David Yudkin
Footballguy
I realize this is an Owens thread, but I am VERY leary of Moss, as his stock is on the rise with comments and reports coming out of camp that he is doing well. IMO, what is happening is the Niners and the media that cover the team are bending over backwards to praise Moss because ANY criticism of him stands a very high chance of turning Moss into a sour #### again. I saw first hand how poorly things ended in NE, and the Niners are doing everyting in their power to keep Moss happy. So I think the praise and adulation coming his way is more a ploy to keep him motivated and interested in football than it is a bonafide testament to his skill set.I have heard some others suggest the same thing, that Moss will be into it for now, but any signs of adversity, not getting the ball enough, any complaints about his effort level, etc. will become a problem and by the end of the season he could end up being benched like he was to end 2010. I hope that Moss does well and can effectively turn the switch back on, but I have some doubts.As far as either Moss or Owens go, I agree that they have done things that other players have not done . . . and that could be the case again. But to what level is another question. Most WR in their mid to late 30s DON'T take a year off and come back, so the fact that they are even in the league now is more than other receivers in their age bracket have been able to do. Remember that 32 teams based on these guys and only now is there 1 team that went out on a limb and signed them. No one was beating the door down to sign them . . . which should tell us something.Again, there are worse lottery tickets out there for what it takes to draft either of them, so there is not much downside in rostering them, but I have seen some folks licking their chops looking for Moss or Owens numbers from 4 years ago or throwing out some Jerry Rice stat lines. I would say there is a chance they could do that, but in the main I would temper my projections on either of them.The reason I was higher on the former Ocho Cinco is it seems like there are so few other receiving options in MIA that he stands a decent chance to be their top receiver. I don't know if that is a vote in confidence in Ocho or a lack of confidence in the other receivers.Generally speaking, I think everyone shys away from guys with all of these question marks. But we're talking about 2 of the greatest WRs of all time. These guys can be exceptions to the rule as they have been for most of their careers. I'm late getting into my rankings but I think I have a better feeling about TO and Moss than I do Chad. After you get to WR35 or so there arent a lot of names out there that excite me and some of us will start to consider rolling the dice on a TO or Moss.I generally shy away from old receivers that missed a year that are coming off of major knee surgery and are a head case. But maybe that's just me. I would say the same thing about Moss, except he at least he did not have major knee surgery. I would be really, really surprised if either of these two were a fantasy factor this season. Chad Johnson is slightly younger, did not take a year off, and has at least practiced throughout. I think he will have the best (but still not great) season of these three. The fact that none of them has a top QB won't help any.
Last edited by a moderator: