CMC Trade Offer!!! (1 Viewer)

[Wangster]

12 team 0.5PPR, start 2RB/2WR/Flex, can keep 2 players each year.

CMC owner is 0-4 (shocker) and has offered him to me as I am the Jordan Mason owner. His original ask is DK and B Robinson Jr. and thats a hard NO from me. But what is a fair trade? I was thinking Pickens and Mostert, but not sure that gets it done. Thoughts?

My team:

QB - Lamar
RB - Kyren, Mason, Robinson Jr, Mostert, Allen
WR - Jefferson, St. Brown, Metcalf, Pickens, Brian Thomas
TE - McBride

 

[Gally]

I would offer up PIckens but would do Metcalf if pressed.

You have the depth to absorb the Metcalf loss for the upside of CMC.

 

[Jaruby]

It is fair. Not sure I’d do it but the question was fair and I believe it is. Like Galley said I’d try for someone else. I like the massive ceiling Metcalf brings but I hate his freaking low floor.

 

[packer_junkie]

No way I would trade Metcalf for CMC

Redraft-- too much for nabors??

I'd give Fields, Dobbins, Shakir Get Nabors Smash accept right? I currently don't have a backup qb on my team and would need to make a move but some guys like Love/Goff/Murray are backups and I have some WR depth to spare (Jefferson, Nabors, Wilson, Puka, Moore, Flowers, Dell) Start QB RB RB...

forums.footballguys.com

 

[LakeCowboy]

I'd absolutely do the deal, if CMC comes back you'll be a heavy favorite to win the league. If CMC looks normal you can keep Justin Jefferson and then have a split decision between CMC and ASB.

 

[Here's Johnny]

I read a lot of conflicting reports about CMC. I think if/when he does come back, Mason will have a roll which will devalue CMC. Mason is an RB1 for the next few weeks so he has a lot of value. I own Mason and wouldn't even think about trading him for Pickens and Mostert.

 

[MrJoshua*]

I would offer up PIckens but would do Metcalf if pressed.

You have the depth to absorb the Metcalf loss for the upside of CMC.

Sorry, no way I'm giving Metcalf

 

[Gally]

I would offer up PIckens but would do Metcalf if pressed.

You have the depth to absorb the Metcalf loss for the upside of CMC.

Sorry, no way I'm giving Metcalf

He can play at most 3 WR's and already has JJ & ARSB. That means he can only play one of Metcalf, Pickens and Thomas. The fall off from Metcalf to the other two is pretty minor to lock up SF backfield. He also has Robinson Jr & Mostert who could also fill in for the flex spot and he only plays 2 WR's.

While Metcalf for an unknown in CMC typically isn't something I would do, given the roster and starting requirements it's a risk I would take.