C. Coleman or Ty. Williams Dynasty Value (1 Viewer)

[Arodin]

Owned Williams last season and loved the unexpected production, but concerned about the addition of Mike.  Coleman has been a disappointment and isn't off to a great start this offseason either, but is he still, as a former 1st round selection, worth more than Tyrell?

Looking at an offer to move Tyrell for Coleman...the other pieces of the deal are fairly balanced, so thsi question is what it comes down to.

 

[Snorkelson]

I like Coleman by a long shot (or at least a decent amount). Don't get scared off by an early June hammy injury. Early in the year he looked great before he got hurt, tyrell benefited from a myriad of injuries, that perfect storm is unlikely this year, and they've added Williams to further cloud up the target distribution. 

 

[travdogg]

I'd say Coleman and it isn't even remotely close. I might have Coleman 30-40 spots higher at WR.

Williams is a must sell in my opinion, I think its very possible he ends up 5th or 6th or the Chargers in receiving. He had everything come together for him last year, and while the stats look nice, they are misleading. He was the target for roughly half of Rivers career high INTs, Rivers was constantly making "Rivers face" at him, and that makes me very nervous. Allen is back, Benjamin is healthy, Henry is likely to breakout, Gates is still there. I could see all 4 of them outproducing Tyrell, and that's before factoring in Mike Williams. I'd probably slot Tyrell ahead of Benjamin, but that is no lock, as Benjamin gives an entirely different aspect to the offense, and they were clearly very high on him, he was just never 100% last year.

 

[slicedbred21]

I agree Coleman by quite a margin. Tyrel had the best situation he could ask for and did do pretty well with it but I am banking on Coleman with his upside/ceiling. 

 

[Gally]

Chock me up for another Coleman by a landslide guy.  He will be a focal point and Williams is in a very crowded place.  He may put up the occasional huge game but you will never know when it is coming and he will be frustrating to own.  I would much rather have the guy that will be a focal point.  Give me Coleman.

 

[heckmanm]

Have to agree with the above.  I own Williams in a salary cap league, and I'll keep him since I have him fairly cheap, but there are a lot more mouths to feed in that offense than in Cleveland.  Coleman looks to be the clear #1 target there.