CMC offer (1 Viewer)

[Brooklyn70]

I received a trade offer of

Give: Christian McCaffrey 

Receive: 2018 1st,C.Coleman, M. Mack and W. Gallman

12 team 

Rbs: P. Perkins,  S. Vereen, Ty Montgomery,  A. Jones,  Jerick McKinnon, K. Hunt,  C, McCaffrey.

Wrs: AROB,  S.Watkins, J. Brown,  D. Funchess, N. Agohlor, R. Switzer, C .Godwin, R. Woods, Ardarius Stewart,  P. Dorsett.

Thoughts on trade offer.

 

[travdogg]

I don't think that is enough for McCaffrey. I don't thin much of Mack or Gallman at all. I'd be surprised if they were ever valuable. I value Coleman a bit, but mostly as a WR3 with upside, and you have no idea where that 1st rounder will fall, if its #1 overall than yes, this would probably be a good deal, but if its mid to late, you are basically giving CMC away. I think McCaffery can be a solid RB1, possibly as soon as this year. 

 

[fightingillini]

Not knowing how high the 2018 1st will be....pretty much kills it for me.  Coleman has upside, but his ceiling appears to be maybe a weak WR2.  Mack and Gallman are just throw ins, and you going to have to find space to roster them.   So you're selling a likely solid starting RB for a raw WR without a huge ceiling, two worthless players and a lottery ticket that you don't know the value at this time.  Not enough to give up McCaffrey.

Pass on that deal.

 

[msudaisy26]

It is a fair offer to just depends on roster space and who you like the most. All things being equal though I would probably do the deal if I thought the other team would miss the playoffs.

 

[Dope]

It is a fair offer to just depends on roster space and who you like the most. All things being equal though I would probably do the deal if I thought the other team would miss the playoffs.

Agreed, for one player, you could possibly get four 2018 starers if things break right. It's not that far fetched, that Gallman and/or Mack are starters in 2018.

 

[Gally]

I don't do that deal.  I value McCaffrey much higher.  If you knew the 2018 pick would be a top 3 pick then I would be more tempted but without knowing that I would rather have McCaffrey.