1981 145

19 Daryle Lamonica qb 1963--1971 143

20 Mark Brunell qb 1994--2002 142

20 Norm Snead qb 1961--1969 142

HDD is so cool.FOR EXAMPLE, I just discovered if you list receiving yards, by season, and look at the top 100 seasons turned in, not one of them happened in the 1970s

THAT is strange

 

[mtffl2]

Even worse is actually coming here and saying "lol, I really don't know anything about this and now I'm trying to save face. Someone else, please argue for me because I'm unable to."

you've got to be kidding... it's not like i have my first born child riding on this answer! i've never claimed to be an expert on the history of the NFL and the records and stats of all the players. i posted it here because i knew the FBG's would know the answer without me having to spend hours upon hours searching for the data. i knew that someone had already done the research and that's why i asked. Marek, i guess you go by the old saying, "Work Harder, not Smarter"it's just a friendly banter back and forth, he says my team sucks and i say his team sucks (even if we really don't feel that way).

 

[stevegamer]

You'll score more points if you say "Peyton has the most yards & TD's but that doesn't really compare well across era or take into accounts things like winning titles, although he has one."

Go deep into history and you might impress him as well as ragging on him.

 

[David Yudkin]

HDD is so cool.FOR EXAMPLE, I just discovered if you list receiving yards, by season, and look at the top 100 seasons turned in, not one of them happened in the 1970sTHAT is strange

But easily explanable. They only played 14 games a year through 1977 (and even fewer in the 60s). And they ran the ball way more than they did today.For example . . .In today's game, we would not be surprised to see a player have a season with 96 receptions, 1236 reciving yards, and 4 receiving TDs. Fantasy wise, that would not have been a Top 15 season for a WR in 2006.HOWEVER . . .In 1973, those totals were what the BUFFALO BILLS put up AS A TEAM. They had over 3,000 yards RUSHING that year.

 

[Grigs Allmoon]

You'll score more points if you say "Peyton has the most yards & TD's but that doesn't really compare well across era or take into accounts things like winning titles, although he has one."Go deep into history and you might impress him as well as ragging on him.

Nah, then you'll just look like you are making excuses.I don't mind your razzing of him, by putting doubt in his mind. Just be sure to eventually say "Yeah, you were right."

 

[salmonstud]

For what it's worth...Marino might have completed more commericials than Manning. Manning has been on a tear the last few years....but Marino did a ton of glove commericals for years....he could have the edge.

 

[BigRed]

what about Don Hutson... was he any good?

In fact, arguably the best ever. WR that is.lol @ how much genuflecting people are doing to Manning now that "he" has won a SB, when many of the same people were much more down on him because of no SB ring. Funny how a defense playing well makes a QB so much better

 

[Despyzer]

For what it's worth...Marino might have completed more commericials than Manning. Manning has been on a tear the last few years....but Marino did a ton of glove commericals for years....he could have the edge.

here we go...Marino v. Manning ... part 32

 

[salmonstud]

Favre (What About Mary) & Marino (Ace Ventura) have Manning edged in major motion picture appearances as well....although it was past 9 years in the league for Marino. Lay that info on your boss....he will have to agree than Manning is not the best.

 

[BGP]

Good as in what?

Totals? Per game basis? Playoffs?