What's new
Fantasy Football - Footballguys Forums

This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Ford Frick Award Nominees Announced (1 Viewer)

Eephus

Footballguy
For the second consecutive year, baseball fans voted overwhelmingly for Joe Nuxhall to be on the ballot for the Ford C. Frick Award for broadcasting excellence that was announced Monday by the National Baseball Hall of Fame. Nuxhall and two longtime Canadian broadcasters, Jacques Doucet and Tom Cheek, were the fans' choices for the ballot. Nuxhall, a fixture with the Cincinnati Reds for 53 years as a pitcher and announcer before his death on Nov. 15, 2007, received 19,547 votes from the record total of 145,138 votes cast in the fans' election. Doucet, who spent his entire 34-year career with the Montreal Expos as the play-by-play radio voice on their French language network, received 10,282 votes. Cheek, who died during the 2005 season, his 28th as the Toronto Blue Jays' radio play-by-play man, got 8,992 votes. The other seven candidates nominated by the Frick Award Committee include a Hall of Fame pitcher, Dizzy Dean, who worked Cardinals and Browns games in St. Louis as well as the national "Game of the Week" in the 1950s and '60s. Tony Kubek, also a former player who did "Game of the Week" telecasts in the 1960s and '70s and later worked in the booth for the Blue Jays and New York Yankees, also made the cut. The other nominees are former play-by-play voices Ken Coleman (Cleveland Indians, Cincinnati Reds, Boston Red Sox), Lanny Frattare (Pittsburgh Pirates) and Dave Van Horne (Montreal Expos, Florida Marlins); Spanish radio and TV announcer Billy Berroa (New York Mets) and broadcasting legend Graham McNamee (Westinghouse, NBC), who called 12 World Series beginning in 1923.
Without any quantitative measure other than years on the air, the award is hard to handicap. It probably ends up being a popularity contest among the voting committee. Even that is flawed because of the mixed bag of nominees (French, Spanish, guys from the 1920s). I wonder if any voters have even heard all the nominees.I suppose it's nice recognition for the winner and the nominees but the Hall giving some guy a lifetime achievement award doesn't accomplish much in the grand scheme of things. My vote would go to the Montreal guy because I used to like the SportsCenter highlights where the only understandable words were "lar-REE wokk-rrr"
 
I know I'm biased because he did Yankee games as I was growing up, but Tony Kubek was an outrageously good broadcaster.

 
I know I'm biased because he did Yankee games as I was growing up, but Tony Kubek was an outrageously good broadcaster.
From listening to him on the Game of the Week for years, I'm afraid you're wrong.
Kubek always struck me as competent but not one of the greats. He was one of the pioneers of TV color commentary, where he helped define the sidekick role. The two or three man TV booth is taken for granted nowadays but Kubek was one of the first ex-jocks to focus exclusively on giving his on-the-field experiences to a broadcast partner and his audience.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top