http://subscribers.footballguys.com/2006/0..._rearviewqb.php
One guy to downgrade is Drew Bledsoe. He ranked 6th in standard scoring leagues, based in large part on his ability to play 16 games. But based on FP/AdjG he ranked just 17th, and his schedule was pretty easy too [he ranked 20th after adjusting for SOS]. In reality, he just wasn't a very good fantasy QB last year, but he stayed healthy and didn't have a hard schedule, so he produced good numbers. The addition of Terrell Owens assures that Bledsoe's ADP will remain high, but buyer beware.
I had not looked into Bledose this deeply. I just knew that something didn't
"feel" right about him. Those infamous gut feelings dontcha' know.
While I
still think Bledsoe is going to produce, I am somewhat reassured by the above in passing on him in my drafts, due to how high he was going. I just didn't feel comfortable spending the draft pick necessary to get him. Thought there was better value in other skill positions and could likely get relatively equal QB production / value, a couple of rounds later.
Be interesting to see how he ends up doing.
I believe that a player's rank in adjusted fantasy points per adjusted game is more predictive of his fantasy performance the following year than anything else. It's better than a FP rank, better than a FP/G rank, and way better than any other non-fantasy metric (like team wins or QB rating).In other words, I'd start my ranking of Bledsoe at QB20. Then I'd probably drop him slightly because of age. Then I'd bump him up significantly because of TO. Then I'd drop him down a touch because of the concussions and Romo factor. He'd probably end up at around QB16 on my list.
But anyone using a baseline of QB6 instead of a baseline of QB19 (I'd remove Josh McCown from the list; Aaron Brooks, Drew Brees and Kerry Collins all rank ahead of Bledsoe, but obviously Phillip Rivers isn't on the list...so I'd still probably begin with a baseline where the NO QB, SD QB and OAK QB rank ahead of the DAL QB) is going to be wrong more often than not.
A simple example is Steve McNair. Both players had slightly easier than average SOS. And while in standard leagues Bledsoe ranked 6th and McNair ranked 15th, Bledsoe ranked 17th in FP/AdjG and McNair ranked 15th. McNair averaged 17.6 FP in 13.1 adjusted games; Bledsoe scored 17.2 FP in 16 adjusted games.
If you want to move Bledsoe past McNair because McNair's injury prone, that's fine. But it's important to recognize -- and thus keep Bledsoe's projections in check -- that he wasn't very good when he was on the field last year. In fact, he was below average.
(Note: This is all about setting a baseline, and has nothing to do with TO. If you think TO is going to make QB20 into QB4, then I've got no problem with that -- at least on my current argument. But if you think TO is going to make QB6 into QB4 and now you have Bledsoe as QB4, that's where I think you're making a big mistake.)