Dynasty: Fournette/Bradford for Cook/Winston? (1 Viewer)

[doog7642]

I'm 3-1 with a competitive team, but I'm wondering if the long-term upside of this move makes it worth the short-term hurt. I think in a .5 ppr, which this league is, Cook could have a ton of upside, and the QB upgrade is obvious (though both would be backups). But perhaps I'm underselling the difference a currently healthy Fournette makes for me in a year where I am contending.

Roster:

QB: R. Wilson, Bradford, Garrapolo

RB: D. Johnson, Fournette, McCaffrey, Woodhead, Burkhead

WR: Nelson, Hogan, Thielen, Kupp, Edelman

TE: Graham, Everett

K: Gostkowski

D: Seattle

Scoring

QB: 1/12 passing yards, 3/PTD, -2/ INT

RB: 1/7.5 rushing, .5 PPR, 6/TD

REC: 1/10 rec, .5 PPR, 6/TD

 

[doog7642]

Bump.

 

[Gally]

I don't think I mess with this deal.  You don't need Winston even though he is a decent upgrade over Bradford but you really take a hit this year when it is shaping up to be solid with a 3-1 record. 

Plus you have no idea whether or not Cook comes back to pre-injury form.  It seems like everyone does these days but he had a major knee injury.  There are no guarantees he comes back to normal. 

Stick with Fournette.  You are set up nicely for this year and beyond at the RB spot without this move.  Don't overthink things.