Gibson/Cooper for Barkley + (1 Viewer)

[vanswey]

12-team half PPR Dynasty

I’m wondering if I should trade Gibson and Cooper for Barkley, 1:09, 3:06, 3:11, and 5:09? Here is my starting lineup.

QB: Wilson

RB: Gibson

RB: Montgomery 

WR: Diggs

WR: Amari Cooper

WR: Cooks

TE: Kelce

WRT: Elliott

WRT: Shenault

2022 Picks

1:01, 1:04, 2:03, 3:01, 4:03, 5:10

 

[Gally]

This all boils down to how feel about Barkley.  If you think he isn't done and can get back to pre injury form than I think you do it.  If you think he is a shell of his former self and it isn't likely he bounces back then I hold.

I am not a fan of Cooper so he doesn't really interest me and the picks are a bunch of blah.  It really just comes down to Gibson vs Saquon for me.........and both have a lot of warts.  

For me I just keep Gibson/Cooper.  

 

[vanswey]

Thanks Gally. I went with the trade. I’m concerned that Washington visited with 30 RB’s pre draft and drafted a RB. I was thinking that Saquon has a lower floor than Gibson but Saquon has a higher ceiling than Gibson so I went with the high risk high reward option. I ended up getting Barkley, 1:09, 3:10, 3:11 and a 2023 3rd.