Chubba for Kamara/CMC Keeper Trade (2 Viewers)

[abosweiler]

PPR, 10-team, 2-FLEX, 1-keeper league. I am currently T-2 @ 7-3 with a strong team to make a playoff run. There are two teams guaranteed to not make the playoffs, neither of which have a decent keeper for the 2025 season. I have keeper options, and want to trade away Chubba (8th rounder in 2025) for a potential upgrade for the playoff run. My first option would be to get CMC from a team, but doubt that will happen. But realistically, may have to try and get Kamara from the other owner. If I cannot get CMC, is Kamara an upgrade over Chubba for the playoff run?

Playoff defenses (Rank vs. RB)
Chubba: Dal(28), ARI(15), @TB(32)
Kamara: WASH(11), @GB(15), LV(26)

Current roster
QB: Daniels
RB: DHenry, Walker, CBrown, Chubba, Dowdle, Brooks
WR: Chase, GWil, Scary Terry, DK, Leggette
TE: NJoku, Pitts

Thanks, and WHIR!

 

[Jaruby]

I’d rather have Kamara but don’t give up to get him. Your team looks nice as is.

 

[Ray_T]

Kamara is by far the better receiver. so when the game script flips he can still put up good numbers receiving. for that reason I prefer Kamara (at least for this year) but this is a keeper league and due to age, Chubba is young and Kamara is not. so in a keeper format Chubbas youth makes him more valueable as a keeper in the long run. for that reason I'd need him to throw in more if trading Chubba away for Kamara. only exception is if you think you can win the championship now, you throw caution to the wind and make the deal.

 

[Jaruby]

I don’t care if this is a keeper league and I am deciding between Kamara and Hubbard. I would not make this trade. Hubbard is good but he is splitting time placeholder. Next year he is going to lose carries to Brown. Next year Kamara will still be the man until he gets injured. If he doesn’t get injured, he’s a much better back than Hubbard.