Go on record. Give a thumbs up/down on some controversial (1 Viewer)

[Chaos Commish]

Brady Quinn - Jamarcus Russell - Ted Ginn - Dwayne Jarrett - Levi Brown - Leon Hall -

Brady Quinn - Jamarcus Russell - Ted Ginn - Dwayne Jarrett - Levi Brown - Leon Hall - Quinn and Russell deserve franchise grades.Ginn and Jarrett both seem underrated lately and both will be good.Brown and Hall are both overrated. Brown needs time to be good and the thumbs down is too harsh. I was just being contrary to Rounders there. I don't think Brown is worth a top 15 pick this year though. Anytime after that is fine. Hall can't cover Ginn or Jarrett, but he looks good and tries hard.eta for better accuracy... Quinn - Brown - Brown will be sloppy for a couple years but the the potential is solid. Quinn's last game is still bothering me, and I have seen a dozen or more of his games.

 

[Cecil Lammey]

Brady Quinn -

Jamarcus Russell -

Ted Ginn -

Dwayne Jarrett -

Levi Brown -

Leon Hall -

 

[coolnerd]

Brady Quinn - Think is in the range of good, but needs help QBs. Have trouble getting excited about those typeshigh in the draft

Jamarcus Russell - total boom or bust player in my mind. Not what I would want to bet my franchise on unless I totally sure. I am not.

Ted Ginn - I think straightline speed is overrated. I have been all over the place in terms of his actually route running, ability get open and catch. Seems like if he hits he will really hit, just don't like the percentages.

Dwayne Jarrett - probably not as much as some, I think he will just be solid as a pro.

Levi Brown - Has many of the attributes you want, but can't ignore the lapses in technique. If he gets good coaching I think Levi will be fine, it not ouch.

Leon Hall - Productive and displays more speed and athletic ability than originally though. Not extremely high, but more positive than negative

 

[Andy Dufresne]

Bump.

Anyone we should add?

Anyone want to change an opinion?

 

[Fallerjw]

Brady Quinn - will be good if he doesn't end up behind the Browns cursed line. I actually like him and think he'll be good over time.

Jamarcus Russell - I think he has a ton of potential, but probably won't do well if he goes to Oakland.

Ted Ginn - as a #1 WR as a #2 - depends on the team. Won't do well as a #2 in Atlanta, for example. #3 great additions to Arizona, Indy, Carolina, etc.

Dwayne Jarrett - I think he'll do alright in the NFL. Not a big but, he'll do fine

Levi Brown - I'm not sold. I don't think he's a pro bowl caliber player

Leon Hall - faster than people thought he was. I still think Chris Houston will be the best CB in this draft.

 

[Fallerjw]

Bump.Anyone we should add?Anyone want to change an opinion?

Branch - Would be a great DT in a 4-3 defense for many years. Poszlusny - faster than he seems, very productive and hard working. Willis - I'm not sure about him. I thought he'd be ok, but he seems to be getting a lot of hype recently and could start smelling like a bust. Seems like a lot of the recent rise is coming from his speed. That's not always a good sign.

 

[stevegamer]

Brady Quinn -

Jamarcus Russell -

Ted Ginn -

Dwayne Jarrett -

Levi Brown -

Leon Hall - :whoosh:

Quinn & Russell will be okay, but not great. The is relative to draft spot.

I think Ginn is a very good returner, but not so great a WR, so he's about on average.

Brown will be a solid but not star lineman, the very definition of

I think Jarrett is underrated right know, and is being unfairly compared to BMW.

Not impressed with Hall.

 

[Andy Dufresne]

It will be interesting to see if the guys highlighted here get more playing time as the season progresses. Still too early to tell with most of these guys.

Those giving a to Jarrett look like they were right. How have Brown & Hall looked?