Do I trade Miller and John Brown for Jordy? (1 Viewer)

[Nate Cousineau]

12 team PPR. I have a trade on the table that I just can't decide on...

In the trade I give Lamar Miller and John Brown and I get Jordy Nelson back. I am getting worried about Miller. The volume is there, but he simply hasn't looked all that explosive and doesn't seem to be making big plays (now rumors of offseason weight gain are circling). Love Jordy, but don't love that he will face Seattle and Minnesota in the playoffs. I feel as though I have enough depth and lottery tickets at the RB position to add a potential top 5 wr... HELP!

Current Roster:

QB Brees
WR Robinson
WR Maclin
WR Shepard
RB Miller
RB McKinnon
TE Reed
FLEX Dwayne Washington
 

BENCH Charles
BENCH K. Dixon
BENCH DeAndre Washington
BENCH M. Thomas
BENCH John Brown
BENCH Hunter Henry

 

[jungchen]

I assume this is a re-draft league? If it´s not, this question shouldn´t have been asked.

If it´s a re-draft league, you should start considering J. Brown as dead weight as he´s losing more and more opportunities to Jaron Brown. If you can get the other guy to throw in another dart at RB (or have someone on waivers that you like), I would do the trade.

Care about winning now and worry about your playoff schedule later. Even during playoffs A-Rod has to throw to somebody.

And btw: both Miller and Brown´s week 4 matchups are terrible!!!

 

[Gally]

I would rather keep Miller because I have no faith in Charles coming back to form and all the other guys are flex at best.  Your WR's are fine and much better than your RB depth.  I stay put.

 

[Nate Cousineau]

I assume this is a re-draft league? If it´s not, this question shouldn´t have been asked.

If it´s a re-draft league, you should start considering J. Brown as dead weight as he´s losing more and more opportunities to Jaron Brown. If you can get the other guy to throw in another dart at RB (or have someone on waivers that you like), I would do the trade.

Care about winning now and worry about your playoff schedule later. Even during playoffs A-Rod has to throw to somebody.

And btw: both Miller and Brown´s week 4 matchups are terrible!!!

Yes, it is re-draft.

 

[Nate Cousineau]

I would rather keep Miller because I have no faith in Charles coming back to form and all the other guys are flex at best.  Your WR's are fine and much better than your RB depth.  I stay put.

I don't have a ton of faith in Charles either, but I think he is a viable RB2 with RB1 upside. Ware has been underwhelming since week 1 and I personally think McKinnon, Dwayne Washington, and eventually Dixon are (McKinnon) or have the potential (Washington and Dixon) the potential to be more than flex. 

 

[Nate Cousineau]

The other owner is also including Derrick Henry.

 

[jungchen]

go for it