Chaos Commish
Footballguy
Link]
9. Patrick Willis, LB, SF
17. Paul Posluzney, LB, Buf
23. Jon Beason, LB, Car
26. LaRon Landry, S, Was
31. David Harris, LB, NYJ
33. Buster Davis, LB, Ari
34. Anthony Waters, LB, SD
39. Anthony Spencer, LB, Dal
40. Lawrence Timmons, LB, Pit
45. Gaines Adams, DE, TB
47. Aaron Rouse, S (possible LB)), GB
48. Sabby Piscatelli, S, TB
49. Stephen Nicholas, LB, Atl
Rouse went to Green Bay, Sig (just a heads up on a typo). Not that that should change your ranking, which is probably too high. I thought that tier of IDPs starting with Spencer started too soon. There's some offensive talent still lingering with much higher value even though I am keyed in on building a little IDP youth. What a crappy class and unfortunate timing for me.
I'd give long odds against your Spencer prediction, but nevermind him. I so hope you are right. Believe me, bro, I hope I got this kid who could never get ahead of Rob Ninkovich wrong. Spencer was sorry as a Junior, fortunate as a Senior, never better than Edwards or Ninkovich.
I watched a ton of Nicholas over the past couple years and he can play anywhere. I know the standard view had him at SLB, but he and St. Louis just played sides, no true weak and strong, more like left and right. Nicholas was a great weakside player and is cut out for the role. He won't have Demorrio's closing ability and I think the tackle numbers would come down a little, but the rest of his game is solid. He'll shine where Demorrio faultered and I think he could be moved up a good 20 spots based on situation and talent. Situation is really key to his value.
I'm curious. What makes Beason less ideal for MLB than Puz? Both have played both at high levels. I am still very impressed with Mayock's breakdown of Beason, and most of the big plays in those clips had Beason coming from the middle. I think he is better off personally in the middle. I don't know if that makes him better than Puz there, but it works for him. I have seen enough to be confident in that.
We see Timmons and Adams the same, and I like Sabby maybe a little more than you, but I still think I would have this class of IDPs downgraded as a group by a full tier.
Thanks Sig! Like all your adoring fans I have been seeking this.
Between you and Jene I feel more confident about the rookie a draft this weekend.
9. Patrick Willis, LB, SF
17. Paul Posluzney, LB, Buf
23. Jon Beason, LB, Car
26. LaRon Landry, S, Was
31. David Harris, LB, NYJ
33. Buster Davis, LB, Ari
34. Anthony Waters, LB, SD
39. Anthony Spencer, LB, Dal
40. Lawrence Timmons, LB, Pit
45. Gaines Adams, DE, TB
47. Aaron Rouse, S (possible LB)), GB
48. Sabby Piscatelli, S, TB
49. Stephen Nicholas, LB, Atl
Rouse went to Green Bay, Sig (just a heads up on a typo). Not that that should change your ranking, which is probably too high. I thought that tier of IDPs starting with Spencer started too soon. There's some offensive talent still lingering with much higher value even though I am keyed in on building a little IDP youth. What a crappy class and unfortunate timing for me.
I'd give long odds against your Spencer prediction, but nevermind him. I so hope you are right. Believe me, bro, I hope I got this kid who could never get ahead of Rob Ninkovich wrong. Spencer was sorry as a Junior, fortunate as a Senior, never better than Edwards or Ninkovich.
I watched a ton of Nicholas over the past couple years and he can play anywhere. I know the standard view had him at SLB, but he and St. Louis just played sides, no true weak and strong, more like left and right. Nicholas was a great weakside player and is cut out for the role. He won't have Demorrio's closing ability and I think the tackle numbers would come down a little, but the rest of his game is solid. He'll shine where Demorrio faultered and I think he could be moved up a good 20 spots based on situation and talent. Situation is really key to his value.
I'm curious. What makes Beason less ideal for MLB than Puz? Both have played both at high levels. I am still very impressed with Mayock's breakdown of Beason, and most of the big plays in those clips had Beason coming from the middle. I think he is better off personally in the middle. I don't know if that makes him better than Puz there, but it works for him. I have seen enough to be confident in that.
We see Timmons and Adams the same, and I like Sabby maybe a little more than you, but I still think I would have this class of IDPs downgraded as a group by a full tier.
Thanks Sig! Like all your adoring fans I have been seeking this.
Between you and Jene I feel more confident about the rookie a draft this weekend.
I am coming around to Nicholas seizing that WLB role and running with it - I was probably too muted in my optimism there.Puz looks more natural to me going sideline to sideline and I think he still has athleticism to regain. Beason is "topped out" in a sense - he's an overachiever who can't get any bigger or faster. I probably underrated that tier from the insane WR in the 3rd, you've got a good point there. any IDPs not in the top 50 that you think should have made the cut?
But after that Tom Casale and some boys from a hard core gambling forum both posted some very VERY VERY negative stuff. I think Maurile will confirm Waters has his work cut out for him. SD has some real good inside guys emerging. When Casale goes that negative (over the past three years anyway), he always nails it. I have never read a more scalding review than his and he tried to destroy Darnell Bing last year.
