Dynasty - IDP on IR (1 Viewer)

[stevegamer]

I was realizing after reading the M.A.S.H Report that there are a fair number of guys who are either out for the year or could be out that long, and that it might be a good idea to have a place to discuss those players. Admittedly, I've got some of these guys on a roster.

I will try and keep this - the thread's first post - updated with guys who are on IR or are expected out for a while, and I think are relevant. If I missed anybody, feel free to toss them into the discussion. I will put my thoughts int he second post.

DE DET James HallDT SEA Marcus TubbsDT HOU Seth PayneDE PHI Javon KearseDE ATL Pat KerneyDE TBB Simeon RiceDE ARZ Bert BerryLB MIN Chad GreenwayLB CHI Jamir WilliamsLB JAX Mike PetersonLB NYG Lavar ArringtonLB CAR Dan MorganLB DAL Greg EllisSF NOS Roman HarperSF IND Mike DossSF CHI Mike BrownCB CLV Gary BaxterCB TBB Brian KellyGuys who are out indefinitely but I don't think are on IRE NYG Osi Umeniyora

DE NYG Michael Strahan

DE ATL John Abraham

 

[stevegamer]

In general I'd drop these guys into the following categories:

Young guys with potential - hang on to them:

DT SEA Marcus Tubbs

SF NOS Roman Harper

LB MIN Chad Greenway

LB CHI Jamir Williams

Studs - keep these guys on the roster.

LB JAX Mike Peterson

DE DET James Hall

SF CHI Mike Brown

Should not be rostered in most leagues, and I don't know why guys are keeping them on IR:

SF IND Mike Doss

LB NYG Lavar Arrington

Useful or better if you break out their positions:

CB CLV Gary Baxter - injury prone in Cleveland

CB TBB Brian Kelly - probably worth holding

DT HOU Seth Payne - old and likely on last legs

Others:

LB DAL Greg Ellis - I am not sure he can come back and be productive, he's a tweener.

LB CAR Dan Morgan - Injured always, may be forced to retire.

DE PHI Javon Kearse - He's been disappointing the last few years, but he does get sacks.

DE ARZ Bert Berry - Injured 2 years in a row, now may be time to cut bait.

DE ATL Pat Kerney - Odd situation with Abraham also hurt.

Guys who are out indefinitely but I don't think are on IR:

DE NYG Osi Umeniyora - Stud when healthy, but Kiwanuka is now there.

DE NYG Michael Strahan - Stud when healthy, but Kiwanuka is now there.

DE ATL John Abraham - Don't know if he's actually going to make it back this season either.

 

[Birdie048]

There is some pressure to have Dan Morgan retire since he suffered a pretty serious concussion. There was talk that he could be forced to retire medically if he has 1 more hard hit.

Mike Peterson is 30 yo and they have several suitable replacements. Peterson is a stud, but he is in a cautious situation with his injury. How Jax treats their injured players will help define this situation, but I don't know what to expect.

 

[Serenity Now]

DE Pat Kerney is also out for the year, right?

 

[ConstruxBoy]

Maybe add Jamir Williams CHI LB to the young potential list?

 

[One Trick Pony]

Maybe add Jamir Williams CHI LB to the young potential list?

And Chad Greenway.

 

[stevegamer]

Updated the first 2 posts.

I think the ATL & NYG situations are the most interesting.

Anyone think the Eagles won't be bringing Kearse back?